You are here: Home | Forum | So much for the views held here
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most of the discussions, articles and other free features. By joining our Virgin Media community you will have full access to all discussions, be able to view and post threads, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload your own images/photos, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please join our community today.
I've no idea if I'm a Right Winger or a Left Winger, what are the characteristics I should look for in order to be assigned a label?
Left Wing = Support a bigger state, more government intervention and maybe more socially progressive.
Right Wing = Support a smaller state, less government intervention and maybe less socially progressive.
Although it's not that simple. I.E Old Labour tended to be less socially progressive but supported a bigger state. Some people on the populist right also think that way now. You also get people who want a much smaller state and are socially progressive in that the government shouldn't get involved in the personal lives of anyone.
Services: Humane elimination of all common Internet pests
Posts: 38,078
Re: So much for the views held here
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carth
right . . .
so what does 'support a smaller/bigger state mean exactly?
Are we about to dump Scotland and Wales, or take over the whole of Ireland?
It means the extent to which the State regulates/owns infrastructure and services, not the number of square miles under government control.
Quote:
Please also explain 'Socially Progressive' too, because for years I've just seen society go backwards.
I'm wondering if the Raving Looneys are the party for me, are they Left, Right, or out of this World?
Socially progressive is supposed to mean advocating for social justice, equality and civil rights. Whether it actually achieves any of that is debatable.
Services: RG41: 1Gig VOLT
Rutland: Gigaclear 400/400
Posts: 12,322
Re: So much for the views held here
Quote:
Originally Posted by Damien
Left Wing = Support a bigger state, more government intervention and maybe more socially progressive.
Right Wing = Support a smaller state, less government intervention and maybe less socially progressive.
Although it's not that simple. I.E Old Labour tended to be less socially progressive but supported a bigger state. Some people on the populist right also think that way now. You also get people who want a much smaller state and are socially progressive in that the government shouldn't get involved in the personal lives of anyone.
LEFT = Support a bigger state, more government intervention and maybe more socially progressive. (As per Damien's Left Wing).
LEFT WING = LEFT + nationalise what you can; maximal governmental intervention; include migration within socially progressive policies; totally screw the rich (whoever that is defined as being). Oh - gas the Tories
RIGHT = Support a smaller state, less government intervention and maybe less socially progressive. (As per Damien's Right Wing).
RIGHT WING = ???? It's certainly not going to be RIGHT+. According to Starmer, it's anyone who supports demonstrations against the Connolly woman who tweeted something deemed to be racist in the heat of her distraught moment after the Southport murders. Even @Russ has a difficulty defining "right wing".
As Chris posted in October ‘22, the second-last time you raised this subject
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sephiroth View Post
We seem to understand what "lefties" means, but "right wing" needs more definition. In my lifetime, it meant fascism.
The Political Compass remains one of the best resources for teasing out these definitions. This is their exapliner, well worth 5 minutes of your time:
Long story short, if you try to describe economic and social politics in terms of “left” and “right” simultaneously you will come unstuck. You need to define someone’s position as economically left or right and socially authoritarian or libertarian. And one position by no means pre-ordains the other.
__________________ Thank you for calling the Abyss.
If you have called to scream, please press 1 to be transferred to the Void, or press 2 to begin your stare. If my post is in bold and this colour, it's a Moderator Request.
Services: RG41: 1Gig VOLT
Rutland: Gigaclear 400/400
Posts: 12,322
Re: So much for the views held here
I'm trying to get Russ to define "right wing", which is a term he used in relation to GB News. He framed a question around that so, before I can answer him properly, I need to know what he means by "right wing". Russ has avoided obliging me with his definition.
I'm not surprised - it's not easy. Past "right wing" has been founded on the Mussolini/Hitler model. But that was then. I've noted what Hugh has researched:
Quote:
Long story short, if you try to describe economic and social politics in terms of “left” and “right” simultaneously you will come unstuck. You need to define someone’s position as economically left or right and socially authoritarian or libertarian. And one position by no means pre-ordains the other.
No wonder Russ cannot justify his "overtly right wing" description of GB News (and by association - Reform UK).
I'm trying to get Russ to define "right wing", which is a term he used in relation to GB News. He framed a question around that so, before I can answer him properly, I need to know what he means by "right wing". Russ has avoided obliging me with his definition.
I'm not surprised - it's not easy. Past "right wing" has been founded on the Mussolini/Hitler model. But that was then. I've noted what Hugh has researched:
No wonder Russ cannot justify his "overtly right wing" description of GB News (and by association - Reform UK).
It really doesn’t.
The Encyclopaedia Brittanica dictionary says
Quote:
Britannica Dictionary definition of RIGHT WING
[singular]
: the part of a political group that consists of people who support conservative or traditional ideas and policies : the part of a political group that belongs to or supports the Right
Quote:
right–wing
Britannica Dictionary definition of RIGHT–WING
: of, relating to, or belonging to the political Right : having or supporting ideas and policies that are associated with conservative groups
Also from Brittanica
What’s your definition of right wing? (please don’t default to your previous standard answer of "its well understood"…
__________________ Thank you for calling the Abyss.
If you have called to scream, please press 1 to be transferred to the Void, or press 2 to begin your stare. If my post is in bold and this colour, it's a Moderator Request.
That has to be out of date now though unless it is the American system where Liberal means something totally different to here. How are the far left Radical ? I thought they were meant to be passive
__________________
Is your muffin buttered? Would you like me to assign someone to butter your muffin?
Join CF
You are here: 
Baby, I was born this way.
