Quote:
Originally Posted by Damien
A long post, I'll address something else:
Wrong on so many levels, First of all there were no major valid concerns. Just a hysterical public who presume to know more about Physics than those who have PhDs and experience in the field. There was a safety report, and these people know what they are doing. They also have a desire for world not to explode.
Also, Scientific process demands we explore the unknown and attempt to learn more about the Universe. We do not need a "clear cut positive benefits", the pursuit of knowledge, learning something completely new about our world, is a massive benefit in itself. The Space Race could be deemed pointless, but it's technological advances are being used as we speak (computers). We are learning about the building blocks of the Universe, imagine the possibility for the future of science and technology.
We can't pause Science because people who don't understand it are concerned about something they read which suggested it's dangerous.
What do you mean 'unquestioned'. They are doing the questioning. How can you question scientists without knowing the science?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maggy J
Well IF you must drag religion into it...
If a God made us the way we are then he is responsible for making us as curious as we are...Surely an omnipotent being would have foreseen that eventually we would try to work out how our universe works so maybe we are doing just what God wants us to do?To achieve our full potential?Your way would have us stuck back in the stone age.
|
Was not me who dragged religion into this one. The question is good though, and as its theoretical there are many possible answers, hope you like all the ones you find for it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by downquark1
This I completely agree on.
This is retardedness. 1st of all we define nature as the physical universe, I am in the physical universe whether I am outside, in space or in my laboratory. If I boil water in my glass beaker over a burner the same thing is happening at me boiling outside over a camp fire. The difference is outside wind will be redirecting the heat almost randomly making it harder to take accurate measurements.
Back to the LHC, another simple reason why we can't measure the existing reactions is taking the atlas detector out side will flood the whole thing with tracks of data making it impossible to see what result came from what particle. There are muons passing through you right now, from the reactions in the atmosphere, there are weak radioactive elements in the earth shooting things out. How can we be expected to work out which is caused by which unless we can control the conditions?
Are you by any chance Melanie Phillips?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuart C
So you have decided that 100s of years of experiments are invalid? Including those which resulted in the technology that enabled you to post here?
Apologies if I am incorrect here, but you seem to have little understanding of how science works.
The reasons that experiments are conducted in controlled environments are simple
1) Outside variables may influence the outcome and therefore render the results invalid.
2) For a result to be valid, it needs to be repeatable. If outside variables are introduced, these can influence the results and make them unrepeatable.
When the experiment has been conducted successfully, they have established a baseline result and can repeat the experiment while varying the conditions.
|
No I am not her.
So what we have here is a dual purpose nuclear research centre in Switzerland a country that is suposed to be neutral as far as any military activity goes, near Genva where the Geneva conventions and Geneva protocol were drawn up and the netherlands is one of the original members of the project where the Hague conventions were drawn up..
The current research is not interested in the random factor that would be required to simulate the suposed big bang and is in reality unlikely to produce any definitve answers on how the universe began, the experiments are actually limited to targeting a few specific particles for collision with specific purpose.
One of these end goals is the hopes of developing the ability to neutralize nuclear waste ? I would also guess this will be looked at for going further and the hopes is to be able to develop a wide angle particle beam that can perform 'in situ enviromental radioactive remediation' in the case of nuclear incidents of which I am sure the various involved governments and their military's would really appreciate as while it may go towards reducing the risks of nuclear power it will also remove the biggest obstacle in the use of tactical nuclear warheads by providing the ability to neutralize the radioactive aftermath.
If all weapons were made for the purpose of self defense use only their purpose would be self defeating.
Personally I dont like this method of us reaching our full potential but then you should not listen to me, I am just some crackpot.