Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Slyder
If your using your rig for games, then AMD wins by far... no question.
Personally I recommend Intel for video and music editing. 
|
Personally speaking, I think that there isn't any difference between the two anymore.
A couple of months ago a friend asked me to find him a machine for "video work and gaming" so I asked on these very forums and zinglebarb replied amongst others that they thought dual core was the way to go.
So started more research on whether my friend was going to notice any difference between the two processors. The choice was simple, dual core Intel or dual core AMD. Eventually I sugested the AMD64 X2 4400 after advice gathered on other forums. He got back to me a couple of weeks or so later saying "It's brilliant, so quick" and when I asked whether there was any difference encoding on the AMD versus his old Pentium. He assured me there was none. Infact he likes his new system even more because he can now use his system to do other tasks ie: surfing, office tasks listen to shoutcasts etc. whilst at the same time encoding video. Something he wasn't able to do with his old system. He started encoding anything then had to go do something else untill the encoding had finnished.
This is something I can personally confirm as well, as during all of this I was delaying the decision whether to update my system or not. In the end I decided to go for it and so we both got a small discount each.
I am presently sat here re-encoding a video, streaming some audio through real player, outlook express is doing its thing. Opera browser is open with 3 tabs showing, I have rainlendar and rainmeter running on my desktop with the usual firewall and antivirus running in the background and my processor is only at 27%. My friend meanwhile has a little more ram than me (2GB) and he can encode (VHS to DVD) and play Half Life 2 quite easily he assures me.
Needless to say, I am now a convert to AMD after previously dismissing them in favour of Intel. I was under the impression that they were the most stable, best for video work etc. But those days are gone. Next time I upgrade, I shan't be looking at Intel, paying a premium for supposed gains. I shall also consider AMD as well.