Forum Articles
  Welcome back Join CF
You are here You are here: Home | Forum | Sky goes terrestrial [Merged]

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most of the discussions, articles and other free features. By joining our Virgin Media community you will have full access to all discussions, be able to view and post threads, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload your own images/photos, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please join our community today.


Welcome to Cable Forum
Go Back   Cable Forum > Alternatives to Virgin Media > Other DTV Services Discussion
Register FAQ Community Calendar

Sky goes terrestrial [Merged]
Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 10-02-2007, 20:21   #31
Chrysalis
cf.mega poster
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 12,060
Chrysalis is cast in bronzeChrysalis is cast in bronzeChrysalis is cast in bronzeChrysalis is cast in bronze
Chrysalis is cast in bronze
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

its a free service I dont see how people can complain as sky have the right to make people pay for sky sports news, sky subscribers have to pay for it.
Chrysalis is offline   Reply With Quote
Advertisement
Old 11-02-2007, 01:40   #32
pedantic
Inactive
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Swinton
Services: O2 standard
Posts: 2,499
pedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronze
pedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronzepedantic is cast in bronze
Send a message via Yahoo to pedantic
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

I think this does raise a few questions, if this move does go forward. Looking at the Freeview listings, there are a few channels that are also listed on the Sky platform. How many more channels does Sky intend on removing, and then replacing with subscription channels. This latest move by Sky, could well be the start of a snowball effect. And the term "Freeview" would become something of a farce, when describing the platform. Sky should have been told, if they are going to offer channels on the Freeview platform, they should remain free.
pedantic is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-02-2007, 11:32   #33
Paul K
Inactive
 
Paul K's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Essex innit
Age: 52
Services: Sky HD + 16Mb ADSL BT Telephone
Posts: 15,735
Paul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered stars
Paul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered starsPaul K is seeing silvered stars
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by Chrysalis View Post
its a free service I dont see how people can complain as sky have the right to make people pay for sky sports news, sky subscribers have to pay for it.
It is NOT a free service if you HAVE to buy Skys' particular set top box. If it were just a "Top Up TV" scenario then why not allow people to use the boxes already out there with card slots?
This is nothing more than Sky trying to increase their revenue now that the switch to digital only is getting nearer.
Paul K is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-02-2007, 15:54   #34
d0pey
Inactive
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 90
d0pey is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by SnoopZ View Post
But if Sky remove the channels and turn them into pay only it's just making Freeview worse as a free platform. It's actually quite good at the moment considering it's free, but it's at it's capacity and can't have many more channels added until analogue switch off. I'm seriously hoping Sky aren't aloud to do this.
I do not see how to you can Sky HAS to give free channels for the general publics benefit. At the end of the day they are a company.

---------- Post added at 15:54 ---------- Previous post was at 15:52 ----------

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul View Post
It is NOT a free service if you HAVE to buy Skys' particular set top box. If it were just a "Top Up TV" scenario then why not allow people to use the boxes already out there with card slots?
This is nothing more than Sky trying to increase their revenue now that the switch to digital only is getting nearer.
It is because of them using MPEG4 to allow more channels.
d0pey is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-02-2007, 16:04   #35
SnoopZ
CF Resident Dog
 
SnoopZ's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Services: Zen FTTP 910
Posts: 16,470
SnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny stars
SnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny starsSnoopZ has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by d0pey View Post
I do not see how to you can Sky HAS to give free channels for the general publics benefit. At the end of the day they are a company.
My point was Sky is wrecking FREEview by removing the free channels and replacing them with channels that aren't free, which in my opinion is not good for Freeview as it doesn't have any free space left for new free channels, until analogue switch off.

And i didn't say Sky HAS to give free channels.
__________________
F1 Race Schedule and Results
https://gridhub.one/?series=F1
SnoopZ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-02-2007, 21:04   #36
etccarmageddon
Inactive
 
etccarmageddon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Manchester
Posts: 5,638
etccarmageddon has a nice shiny star
etccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny star
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by d0pey View Post
I do not see how to you can Sky HAS to give free channels for the general publics benefit. At the end of the day they are a company. ....
it depends if the channel has enough revenue via adverts.
etccarmageddon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2007, 14:59   #37
Chrysalis
cf.mega poster
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 12,060
Chrysalis is cast in bronzeChrysalis is cast in bronzeChrysalis is cast in bronzeChrysalis is cast in bronze
Chrysalis is cast in bronze
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul View Post
It is NOT a free service if you HAVE to buy Skys' particular set top box. If it were just a "Top Up TV" scenario then why not allow people to use the boxes already out there with card slots?
This is nothing more than Sky trying to increase their revenue now that the switch to digital only is getting nearer.
Sorry am I wrong freeview isnt free subscription?
Chrysalis is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-02-2007, 23:58   #38
info4u
Inactive
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 122
info4u is on a distinguished roadinfo4u is on a distinguished road
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

It will be quite interesting to see that happen...

1) VM have MPEG2 to but its HD which makes MPEG4. This is reletivly new technology which is rendered as useless unless you have an HD ready TV.

2) The fact its FREEVIEW brings a great financial risk to Sky
Look at what happened to ONDIGITAL (ITV DIGITAL), they went broke because of pirate cards being created, this happends then you know there is going to be problems for them and they will have to stop.

Freeview dont really charge for anything therefore they dont have to worry about people robbing or nicking the service for free.

3) another desperate move from sky
Going back to ITV move they made on NTL:Telewest, No Teleport functions, No filmflex, no HD and 2 Decoder STBs with 80hrs recording.
Only several HD channels (Again until HD has properly kicked off in the TV market its pretty poor)

Same as when DVD players where first made, those who rushed to buy them found them selves with...

1) Not a big variety of movies
2) Poor technology compared to todays
3) High prices compared to now

In 2000 I purchases a ALBA multiregional DVD from Toys R Us £160.00
Now a DVD player can be purchased for £30.00 (6yrs on)
Imagine back in 1997 when they where brand new

This sort of thing puts people off from rushing to using the new technology
but it will kick off within the next 2yrs without dought properly since it has been running for about 2-3yrs making HD ready TVs and advertising it mainly in the last 1-2yrs.

For years NTL and Telewest had advantages on Sky by being able to provide Broadband Phone and TV where as Sky could only offer a discount with BT and TV
Since ofcom changed the rules, this enabled Sky to purchase Easy.net (i think it was called) called it Sky Broadband and they used it as a ADSL connection via BT lines.

Problem with ADSL.
Lags the further away you are
Old Technology and Limited


I think if it goes freeview
The marketing people who will purchase this will be...

Young people (ages 18-25) who are moving regularly
People who cannot afford the full services (Probably on an lower income than £13.000)
Couples with No children
People in good signal areas
probably willing to pay for more than its worth via Sky directly or Virgin Media for the sake of it being available via the airways

Instead of it being 24.00 it could end up being 32.00
With poor service refunds, Example: Poor signal strength then will Sky or Freeview arrange refunds? nope how will they proove you did have an issue and not just saying that?, probably part of the terms and conditions, so you could be paying for a service you couldnt watch
info4u is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-02-2007, 00:21   #39
Tezcatlipoca
Inactive
 
Tezcatlipoca's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Cambridge
Posts: 16,760
Tezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny stars
Tezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by info4u View Post
It will be quite interesting to see that happen...

1) VM have MPEG2 to but its HD which makes MPEG4. This is reletivly new technology which is rendered as useless unless you have an HD ready TV.
I'm not exactly sure what point you're making...

VM uses MPEG2 for SD & HD digital cable TV.

Sky uses MPEG2 for SD digital satellite TV, & MPEG4 part 10 (aka H.264, aka AVC) for HD digital satellite TV.

Freeview/TUTV uses MPEG2 for SD digital terrestrial TV.


Sky's proposed digital terrestrial TV service will use MPEG4 part 10, for SD channels (4 SD channels in MPEG4 instead of 3 SD channels in MPEG2).


What's rendered useless unless you have an HD-Ready TV?


EDIT: Or you mean that the only point of MPEG4 is for HD, & there's no point in HD if you have no HDTV? MPEG4 isn't just for HD...

Quote:
Originally Posted by info4u
2) The fact its FREEVIEW brings a great financial risk to Sky
Look at what happened to ONDIGITAL (ITV DIGITAL), they went broke because of pirate cards being created, this happends then you know there is going to be problems for them and they will have to stop.

Freeview dont really charge for anything therefore they dont have to worry about people robbing or nicking the service for free.

ONDIGITAL used a crappy encryption system, which was easily hacked.


Sky have their own encryption system - VideoGuard - which is fully owned & controlled by the Murdoch Empire, & is lacking the various flaws which the ONDIGITAL encryption system suffered from.

If/when Sky start their own MPEG4 SD DTT service, it will require their own boxes, & you can be certain they would use their own encryption system again, like they do for satellite TV.... there would be no dodgy CAMs & card cloning like happened to ONDIGITAL.
Tezcatlipoca is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-02-2007, 11:21   #40
themelon
Inactive
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Stoke-On-Trent
Posts: 561
themelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to beholdthemelon is a splendid one to behold
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

This is utter utter crap. Sky can not be allowed to do this. It takes 3 Free channels away from all Freeview and Top Up TV users and replaces it with 4channels which they can not watch unless they get a new box. Wahoo that is great. It is bad for Top Up TV as their boxes/encryption will be incompatible with Skys so they will have to have two boxes or their subscribers will loose channels. It is bad for Freeview as it makes the service less attractive for those sick of being ripped off by Sky.

This is another Sky bully boy tactic, OFCOM has to stamp it authority before it gets out of hand, and unprecedented fine and sanctions must be imposed on Skys monopoly.
themelon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-06-2007, 17:15   #41
Media Boy UK
Got inside news - PM me
 
Media Boy UK's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Media Boy UK HQ
Posts: 15,156
Media Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny stars
Media Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny starsMedia Boy UK has a pair of shiny stars
Free Sky: no more on Freeview?

BskyB is expected to get the go-ahead for a pay-TV service on Freeview, so long as if offers the new channels, at a price, to rival TV providers such as Setanta and Top Up TV. Ofcom is to consultations on Sky's plans to broadcast four paid-for TV channels on Freeview. Sky are set to remove Sky Three, Sky News & Sky Sports News to put their four new channels on-air. Info from the Mail on Sunday.
__________________
Blog Updated Sep 11th
May come Sep 11th
Also on X & BSky
Media Boy UK is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-06-2007, 17:38   #42
Tezcatlipoca
Inactive
 
Tezcatlipoca's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Cambridge
Posts: 16,760
Tezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny stars
Tezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Merged with the existing thread.



Sorry to be pedantic, but they won't be on "Freeview", by the way...as, well, they won't be free.

Freeview is a form of DTT, but not all DTT is Freeview.


Also, as well as not being free (& so not being "Freeview"), the new DTT channels from Sky were previously reported as being expected to use MPEG-4 Part 10 (AVC/H.264), & also will in all likelihood use Sky's own proprietary Conditional Access System, & so will not be compatible with existing "Freeview" STBs & TVs - you'd need a new Sky DTT STB to view them.
Tezcatlipoca is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-06-2007, 18:18   #43
GuestUK
Inactive
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Services: Ex-NTL: Virgin 4mb internet, Virgin phone, Virgin Digital TV (XL): 1 Pace STB, 1 V+ STB
Posts: 245
GuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to beholdGuestUK is a splendid one to behold
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt D View Post
Merged with the existing thread.

Also, as well as not being free (& so not being "Freeview"), the new DTT channels from Sky were previously reported as being expected to use MPEG-4 Part 10 (AVC/H.264), & also will in all likelihood use Sky's own proprietary Conditional Access System, & so will not be compatible with existing "Freeview" STBs & TVs - you'd need a new Sky DTT STB to view them.
As per in some of the news articles, for examle here, it seems that they are likely to be asked to share their channels with other providers (presumably compatabillity with their boxes and access systems). If this is a requirement, it would be most likely Sky would have to give up on mpeg4 and videoguard protection, or have to give up the idea alltogether. That is, of course, if that requirement is made of Sky.

I think it would probably be in Sky's best interests however. Sky's channels are available in other protection styles to other providers already, they were on ITV digital as well.

Plus, if this isn't a requirement, they'll most likely come up with proprietary boxes and systems which I don't think would be in the interests of the DTT platform. On the other hand, if they are recquired to be compatible, not only would customers on TTV and Setanta and with compatible boxes be able to get Sky's servive easily (which I think is a benefit, ready to go) it'd also hepl keep DTT more standardised and prevent Sky from gaining too much of a hold on UK DTT.
GuestUK is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-06-2007, 19:05   #44
popper
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,270
popper has a bronze arraypopper has a bronze arraypopper has a bronze array
popper has a bronze arraypopper has a bronze arraypopper has a bronze arraypopper has a bronze arraypopper has a bronze arraypopper has a bronze array
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt D View Post
Merged with the existing thread.



Sorry to be pedantic, but they won't be on "Freeview", by the way...as, well, they won't be free.

Freeview is a form of DTT, but not all DTT is Freeview.


Also, as well as not being free (& so not being "Freeview"), the new DTT channels from Sky were previously reported as being expected to use MPEG-4 Part 10 (AVC/H.264), & also will in all likelihood use Sky's own proprietary Conditional Access System, & so will not be compatible with existing "Freeview" STBs & TVs - you'd need a new Sky DTT STB to view them.


lets not forget the BBC are also asking for AVC as their prefered long term format.
popper is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-06-2007, 19:15   #45
Tezcatlipoca
Inactive
 
Tezcatlipoca's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Cambridge
Posts: 16,760
Tezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny stars
Tezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny starsTezcatlipoca has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Sky goes terrestrial

Quote:
Originally Posted by GuestUK View Post
As per in some of the news articles, for examle here, it seems that they are likely to be asked to share their channels with other providers (presumably compatabillity with their boxes and access systems). If this is a requirement, it would be most likely Sky would have to give up on mpeg4 and videoguard protection, or have to give up the idea alltogether. That is, of course, if that requirement is made of Sky.

I think it would probably be in Sky's best interests however. Sky's channels are available in other protection styles to other providers already, they were on ITV digital as well.

Plus, if this isn't a requirement, they'll most likely come up with proprietary boxes and systems which I don't think would be in the interests of the DTT platform. On the other hand, if they are recquired to be compatible, not only would customers on TTV and Setanta and with compatible boxes be able to get Sky's servive easily (which I think is a benefit, ready to go) it'd also hepl keep DTT more standardised and prevent Sky from gaining too much of a hold on UK DTT.


I can't see Sky offering the channels to Setanta & TUTV unless forced to.

Or maybe they'll offer them, but at a price they know won't be accepted


The Mail article does say "Viewers would need an upgraded set-top box to watch the new channels.", plus still mentions the plan being to remove the current three channels & replace them with four.

Also, I can't see Sky wanting their channels to use the insecure MediaGuard that TUTV/Setanta use on DTT, rather than their own still unbroken VideoGuard.


As for having to buy new equipment, that already happens for anyone who wants to use the "TopUp TV Anytime" DTT service (push-VOD like Sky Anytime), as you need a proprietary "TopUp TV Anytime" DTT PVR.

Hmm. Actually, looking at the TopUp TV website, it seems that the *only* "TopUp TV" option available for new subscribers is to buy the TopUp TV PVR. Seems the old-style TopUp TV smart card / CAM option only remains for existing subscribers.
Tezcatlipoca is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:22.


Server: lithium.zmnt.uk
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum