Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Networking (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=87)
-   -   Router, dual WAN capability (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33701415)

Ignitionnet 19-09-2015 18:20

Router, dual WAN capability
 
Greetings infidels.

So my situation is as follows:

I require a router that can do load balancing across 2 WAN links, and do this while handling a WAN->LAN throughput of at least 400Mb, ideally 600Mb, and LAN->WAN of 100Mb.

Ridiculous WiFi would be a bonus.

Ethernet WAN ports are fine, as the 'modem' aspect will be handled by other equipment.

I don't have any great desire to build my own router. I prefer using off the shelf equipment as I'm lazy and don't like messing around too much with network equipment at home if I can help it.

Any recommendations other than this beast?

Uncle Peter 19-09-2015 20:48

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Guten Abend

http://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/product...78-706724.html

Fits your throughput profile but no funky wireless, in fact no wireless at all.

My company have these in our network services portfolio. They work.

Ignitionnet 20-09-2015 14:35

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Reluctant as I am to add more Cisco kit to my magnificent 2610 and 2 x 3550 that looks like it'd fit the bill, thank you!

Paul 20-09-2015 16:10

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Also this ?

http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00D3ZLNKA/

(Could not find any details of its throughput, probably not has high as you're looking for though)

Ignitionnet 21-09-2015 11:16

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Sadly not.

NAT Throughput 160Mbps

Ignitionnet 30-09-2015 08:45

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
I may actually need considerably more than 600Mb WAN to LAN and 802.3ad support.

Looks like it'll be my own build. Quite sure I'm into the realms of Enterprise kit otherwise.

Uncle Peter 30-09-2015 11:37

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
That throughput is a tall order once you start adding rules.

So if you're building, say around pfsense does this pique your interest?

http://www.fit-pc.com/web/products/fitlet/fitlet-x/

Ignitionnet 30-09-2015 14:13

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35801056)
That throughput is a tall order once you start adding rules.

So if you're building, say around pfsense does this pique your interest?

http://www.fit-pc.com/web/products/fitlet/fitlet-x/

I have a few options. I will potentially need 1.4Gb/s to avoid bottlenecks which reduces the options but definitely building my own with a couple of 2 port NICs is the way to go.

qasdfdsaq 01-10-2015 14:19

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
1.4Gb/s for your home connection? Jeebus.

That said, any old laptop with pfSense could do the trick, I have a ten year old device that'll happily do 2Gb/s+ NAT throughput.

USB3 Gigabit adapter for a tenner for the second NIC or ExpressCard if you're anal about USB jitter.

Matthew 02-10-2015 09:39

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Selection of dual wan routers here. I get all my kit from here, got a Draytek running at the moment.

Ignitionnet 03-10-2015 17:03

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Thank you, though sadly doesn't come close to the performance levels I require.

qasdfdsaq 08-10-2015 17:32

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
How much money are you willing to spend? The pfSense hardware range is fairly decent but reaches upwards of $500 USD for the good stuff:

http://store.pfsense.org/SG-4860/

However it looks like with all the SPI features on it only manages about 800Mb/s, though potentially much higher - the 2-core 1.7Ghz version hits 600Mbps so I'd expect the 4-core 2.4Ghz to exceed 1.4Gbps if configured right.

Matthew 09-10-2015 20:58

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
If your going to look at pFsense look at buying a Watchguard box off eBay and putting pFsense on it, cheaper than above.

Ignitionnet 10-10-2015 22:16

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matthew (Post 35802851)
If your going to look at pFsense look at buying a Watchguard box off eBay and putting pFsense on it, cheaper than above.

That'll do nicely. I see an XTM 505 that will do the job admirably.

Uncle Peter 10-10-2015 23:13

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Watch out with those boxes dude, those throughput claims are pretty optimistic.

qasdfdsaq 11-10-2015 17:40

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matthew (Post 35802851)
If your going to look at pFsense look at buying a Watchguard box off eBay and putting pFsense on it, cheaper than above.

Care to post an example? The only ones I can find quote throughput figures less than 1/10th what he needs.

---------- Post added at 17:40 ---------- Previous post was at 17:38 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35802968)
Watch out with those boxes dude, those throughput claims are pretty optimistic.

Optimistic? The ones I see on eBay quote 125Mbps firewall/20Mbps VPN! My mobile phone can do more than that.

Carlos Carboni 11-10-2015 18:45

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Igintion mentioned ebay XTM 505
A bit expensive.

Aren't these

ERPro-8 Ubiquiti EdgeRouter PRO

a better choice? We have some of these at work and they are highly respected.

Uncle Peter 11-10-2015 23:55

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35803056)
Care to post an example? The only ones I can find quote throughput figures less than 1/10th what he needs.

---------- Post added at 17:40 ---------- Previous post was at 17:38 ----------



Optimistic? The ones I see on eBay quote 125Mbps firewall/20Mbps VPN! My mobile phone can do more than that.

3.5Gbps claim of some arbitrary throughput measure on one of those Watchguard appliances which aren't actually that cheap.

qasdfdsaq 12-10-2015 12:35

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35803092)
3.5Gbps claim of some arbitrary throughput measure on one of those Watchguard appliances which aren't actually that cheap.

And that's exactly why I dislike proprietary "black box" systems.

Ignitionnet 12-10-2015 14:06

Re: Router, dual WAN capability
 
I have re-evaluated and while load balancing to reach 1.3Gb/s may be good for the e-penis it's not worth the hassle, so I'll run the 2 in active-passive, meaning line rate gigabit downstream and ~100Mb upstream simultaneously is fine, which brings me back into scope of highest-end home routers.

This works well for me as I hate messing with my home network, KISS, and I have a few months before I have to worry about a purchase so can wait for prices of current top-end kit to drop.

Thanks for the input!


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 00:43.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum