Forum Articles
  Welcome back Join CF
You are here You are here: Home | Forum | Faster than the speed of light?Update...

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most of the discussions, articles and other free features. By joining our Virgin Media community you will have full access to all discussions, be able to view and post threads, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload your own images/photos, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please join our community today.


Welcome to Cable Forum
Go Back   Cable Forum > General Discussion > Science & Technology

Faster than the speed of light?Update...
Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 23-09-2011, 12:39   #16
Russ
cf.mega poster
 
Russ's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Half in the corporeal, half in the etheral
Posts: 37,182
Russ has a golden aura
Russ has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden auraRuss has a golden aura
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Anything to get away from Adele's music
__________________
Heavy Is The Crown
Russ is offline   Reply With Quote
Advertisement
Old 23-09-2011, 12:44   #17
downquark1
cf.mega poster
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 4,952
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kymmy View Post
Going a bit off topic I find it weird that the greeks were fully aware of the earth being round and orbiting the sun only for this knowledge to be lost and then for christian so called scientists who thought/taught that the earth was too important not to be the centre of the universe..
As I understand it the orbiting the sun bit was a controversial opinion at the time.
__________________
"Knowledge is Power. Power Corrupts. Study Hard. Be Evil."
downquark1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 13:03   #18
Anonymouse
RIP Tigger - 14 years?!
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Bolton
Age: 61
Services: BT Superfast Broadband
Posts: 1,871
Anonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appeal
Anonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appealAnonymouse has a bronzed appeal
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

This would be utterly astounding if true, but relativity has withstood every practical test ever thrown at it. Besides, IIRC there's still no firm figure for the neutrino's mass (though the theory insists that if they can change from one type to another they must have a bit of mass). By Occam's Razor, by far the simplest explanation is that there's been either some sort of very tiny but significant measurement error, or they've misinterpreted the results.

Also, if true the result should be repeatable. If it isn't, then they have made a mistake somewhere, a la cold fusion (i.e. the heat increase supposedly measured in one test which hasn't been reported since).

Come to think of it, under certain circumstances some particles can travel faster than light...in water, as explained here. But the speed of light in any medium is of course lower than its absolute, i.e. its speed in vacuum. It may be that this particular type of neutrino can travel faster than light in air - not a violation of relativity, but still fascinating in its own right, as I'm pretty sure it would be the first such observation ever made.


Oh, hang on - surely the interior of the LHC would be a vacuum. Hmm. That implies something rather odd is going on. Having reread the article, if they've gotten the same consistent result 15,000 times...hmm. But it still must be repeatable at a different site by different experimenters, else it can't be regarded as a valid result.

If it is, though, it'll change everything.

(Slightly O/T)

Mind you, if anyone ever proves the Riemann Hypothesis, that'll change everything, too. It's a curious fact that the majority of mathematics is essentially built on sand; while I was doing my degree, one maths lecturer remarked on the title of a maths book, 'Foundations of Mathematics', and said it always made him laugh because the foundations of mathematics are shaky at best. It wasn't until I learned about the Riemann Hypothesis and how many fundamental theorems depend on its correctness when it hasn't even been proved yet that I understood what he meant. To anyone who can appreciate the beauty of mathematics, it's a little worrying. It makes me think of what happened to God in the Hitch-Hiker's Guide to the Galaxy:

"I refuse to prove I exist," says, God, "for proof denies faith, and without faith I am nothing."
"But," says Man, "the Babel Fish is a dead giveaway, isn't it? It couldn't have evolved by chance. It proves you exist, and so therefore you don't. QED."
"Oh, dear," says God, "I hadn't thought of that," and promptly vanishes in a puff of logic.
__________________
"People tend to confuse the words 'new' and 'improved'."
- Agent Phil Coulson, S.H.I.E.L.D.

WINDOWS 11/UK 'GOVERNMENT', ANYONE?!
Anonymouse is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 13:22   #19
Kymmy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,385
Kymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny stars
Kymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Anonymouse View Post
This would be utterly astounding if true, but relativity has withstood every practical test ever thrown at it. Besides, IIRC there's still no firm figure for the neutrino's mass (though the theory insists that if they can change from one type to another they must have a bit of mass). By Occam's Razor, by far the simplest explanation is that there's been either some sort of very tiny but significant measurement error, or they've misinterpreted the results.
Mass has no relevance on speed. A two ton elephant travelling at 10m a second is still travelling at the same speed as a ball also travelling at 10m a second. Perhaps you're getting confused between mass and acceleration?
Kymmy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 14:25   #20
downquark1
cf.mega poster
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 4,952
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kymmy View Post
Mass has no relevance on speed. A two ton elephant travelling at 10m a second is still travelling at the same speed as a ball also travelling at 10m a second. Perhaps you're getting confused between mass and acceleration?
Mass has relevance here because an object with mass cannot achieve the speed of light (according to incumbent relativity theory- perhaps to be called "classical relativity" soon).

Anyway, the results are going to be discussed in 30 min here: http://webcast.web.cern.ch/webcast/
__________________
"Knowledge is Power. Power Corrupts. Study Hard. Be Evil."
downquark1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 14:53   #21
Kymmy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,385
Kymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny stars
Kymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Even if a neutrino changes state it still has mass albeit a small one. As their calculations are based on neutrinos then mass has no relevance unless the change of state is accelerating the mass?

It's a weird one that I for one will be interested in the outcome.
Kymmy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 15:27   #22
downquark1
cf.mega poster
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 4,952
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by heero_yuy View Post
Einsteins equations do not forbid faster than light speed but the mass of the object has to be complex. (Involving the square root of -1)
A complex mass is a "non-physical" result i.e. impossible. Even then you have the problem of further acceleration requiring infinite amounts of energy.
__________________
"Knowledge is Power. Power Corrupts. Study Hard. Be Evil."
downquark1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 15:45   #23
Ignitionnet
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Leeds, West Yorkshire
Age: 48
Posts: 13,995
Ignitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny stars
Ignitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny starsIgnitionnet has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kymmy View Post
Even if a neutrino changes state it still has mass albeit a small one. As their calculations are based on neutrinos then mass has no relevance unless the change of state is accelerating the mass?

It's a weird one that I for one will be interested in the outcome.
Neutrinos have to have mass under the standard relativistic model, certain types of them have been shown to be marginally slower than the speed of light. Massless particles not only can move at the speed of light but must.
Ignitionnet is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 16:07   #24
joglynne
Born again teenager.
 
joglynne's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Manchester. (VM area 20)
Age: 78
Services: Maxit TV, M250 Fibre BB. Phone-Anytime Chatter
Posts: 13,934
joglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aura
joglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aurajoglynne has a golden aura
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

I have just been listening to Prof Brian Cox and I like the idea that these results, if they are right, could just indicate, amongst other things that there is a Forth Dimension.

I wouldn't mind the short cuts through time if it meant I didn't have to sit on planes for as long.


http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-15034852
__________________
"I intend to live forever, or die trying" - Groucho Marx..... "but whilst I do I shall do so disgracefully." Jo Glynne
joglynne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 16:10   #25
Kymmy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,385
Kymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny stars
Kymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny starsKymmy has a pair of shiny stars
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by joglynne View Post
I have just been listening to Prof Brian Cox and I like the idea that these results, if they are right, could just indicate, amongst other things that there is a Forth Dimension.

I wouldn't mind the short cuts through time if it meant I didn't have to sit on planes for as long.


http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-15034852
Why does this remind me of an episode of Futurama.. The forward time machine???
Kymmy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 17:06   #26
Cobbydaler
Inactive
 
Cobbydaler's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Manchester, UK
Services: ClearFibre Internet, Vodafone mobile Google Pixel 4
Posts: 9,699
Cobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered stars
Cobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered stars
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Well, one Professor's pretty confident it's a measurement error...
Quote:
"The scientists are right to be extremely cautious about interpreting these findings," said Jim Al-Khalili, a physicist from the University of Surrey, who suggested that a simple error in the measurement is probably the source of all the fuss.

But he has gone further.
"So let me put my money where my mouth is: if the Cern experiment proves to be correct and neutrinos have broken the speed of light, I will eat my boxer shorts on live TV."
Link
Cobbydaler is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 18:59   #27
Maggy
The Invisible Woman
Cable Forum Mod
 
Maggy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: between Portsmouth and Southampton.
Age: 74
Services: VM XL TV,50 MB VM BB,VM landline, Tivo
Posts: 40,379
Maggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden aura
Maggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden auraMaggy has a golden aura
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cobbydaler View Post
Well, one Professor's pretty confident it's a measurement error...
Link
From the above link
Quote:
We'll never get old - politicians would stay young forever”
Sergio Bertolucci
Snigger! But the young girls would still be younger than him..
__________________
Hell is empty and all the devils are here. Shakespeare..
Maggy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 19:20   #28
Cobbydaler
Inactive
 
Cobbydaler's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Manchester, UK
Services: ClearFibre Internet, Vodafone mobile Google Pixel 4
Posts: 9,699
Cobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered stars
Cobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered starsCobbydaler is seeing silvered stars
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Maggy J View Post
From the above link

Snigger! But the young girls would still be younger than him..
I misread that for Berlusconi...
Cobbydaler is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-09-2011, 19:29   #29
downquark1
cf.mega poster
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 4,952
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
downquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appealdownquark1 has a bronzed appeal
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Maggy J View Post
From the above link

Snigger! But the young girls would still be younger than him..
One of the chairmen was hilarious (by physicist standards) during the presentation.

The presenter gave a full complete and incredibly complicated overview of the experiment so when it came to questions he said "Well since speed is distance over time lets split the questions into those questioning the distance measurement and those questioning the time measurement."

He also made a crack at the end about not forgetting the actual purpose of the experiment. It should be noted that the experiment was not built measure the speed of the neutrino but neutrino oscillation.

Also the implications of relativity being wrong kind of undermine the experiment itself since relativity was using in the GPS technology used.
__________________
"Knowledge is Power. Power Corrupts. Study Hard. Be Evil."
downquark1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 24-09-2011, 14:04   #30
Sparkle
cf.mega poster
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Open Prison, H.M.United Kingdom
Posts: 1,037
Sparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful oneSparkle is the helpful one
Re: Faster than the speed of light?

I wonder if an explanation for these recent findings is that it could be related to the compression of space/time due to the mass of the earth. Thus allowing the neutrino to appear to travel faster than the speed of light, whereas if the neutrino had travelled alongside a light beam it would have in fact travelled slower.

I really do hope however that this "faster than light" feat does turn out to be true. Relatively little is known about what really goes on inside atoms and basic questions are yet to be answered. Yes, scientists have been smashing atoms together for some time now and observing the results in bubble chambers. Yet still noone really knows what an electron is, or why an atom is what it is. There are only theories, this is why we can't really design our own atoms or develop new chemical compounds (i.e. super materials) which use the inner electron shells of atoms rather than merely the valence electron shells. In high pressure physics, compounds are compressed together to millions of atmospheres and all new novel compounds are created (with surprising results), not just using the outer valence electrons. This really just goes to show how little we know about matter.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diamond_anvil_cell
http://focus.aps.org/story/v15/st12

So, personally speaking, I wouldn't be particularly surprised if some ghost mystery particle seems to be able to get around one or some of the laws of physics which apply to other particles. Could be a very small step on a very long road of scientific discovery, or maybe just a mistake. We can but hope.

---------- Post added at 13:31 ---------- Previous post was at 11:55 ----------

http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/20...light-violated

Quote:
Professor Jim Al-Khalili at the University of Surrey said it was most likely that something was skewing the results. "If the neutrinos have broken the speed of light, it would overturn a keystone theory from the last century of physics. That's possible, but it's far more likely that there is an error in the data. So let me put my money where my mouth is: if the Cern experiment proves to be correct and neutrinos have broken the speed of light, I will eat my boxer shorts on live TV."
I can just see the internet petitions for this if it's proved true.

---------- Post added at 14:04 ---------- Previous post was at 13:31 ----------

In another thread, Here I mentioned about how easy it is to measure one thing with tremendous accuracy, speed.
If this latest FTL observation turns out to be genuine then it won't surprise me that it was speed that was first shown to reveal a discontinuity in the laws of physics as we know them to be, since speed is something that is so easily measured. No arguing with speed, as its easy reproducible and measured anywhere by anyone with the right equipment.
Imagine, assuming this to be true, that other laws are routinely broken at the subatomic level. How would we know? These are new particles, we don't know their properties. Physicists have essentially been breaking atoms, and writing the science as they go along, as there is little else they can do.
Perhaps, some particles actually have less mass/inertia than they should. Others have more or less charge than they should.
These "violations" would not be so obvious, as so little is understood about them. But, as soon as one goes faster than that ultimate speed - then it's abundantly clear to all. Just as long as it gets measured.
This is partly why I've got my fingers crossed here, as if this latest possible claim is true, I expect in the years to come that we'll find evidence of other laws that are regularly flouted (but previously unnoticed), and we'll begin to see a gradual unravelling of the secrets of the physical dimension as we've come to know it.

Its long been theorised that the laws which govern the physical universe, are actually dictated in higher dimensions. Mitchio Kaku, a leading theoretical physicist, wrote much of this in his best seller "Hyperspace" in the mid '90s.
His explanation was that from the vantage point of higher dimensions, the lower dimensions simplify, and the physical properties we observe, are only explicable from the higher dimensional vantage point.
One example he provides is the chaos in the battlefield (assume 2 dimensional) becomes ordered when an extra dimension is added (the high ground) where the battle commanders can see what is occurring, but which the combatants are oblivious to.
He goes on to say, that although the physical laws which we can observe appear very chaotic (hence no unified field theory), the chaos disappears in the higher dimensions which dictate the laws of physics as we know them. The understanding of the higher dimension is the key to understanding the physical 3D universe as we've come to know it.
Sparkle is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:36.


Server: lithium.zmnt.uk
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum