[Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
11-09-2008, 12:52
|
#226
|
|
cf.mega poster
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 4,952
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
I should have anticipated this, I'm going now so I'm not going to respond to all of this but I will address this:
Quote:
|
Finally, this device is allegedly attempting to simulate the suposed creation of the universe and is simply mimicing daily occurances already going on naturally but in a suposedly controlled enviroment, so why not go and observe the real enviroment as that will certainly provide more factual results than any man made one ? And if this is not currently possible then just perhaps mankind is not yet ready to make such observations and develop any subsequent research or draw any conclusions from it, or perhaps these scientists are actually frightened of what they may discover if they were to study the real enviroment.
|
The environment i.e. the universe is philosophically assumed to have universal laws, this is supported by the fact planes don't fall out of the sky just because they exit british airspace.
Many of the reactions take place in the upper atmosphere and we can't lug this thing into the upper atmosphere and with the high speed data cables and all http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...RN_feb2007.jpg
Controlled experiments are needed simply because laws of physics are simply input output functions, you put something in and get a different thing out, you can't establish what the relation is if you can't experiment with what's going in. Furthermore you can't establish the energy a particle has without robbing it of that energy, so picking a random particle in space wouldn't help as you would have to stop it to see what its energy was at which point its no good to collide with.
Any reference to God is media spin. As I said before, whoever coined "God particle" needs to be shot.
If nature is a cult then existence is a cult to which we are all part of.
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 13:57
|
#227
|
|
cf.mega pornstar
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 19,541
|
Re: Lawsuit over CERN's Large Hadron Collider
Quote:
Originally Posted by downquark1
Dam that's after my project is due in.
|
You could always tell them it got eaten by a mini black hole
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 14:09
|
#228
|
|
Remoaner
Cable Forum Mod
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 33,041
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
A long post, I'll address something else:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by NitroNutter
The judgement made allowing this device to be powered on has removed the free will of many with major concerns no matter how unfounded those concerns be. This experiment does not provide any clear cut positive benefits, everything about it is a 'maybe'. So it maybe good, it maybe bad, it maybe super beneficial and no matter how remote it could be catastrophic. To postpone the turning on of the device would have had no possible negative or positive effects, to turn it on has thrown the fear of possible irreversible negative effects potentially on a global or larger scale into the minds of many, therefore in the interest of sound legal and humanitarian judgement alone the powering up of the device should have been postponed.
|
Wrong on so many levels, First of all there were no major valid concerns. Just a hysterical public who presume to know more about Physics than those who have PhDs and experience in the field. There was a safety report, and these people know what they are doing. They also have a desire for world not to explode.
Also, Scientific process demands we explore the unknown and attempt to learn more about the Universe. We do not need a "clear cut positive benefits", the pursuit of knowledge, learning something completely new about our world, is a massive benefit in itself. The Space Race could be deemed pointless, but it's technological advances are being used as we speak (computers). We are learning about the building blocks of the Universe, imagine the possibility for the future of science and technology.
We can't pause Science because people who don't understand it are concerned about something they read which suggested it's dangerous.
Quote:
|
Even if this is not a world ending device it does not mean that as we allow science to continue unquestioned we will not become victims to its biggest belief which is its own conjoined and differing delusion of grandure thats accompanying each individuals delusions of grandure.
|
What do you mean 'unquestioned'. They are doing the questioning. How can you question scientists without knowing the science?
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 15:04
|
#229
|
|
Inactive
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: <-- Not All there ? Knock Knock
Services: You cannot afford me!!!
Posts: 1,139
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Quote:
Originally Posted by downquark1
I should have anticipated this, I'm going now so I'm not going to respond to all of this but I will address this:
The environment i.e. the universe is philosophically assumed to have universal laws, this is supported by the fact planes don't fall out of the sky just because they exit british airspace.
Many of the reactions take place in the upper atmosphere and we can't lug this thing into the upper atmosphere and with the high speed data cables and all http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...RN_feb2007.jpg
Controlled experiments are needed simply because laws of physics are simply input output functions, you put something in and get a different thing out, you can't establish what the relation is if you can't experiment with what's going in. Furthermore you can't establish the energy a particle has without robbing it of that energy, so picking a random particle in space wouldn't help as you would have to stop it to see what its energy was at which point its no good to collide with.
Any reference to God is media spin. As I said before, whoever coined "God particle" needs to be shot.
If nature is a cult then existence is a cult to which we are all part of.
|
That just proves the blinkered view of our society, I never said 'nature is a cult', however you seem to have misinterpreted my words to arrive to that conclusion. This is exactly what I mean about this incessantly deluded and all to often automatic viewpoint everything revolves around us, somehow I seriously doubt humanity is the centre of the universe and to me the human race as a race to nature is about as insignificant as any other race that can very easily become extinct without nature really being that concerned over the loss.
Wether humanity existed or not I personally would expect there to be something going on, therefore some form of a natural sequence of events amounting to a form of evolution of some description would likely exist without the need for humanity so while the word 'nature' may not exist, nature itself which in universal terms would still be everything and so could not be a cult, the term cult is a word used to describe a section of a society so one can safely assume when refering to a 'cult' and 'humans' in the same sentence it is the human actions of particular sections and groups within it which will generally hold certain beliefs or disbeliefs that form the various cults, ie christianity, islam, hindu, budhism, atheism and science, all religous or non-religous sections of society are just a variety of cults with some differing opinions, and when it comes to inaccuracies, lies, destruction and wasted losses of human life science is by far not the angel of cults.
It still stands that if mankind is incapable of collecting the data it wants from the natural enviroment where they could maximise accuracy of the research then it may be that mankind is not yet ready to collect this information, to do it in a controlled enviroment is not the same and will as ever produce innacurate results which can and will lead to false and incorrect conclusions which may well be the biggest catastrophe derived from the experiment depending on how any of the information is used or perhaps a better term would be misused.
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 15:10
|
#230
|
|
Remoaner
Cable Forum Mod
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 33,041
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Quote:
|
It still stands that if mankind is incapable of collecting the data it wants from the natural enviroment where they could maximise accuracy of the research then it may be that mankind is not yet ready to collect this information, to do it in a controlled enviroment is not the same and will as ever produce innacurate results which can and will lead to false and incorrect conclusions which may well be the biggest catastrophe derived from the experiment depending on how any of the information is used or perhaps a better term would be misused.
|
They have been planning this for 30 years, I think they have a good idea of which is the best method of collecting data. I don't know what the problem you have is but Science has done some wonderful things which obviously shows the scientific method works.
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 15:32
|
#231
|
|
-
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Somewhere
Services: Virgin for TV and Internet, BT for phone
Posts: 26,546
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Quote:
Originally Posted by NitroNutter
It still stands that if mankind is incapable of collecting the data it wants from the natural enviroment where they could maximise accuracy of the research then it may be that mankind is not yet ready to collect this information, to do it in a controlled enviroment is not the same and will as ever produce innacurate results which can and will lead to false and incorrect conclusions which may well be the biggest catastrophe derived from the experiment depending on how any of the information is used or perhaps a better term would be misused.
|
So you have decided that 100s of years of experiments are invalid? Including those which resulted in the technology that enabled you to post here?
Apologies if I am incorrect here, but you seem to have little understanding of how science works.
The reasons that experiments are conducted in controlled environments are simple
1) Outside variables may influence the outcome and therefore render the results invalid.
2) For a result to be valid, it needs to be repeatable. If outside variables are introduced, these can influence the results and make them unrepeatable.
When the experiment has been conducted successfully, they have established a baseline result and can repeat the experiment while varying the conditions.
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 15:51
|
#232
|
|
Remoaner
Cable Forum Mod
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 33,041
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
You know, around 20 years ago. Tim Berners-Lee developed the World-Wide-Web at CERN, the reason we can have this debate from out chairs on a simple to use forum. They developed this amazing technology, which has transformed business and communication and they gave it away. For Free. They did not sell it, ask for licence fees or even impose limitations on what it could be used for. They gave it to the world and moved on to discover news things.
Think about how much money the internet has generated thanks to their work before complaining about the $5 Billion they spent trying to progress scientific knowledge. As well as dismissing the motives of the Scientists, who really do want to learn and are not concerned with "playing god".
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 16:01
|
#233
|
|
The Invisible Woman
Cable Forum Mod
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: between Portsmouth and Southampton.
Age: 74
Services: VM XL TV,50 MB VM BB,VM landline, Tivo
Posts: 40,379
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Quote:
Originally Posted by NitroNutter
I am glad to say this machine has already proven wonders. It has proven that the legal system of mankind is as flawed as that of its new found fashionable cult/religion of science.
The judgement made allowing this device to be powered on has removed the free will of many with major concerns no matter how unfounded those concens be. This experiment does not provide any clear cut positive benefits, everything about it is a 'maybe'. So it maybe good, it maybe bad, it maybe super beneficial and no matter how remote it could be catestrophic. To postpone the turning on of the deivce would have had no possible negative or positive effects, to turn it on has thrown the fear of possible irreversible negative effects potenitally on a global or larger scale into the minds of many, therefore in the interest of sound legal and humanitarian judgement alone the powering up of the device should have been postponed.
A dealer of crack just as any salesperson or other representative is not going to tell you the negatives in the hopes of gaining a sale. They will allways spout of the positives including any based on suposition.
Why does science allways throw the 'god argument' out when trying to support its case, its as bad and as abusive of human nature as the other foot and is simply used to gain like minded fevered support from atheists and evolutionists as their religous counterparts regardless of what knowledge its hopeful followers may have on the current debatable subject which in many cases may not be a great deal, wether there is a god or not is a matter for personal preference of belief and opinion, the turning on of this machine has potentially forced this particular denomination of the scientific cult onto those that did not wish it to occur, proof that under the science of man cult free will does not exist. Also when science has such a definitive view on the non-existence of god why does it continually insist on trying to play at being one ?
No matter how far forward science advances it will never be able to unequivocally disprove or prove the existence of god, this is a very simple fact. To do that would require his/her prescence in a perceivable form and that is one thing mankind really does not want to happen, the lacking of this presence or perhaps certain persons perceptions of it's non-existence merely coludes with other human perceptions to form a belief or disbelief. Any abuse towards others that can occur be it as a result of personal beliefs wether those beliefs be infavour of the existince of a supreme entity or not is nothing but a flaw of the individual person, science is subject to the exact same human misperceptions that all cults followed by the various sections in humanity carry. Science is never definitive, its results will always be open to adjustment and amendments, unfortunately todays science has to be at the most dangerous level it has ever attained, this is for 2 main reasons, one the power it has at its disposal, the fact that this power is in the hands of humanity which can and will draw conclusions from minimul and grossly incomplete research if desired for a wide variety of reasons, therefore the margin of error today is also at its largest ever.
There are other considerations which should be taken into account in this device. Religionists that have extreme agendas or even other nations that do not carry a highly religously motivated political agenda could easily turn this into a just cause. Please can someone tell me what fool allowed such a device of this magnitude and its so obviously potential political, religous and therefore military ramifications to be built in the vicinity of 'Geneva' ?
Also, this machine may have only cost 20 years and near to 5 billion to create, but it carries one very hefty power drain on the worlds fuel supplies, it carries a cost of some 15 million a year in fuel requirements and thats at todays cost. At a basic guess this is chewing the juice that could supply some 15,000 westernised homes or so and all in the name of an experiment which may return zilch thats useful. This gross waste of energy will be one that aids in increasing prices for everyone including our elderly and infirm at such a time when we do not need to have any further cause for extra increases, more increases on this domestic cost will mount to a form of euthenasia as the elderly and infirm start dying off due to unaffordable supplies. This is before any consideration of the subsequently large carbon footprint it will be contributing which funnily enough seems to be of great concern to some parts of our sciencific cult. Even if this is not a world ending device it does not mean that as we allow science to continue unquestioned we will not become victims to its biggest belief which is its own conjoined and differing delusion of grandure thats accompanying each individuals delusions of grandure.
One of the key statments used in defence of the device is 'it is doing nothing more than what nature is doing daily' should be taken as it stands, if you dont belive in god then you most probably belive in nature and evolution which while on an individual level nature may not be considered as a 'supreme being' of any particular description it is not without significant power well over the power of man or any of its cults and religions including the one known as science, therefore if nothing else the power of nature should not be taken so lightly, it maybe there is no god to create the contents of the universe but that does not mean there is no power within its natural creation and evolution, and nature is not always very nice or so predictable in the way it reacts.
Finally, this device is allegedly attempting to simulate the suposed creation of the universe and is simply mimicing daily occurances already going on naturally but in a suposedly controlled enviroment, so why not go and observe the real enviroment as that will certainly provide more factual results than any man made one ? And if this is not currently possible then just perhaps mankind is not yet ready to make such observations and develop any subsequent research or draw any conclusions from it, or perhaps these scientists are actually frightened of what they may discover if they were to study the real enviroment.
Every reaction is an action, every action carries consquence, and in my personal opinion this is one where man is perhaps making a mistake of running before it can crawl.
While I do not actively support any church I do believe that the worst kind of zealousy has to be that which is founded on atheism as it seems to be providing a gross intolerance of anything but that of a personal agenda with just as flawed justifications for the actions of its flock as any religion carries and with what appears to be a greatly diminishing degree of conscience.
|
Well IF you must drag religion into it...
If a God made us the way we are then he is responsible for making us as curious as we are...Surely an omnipotent being would have foreseen that eventually we would try to work out how our universe works so maybe we are doing just what God wants us to do?To achieve our full potential?Your way would have us stuck back in the stone age.
__________________
Hell is empty and all the devils are here. Shakespeare..
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 16:09
|
#234
|
|
cf.mega poster
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 4,952
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Quote:
Originally Posted by NitroNutter
That just proves the blinkered view of our society, I never said 'nature is a cult', however you seem to have misinterpreted my words to arrive to that conclusion. This is exactly what I mean about this incessantly deluded and all to often automatic viewpoint everything revolves around us, somehow I seriously doubt humanity is the centre of the universe and to me the human race as a race to nature is about as insignificant as any other race that can very easily become extinct without nature really being that concerned over the loss.
|
This I completely agree on.
Quote:
|
It still stands that if mankind is incapable of collecting the data it wants from the natural enviroment where they could maximise accuracy of the research then it may be that mankind is not yet ready to collect this information, to do it in a controlled enviroment is not the same and will as ever produce innacurate results which can and will lead to false and incorrect conclusions which may well be the biggest catastrophe derived from the experiment depending on how any of the information is used or perhaps a better term would be misused.
|
This is retardedness. 1st of all we define nature as the physical universe, I am in the physical universe whether I am outside, in space or in my laboratory. If I boil water in my glass beaker over a burner the same thing is happening at me boiling outside over a camp fire. The difference is outside wind will be redirecting the heat almost randomly making it harder to take accurate measurements.
Back to the LHC, another simple reason why we can't measure the existing reactions is taking the atlas detector out side will flood the whole thing with tracks of data making it impossible to see what result came from what particle. There are muons passing through you right now, from the reactions in the atmosphere, there are weak radioactive elements in the earth shooting things out. How can we be expected to work out which is caused by which unless we can control the conditions?
Are you by any chance Melanie Phillips?
|
|
|
11-09-2008, 20:07
|
#235
|
|
laeva recumbens anguis
Cable Forum Mod
Join Date: Jun 2006
Age: 70
Services: Premiere Collection
Posts: 45,189
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Charlie Stross put it best (imho) Link
"We. Are. Not. Going. To. Die. On. Wednesday.
The maximum energy the particles generated by the LHC (7TeV) get up to is many orders of magnitude below the maximum energy of cosmic rays that hit the Earth's upper atmosphere from space every fricking day. None of them have created black holes and gobbled up the planet, or turned us all into strange matter. Nor have they done ditto to any cosmic bodies we can see, such as planets or stars. Therefore the world isn't going end when they switch on the LHC on Wednesday. QED.
Joking is all very well, but please, can we not be spreading the FUD and scaring people needlessly? The current climate of superstitious dread with respect to the sciences is bad enough as it is ..."
__________________
Thank you for calling the Abyss.
If you have called to scream, please press 1 to be transferred to the Void, or press 2 to begin your stare.
If my post is in bold and this colour, it's a Moderator Request.
|
|
|
12-09-2008, 10:34
|
#237
|
|
Inactive
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Portsmouth
Age: 59
Services: XL BB, XL TV, V+
Posts: 742
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
very interes..
|
|
|
12-09-2008, 11:52
|
#238
|
|
Inactive
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Merseyside
Age: 38
Services: BT Infinity Option 2, HH5, synced at maximum 80Mbps/20Mbps.
Posts: 2,221
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Quote:
Originally Posted by punky
|
Yey! We all died!
|
|
|
12-09-2008, 13:21
|
#239
|
|
laeva recumbens anguis
Cable Forum Mod
Join Date: Jun 2006
Age: 70
Services: Premiere Collection
Posts: 45,189
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
What do you mean we?
Obviously the LHC version of the Rapture - only those who believed it was going to end the world got "uplifted".
__________________
Thank you for calling the Abyss.
If you have called to scream, please press 1 to be transferred to the Void, or press 2 to begin your stare.
If my post is in bold and this colour, it's a Moderator Request.
|
|
|
12-09-2008, 13:30
|
#240
|
|
Inactive
Join Date: Jun 2003
Age: 45
Posts: 14,750
|
Re: [Update] CERN's Large Hadron Collider goes live
Quote:
Originally Posted by AbyssUnderground
Yey! We all died!
|
I think heaven is overrated
Anyone know where Johnny Cash is hiding out?
|
|
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 12:34.
|