Forum Articles
  Welcome back Join CF
You are here You are here: Home | Forum | Three Person IVF - A step too far?

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most of the discussions, articles and other free features. By joining our Virgin Media community you will have full access to all discussions, be able to view and post threads, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload your own images/photos, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please join our community today.


Welcome to Cable Forum
Go Back   Cable Forum > General Discussion > Science & Technology
Register FAQ Community Calendar

Three Person IVF - A step too far?
View Poll Results: Three Person IVF - Should it be allowed
Yes 5 41.67%
No 5 41.67%
Don't Know 1 8.33%
Don't Care 1 8.33%
Voters: 12. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 17-09-2012, 17:46   #1
MovedGoalPosts
Inactive
 
MovedGoalPosts's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: 127.0.0.1
Age: 62
Posts: 15,868
MovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny stars
MovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny stars
Three Person IVF - A step too far?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-19597856

Genetic modification to allow parents to mix a second woman's DNA to their own mix to get around potential genetic defects. Whilst I understand a desire to have healthy children surely this is playing with nature in a way that we cannot understand the ramifications for future generations. Surely it can't be right?
MovedGoalPosts is offline   Reply With Quote
Advertisement
Old 17-09-2012, 17:55   #2
BenMcr
Inactive
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Manchester
Services: 360 x2, Maxit TV, Sky Sports and Sky Cinema. Gig1
Posts: 17,929
BenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny stars
BenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

Definately a step too far
BenMcr is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-09-2012, 18:51   #3
Vieil Homme
Inactive
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 461
Vieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud of
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

Not if your wife has a genetic code that is slightly wrong, that would cause a problem with your child.

We are talking about mitochondrial DNA where a small amount of genetic material from a fertilised egg ie the mother's and father's is put into another egg from a donor with healthy mitochondrial.

It would prevent certain medical conditions but means that the resulting child would have small amount of DNA from the donor So paternity tests could be a problem.

We already take a fertilised egg and place it in a donors womb, this is just one step further and its not to give you a designer baby far from it.

Prof Winston talked of this 25 years ago and only today we are talking about again, it may be another 25 years before its accepted.

My view is as long as its used to overcome genetic problems its not a step too far.

It would be good if there was a poll on this question.
Vieil Homme is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-09-2012, 19:02   #4
MovedGoalPosts
Inactive
 
MovedGoalPosts's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: 127.0.0.1
Age: 62
Posts: 15,868
MovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny stars
MovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

A fertilised egg placed in another womb doesnt change the DNA and genetics of the egg?

Messing with the genetic make up is going to some to be a "designer baby". Just because the scientific advances might enable something to be achieved, doesn't mean it should be permitted.

It might seem harsh, but perhaps there are times when our medical knowledge should be used to determine that risks are too great and you shouldn't have a child, not to be playing around with stuff that could have unkown consequences in the futuer. As the article points out, once the amended genetics are in existence, it won't be possible to prevent their further dissemination and dilution into the wider population.

I'll add a poll ....
MovedGoalPosts is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-09-2012, 22:41   #5
Vieil Homme
Inactive
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 461
Vieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud of
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

Yes, I do know a fertilised egg placed in another womb doesn't change the DNA and genetics of the egg but again it was said they were going too far was the point I was trying to make......

Believe it or not the same arguments were being put forward 25 years ago regarding Test tube Babies and the way they were manipulating sperm to get the stronger ones and removing the slow and double tail sperm. The stronger ones were then used for IVF

34 years down the line test tube babies do not have health problems above that of children conceived in coitus.

25 years ago my wife and I were on the test tube baby programme at Hammersmith Hospital and later on became a volunteer helping out, some very funny stories and sadly more sad ones.

Thanks for adding the poll
Vieil Homme is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-09-2012, 22:41   #6
Maggy
The Invisible Woman
Cable Forum Mod
 
Maggy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: between Portsmouth and Southampton.
Age: 74
Services: VM XL TV,50 MB VM BB,VM landline, Tivo
Posts: 40,379
Maggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden aura
Maggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden aura
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

How many children are affected in this manner?
__________________
Hell is empty and all the devils are here. Shakespeare..
Maggy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-09-2012, 22:58   #7
Vieil Homme
Inactive
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 461
Vieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud of
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Maggy J View Post
How many children are affected in this manner?
While I'm no expert I would say how long is a bit of string. This would help many women have full term healthy babies.

At the moment there are many babies born with inherited defects in their mitochondrial DNA, the effects of which can be very severe, or even fatal, depending on which cells are affected. If those faulty cells are exchanged for good ones it can only be good.

In answer to your question I think its near 1 in 5000 that are affected but don't hold me to that figure i'm a plumber not a doctor or nurse

so thats about 140 ish babies per year that could be saved per year.....
Vieil Homme is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18-09-2012, 09:57   #8
MovedGoalPosts
Inactive
 
MovedGoalPosts's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: 127.0.0.1
Age: 62
Posts: 15,868
MovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny stars
MovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny starsMovedGoalPosts has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vieil Homme View Post
Yes, I do know a fertilised egg placed in another womb doesn't change the DNA and genetics of the egg but again it was said they were going too far was the point I was trying to make......

Believe it or not the same arguments were being put forward 25 years ago regarding Test tube Babies and the way they were manipulating sperm to get the stronger ones and removing the slow and double tail sperm. The stronger ones were then used for IVF
Big difference. The test tube baby process is simply assisting nature. It isn't messing with the fundamental genetics of one male, one female for fertilisation. Three person IVF is adding something that just cannot occur in any natural process.
MovedGoalPosts is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18-09-2012, 10:45   #9
BenMcr
Inactive
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Manchester
Services: 360 x2, Maxit TV, Sky Sports and Sky Cinema. Gig1
Posts: 17,929
BenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny stars
BenMcr has a pair of shiny starsBenMcr has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vieil Homme View Post
If those faulty cells are exchanged for good ones it can only be good.
It may be good for that single child, but who knows what the longer term effects are once that DNA enters into the genetic pool?
BenMcr is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18-09-2012, 15:12   #10
Vieil Homme
Inactive
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 461
Vieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud ofVieil Homme has much to be proud of
Re: Three Person IVF - A step too far?

From the article link posted :
Quote:
1) Two embryos are fertilised with sperm creating an embryo from the intended parents and another from the donors. 2) The pronuclei, which contain genetic information, are removed from both embryos but only the parents' is kept 3) A healthy embryo is created by adding the parents' pronuclei to the donor embryo, which is finally implanted into the womb.
This would give healthy children free of a potentially fatal genetic disease. Future generations of those families would also be free of the original genetic fault. This could have legal implications for future generations but not health issues due to the original transfer of cells.

No genetic engineering has taken place but cells have been replaced giving a healthy embryo to a couple.

If the cells had been engineered in a lab I would think that was a step too far with our present knowledge but the next 50 years it will be common place.

For the last 20 years our health service have been implanting stem cells from placenta obtained after a C section. The IVF in the UK have stricter controls than other procedures such as stem cell therapy which treat such diseases as, among many others: Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s disease, auto-immune disorders, stroke, lupus. muscular dystrophy and cerebral palsy.

Have you seen they have invented a needleless syringe LINK
Vieil Homme is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:38.


Server: lithium.zmnt.uk
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum