Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Stuart W
I must admit I find it very hard to believe a court would act on evidence as flimsy as a text file!
|
As always it is up to the jury to decide on the credibility of any evidence and in this particular case I actually pointed out to the court that yes it was possible to "Fake" any file but that forensic examination of the HD could in many cases expose such a fake.
I'm not suggesting this guy got sent down solely because of the txt file but simply that its existance provided evidence of the credibility of the victims statement that she had sent messages to me at a specific time and date confirming key details of the attack.
A log file from a PC could therefore also add weight to a claim that a call to a specific number had not been made from the PC.
Here is a scenario for you involving external tampering with the green box.
The number called is an on-line sexsite.
This has been iniated from the green box not the PC.
The call can be proven not to be a "Voice" line so on a balance of probability it would only have been made in two circumstances.
1. The call was made from the PC to access the sex site in which case the log would normally show this call.
2. The call was iniated by someone else wanting to benefit from the revenue generated by the call.
A jury would consider not just the log but the credibility of the person making the claim that the log was accurate. A question they might pose is, "would someone create a "fake" file simply to avoid paying a £30 call charge and then run the risk of getting found out in court and be guilty of perjury".
The above is a possible scenario following the "Scam" referred to in the reports on the Register, whereby some criminals have generated calls to numbers they own by tapping into the phone lines.
Hope that clarifies.