Euthanasia? - Page 5

27-07-2004, 19:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Incognitas

My thoughts go out to all those who struggle to come to terms with the increasing ill health of any one suffering a degenerative and terminal disease

I totally agree

Jerrek · 27-07-2004, 19:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by Electrolyte

How does that mean I'm a murderer?

Killing someone who didn't want to die... We call that murder, you know?

Looking at the article, unless the kid asked to be killed, it is ... murder. There is no way to be sure he would have wanted to die, unless he communicated his wishes to his parents.

Sorry folks, I'm not about to dress it up in nice flowery language to make it sound less cold. The kid is DEAD. His heart doesn't pump anymore. D E A D.

27-07-2004, 19:09

You really are one cold person arn't you? Don't you have feelings for people who are dead? I do....and I bet other people of the forum do to.

paulyoung666 · 27-07-2004, 19:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jerrek

Killing someone who didn't want to die... We call that murder, you know?

Looking at the article, unless the kid asked to be killed, it is ... murder. There is no way to be sure he would have wanted to die, unless he communicated his wishes to his parents.

Sorry folks, I'm not about to dress it up in nice flowery language to make it sound less cold. The kid is DEAD. His heart doesn't pump anymore. D E A D.

by the letter of the law you are totally correct , as a human being i am afraid you are showing yourself to be as cold as the lad concerned is

**Maggy** · 27-07-2004, 19:12

So easy for you to say Jerrek but you are niether a parent or a carer.Until you are I suggest you can have little real insight.Good day.

Jerrek · 27-07-2004, 19:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by Electrolyte

You really are one cold person arn't you? Don't you have feelings for people who are dead? I do....and I bet other people of the forum do to.

How can you take such a decision upon yourself whether someone wants to live or not if that person is unable to tell you?

How dare you?

Just what if that person didn't want to die? Is it still justified? Is it?

**Maggy** · 27-07-2004, 19:17

And just who are you to be sitting in judgement.Walk a mile in my shoes the saying goes but I think you just refuse to see any viewpoint but your own.

Jerrek · 27-07-2004, 19:19

I thought I'm on your ignore list? Changed your opinion so fast?

I'm not sitting in judgment, but I am expressing an opinion that murder is wrong, no matter what your "feelings" may tell you.

27-07-2004, 19:23

Don't bother with him Incognitas, he's only cares about him self really.

I know I shouldn't really have said that, but I had to break it out some time or the other.

Jerrek · 27-07-2004, 19:24

Answer my question:

Just what if that person didn't want to die? Is it still justified? Is it?

paulyoung666 · 27-07-2004, 19:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jerrek

I thought I'm on your ignore list? Changed your opinion so fast?

I'm not sitting in judgment, but I am expressing an opinion that murder is wrong, no matter what your "feelings" may tell you.

how can anyone be as cold as you , or is the enviroment you live in rubbing off on you

27-07-2004, 19:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jerrek

Just what if that person didn't want to die? Is it still justified? Is it?

And why should I answer that? Not in my right to answer it.

Jerrek · 27-07-2004, 19:26

Cold? Heh, I'm not the one trying to justify murdering people...

27-07-2004, 19:27

This isn't murder, it's Euthanasia, stay on topic.

Jerrek · 27-07-2004, 19:28

You're killing someone who didn't want to die. Of course it is murder!