Forum Articles
  Welcome back Join CF
You are here You are here: Home | Forum | Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most of the discussions, articles and other free features. By joining our Virgin Media community you will have full access to all discussions, be able to view and post threads, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload your own images/photos, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please join our community today.


Welcome to Cable Forum
Go Back   Cable Forum > Computers & IT > General IT Discussion

Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool
Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 27-06-2006, 20:47   #1
littld
Inactive
 
littld's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Manchester
Age: 54
Services: Phone line
Posts: 305
littld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud of
Send a message via MSN to littld
Question Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Okay, here's the thing.

New 1GB DIMM bought today for my home PC.

If I run Microsoft's Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool it says I have hardware problems. No detail.

I run MEMTEST86+ and it reports no errors on the first pass, then has a failing address.

Should I return it or wait until my PC starts crashing?

How serious is it anyway?

Advice gratefully received.
littld is offline   Reply With Quote
Advertisement
Old 27-06-2006, 21:29   #2
Druchii
cf.mega poster
 
Druchii's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Oslo, Norway.
Age: 37
Services: Canal Digital: 50/10
Posts: 7,577
Druchii has a nice shiny star
Druchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny star
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Return it. New RAM should have no errors what-so-ever.
Druchii is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:32   #3
zing_deleted
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Is it branded or generic? whatever it is take it back and if its generic slap your own wrists you should have known better
  Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:38   #4
littld
Inactive
 
littld's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Manchester
Age: 54
Services: Phone line
Posts: 305
littld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud oflittld has much to be proud of
Send a message via MSN to littld
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Oh well, probably my own fault. I've always bought Corsair before and this is generic.

Back to the shop I go. Hope they'll take it back.

Wish Vista didn't need so much memory.

Thanks for the help guys.
littld is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:39   #5
Wicked_and_Crazy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Peterborough
Posts: 5,106
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Send a message via MSN to Wicked_and_Crazy Send a message via Yahoo to Wicked_and_Crazy
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Quote:
Originally Posted by zinglebarb
Is it branded or generic? whatever it is take it back and if its generic slap your own wrists you should have known better
nothing wrong with generic if its the correct spec for the mobo
Wicked_and_Crazy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:40   #6
Druchii
cf.mega poster
 
Druchii's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Oslo, Norway.
Age: 37
Services: Canal Digital: 50/10
Posts: 7,577
Druchii has a nice shiny star
Druchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny star
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

No problem, worth noting though, my memory by Infineon and Nanya has never had any erors, which shows that you can get lucky buying generic. Next PC will either be Corsair or Crucial.
Druchii is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:44   #7
Wicked_and_Crazy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Peterborough
Posts: 5,106
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Send a message via MSN to Wicked_and_Crazy Send a message via Yahoo to Wicked_and_Crazy
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Quote:
Originally Posted by Druchii
No problem, worth noting though, my memory by Infineon and Nanya has never had any erors, which shows that you can get lucky buying generic. Next PC will either be Corsair or Crucial.
i bought Kingston last time and had notihng but trouble. However their tech support were brilliant and they sorted the problem quite quickly
Wicked_and_Crazy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:45   #8
Druchii
cf.mega poster
 
Druchii's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Oslo, Norway.
Age: 37
Services: Canal Digital: 50/10
Posts: 7,577
Druchii has a nice shiny star
Druchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny starDruchii has a nice shiny star
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wicked_and_Crazy
i bought Kingston last time and had notihng but trouble. However their tech support were brilliant and they sorted the problem quite quickly
I have a 128Mb stick of Kingston ValueRam in my other PC, works like a dream too. I suppose it all depends on wheteher it's set to the correct timings and whether the mobo even supports it correctly.

May i ask what was wrong in the end?
Druchii is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:54   #9
Wicked_and_Crazy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Peterborough
Posts: 5,106
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Send a message via MSN to Wicked_and_Crazy Send a message via Yahoo to Wicked_and_Crazy
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Quote:
Originally Posted by Druchii
I have a 128Mb stick of Kingston ValueRam in my other PC, works like a dream too. I suppose it all depends on wheteher it's set to the correct timings and whether the mobo even supports it correctly.

May i ask what was wrong in the end?
Mine was Knigston Value ram too. Using the Kingston Memory selector tool to determine which sticks i needed i ordered memory. It didnt work, they replaced it with the same sticks but different version. Apparenlty the MOBO i have is a bit finicky
Wicked_and_Crazy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:56   #10
zing_deleted
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

I would argue that generic should be left alone and value ram used instead its hardly any more
  Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 21:59   #11
Wicked_and_Crazy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Peterborough
Posts: 5,106
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Send a message via MSN to Wicked_and_Crazy Send a message via Yahoo to Wicked_and_Crazy
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Quote:
Originally Posted by zinglebarb
I would argue that generic should be left alone and value ram used instead its hardly any more
from experience, value ram didnt work. As long as its the correct spec it should still work
Wicked_and_Crazy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 22:04   #12
zing_deleted
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

well from my experience and a lot of ram has passed through my hands the generic ram such as elixier has a much higher failure rate from new than any branded value ie kingston/corsair in fact ive had countless trucks to my suppliers with generic when it was crazy prices and just 1 stick of corsair go on 6 years of building pcs
  Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 22:06   #13
Wicked_and_Crazy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Peterborough
Posts: 5,106
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Send a message via MSN to Wicked_and_Crazy Send a message via Yahoo to Wicked_and_Crazy
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Quote:
Originally Posted by zinglebarb
well from my experience and a lot of ram has passed through my hands the generic ram such as elixier has a much higher failure rate from new than any branded value ie kingston/corsair in fact ive had countless trucks to my suppliers with generic when it was crazy prices and just 1 stick of corsair go on 6 years of building pcs
perhaps passing it through your hands is the problem
Wicked_and_Crazy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 22:08   #14
zing_deleted
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

well if you read back my threads from long ago you will see ive always taken precautions
  Reply With Quote
Old 27-06-2006, 22:10   #15
Wicked_and_Crazy
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Peterborough
Posts: 5,106
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Wicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny starWicked_and_Crazy has a nice shiny star
Send a message via MSN to Wicked_and_Crazy Send a message via Yahoo to Wicked_and_Crazy
Re: Memory Issues - MEMTEST86+ vs Windows Memory Diagnostics Tool

Quote:
Originally Posted by zinglebarb
well if you read back my threads from long ago you will see ive always taken precautions
wasnt questioning if you were pregnant
Wicked_and_Crazy is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:22.


Server: lithium.zmnt.uk
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum