View Single Post
Old 15-11-2003, 23:21   #88
Chris
Trollsplatter
Cable Forum Team
 
Chris's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: North of Watford
Services: Humane elimination of all common Internet pests
Posts: 38,612
Chris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden aura
Chris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden auraChris has a golden aura
Re: What happens when you die?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Drudge
It can be shown that religious beliefs are positively irrational, that several parts of the theological doctrine are inconsistent with one another.
Christians claim the following
It's late, I'm tired, I don't know why I'm bothering to answer this but here goes anyway ... guess I'm too stupid not to. Seeing as Drudge has made the explicit claim 'Christians claim the following', I am going to try to give a Christian answer. I make no apologies for the assumptions I am about to make about the nature of the universe. Just bear with me.

1) God is omnipotent (i.e., all-powerful).
correct.

2) God is omniscient (i.e., all-knowing).
yep.

3) God is perfectly good.
Still on track here.

4) Evil exists.
clearly, it does. So still full marks.

5) Any two or three of them might be true at the same time; but there was no way that all of them could be true.
And you were doing so well. Let's see how you back up this bold statement of opinion.

6) If God is omnipotent, he would be able to prevent all of the evil and suffering in the world.
He is capable of doing this and has made adequate arrangements. See below.

7) If God is omniscient, he would know about all of the evil and suffering in the world and would know how to eliminate or prevent it.
He is fully aware, and has already done everything necessary to put a stop to it.

8) If God is perfectly good, he would want to prevent all of the evil and suffering in the world.
He is, and he does. In fact, he has already taken steps to address this.

Statements (6) to (8) jointly imply that if the perfect God existed, there would not be any evil or suffering. However, as we all know, our world is filled with a staggering amount of evil and suffering. If we think about (6) to (8) in light of the fact of evil and suffering in our world, we should be led to the following conclusions:
Now, I just know your conclusions are going to be skewed, because the statement above makes absolutely no attempt to give God a chance to explain himself and his actions. You can't sum up the prosecution before the defence has had a chance to answer the charges. If you are as well-read as you say you are, you could very easily have dropped in the answers a number of religions give to the points you have raised, before telling us all why you disagree with them. The fact that you have not done this is very telling. In fact, all you have done is state some observations about the world, and then claimed (very boldly indeed) that God must address them in the way you see fit if you are to accept his claims to omniscience, omnipotence, etc.

9) If God knows about all of the evil and suffering in the world, knows how to eliminate or prevent it, is powerful enough to prevent it, and yet does not prevent it, he must not be perfectly good.
True, although as I said above you have not mentioned any of the possible 'answers' to this provided by religions. Let me give you the answer from my religion, Christianity, seeing as that is the religion you set out to address. God knows about evil, answered it by offering eternal life through his son Jesus, and gives it to anyone who asks. Evil persists in the world because people refuse to take the remedy, not because God is powerless to offer one.

10) If God knows about all of the evil and suffering, knows how to eliminate or prevent it, wants to prevent it, and yet does not do so, he must not be all- powerful.
Having absolute power is one thing. Using it with absolute wisdom is something else. The USA is getting a hammering in another thread on this forum for 'imposing' its view of things on another sovreign nation, regardless of the fact that a great deal of evil is being done in that nation (Iraq). 'The ends don't justify the means' is a common theme. So would you be happy if God just forced his way of doing things on you? I thought not.

11) If God is powerful enough to prevent all of the evil and suffering, wants to do so, and yet does not, he must not know about all of the suffering or know how to eliminate or prevent itâ₠¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â€šÂ¬Ã‚that is, he must not be all-knowing.
You are dancing yourself round in philosophical circles, but as I've been illustrating above, your previous statements are based on some very false assumptions indeed. If your previous statements are untrue, then this conclusion is completely wide of the mark. As is what follows:

From (9) to (11) we can state:
12) If evil and suffering exist, then God is either not omnipotent, not omniscient, or not perfectly good.

Since evil and suffering obviously do exist, we get:
13) God is either not omnipotent, not omniscient, or not perfectly good.

Putting the point more bluntly, this line of argument suggests thatââ‚ ¬Ã¢â‚¬Âin light of the evil and suffering we find in our worldââ‚ÆšÂ¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â€šÂ¬Ã‚if God exists, he is either impotent, ignorant or wicked.

It is obvious that (13) conflicts with (1) to (3) above.

To make the conflict more clear, we can combine (1), (2) and (3) into the following single statement.

14) God is omnipotent, omniscient and perfectly good.

Statement (14) is simply the conjunction of (1) to (3) and expresses the central belief of christian.

There is no way that (13) and (14) could both be true at the same time. These statements are contradictory.

Philosophers have always believed it is never rational to believe something contradictory. So, the existence of evil and suffering makes christians' belief in the existence of a perfect God IRRATIONAL.


It's very clever, the way you spin a complex web of interdependent statements, which build into a set of contradictions which are then easy for you to 'prove' irrational. It's just a pity you didn't spend the time actually reading what the Bible says about these issues instead. Your statement (13) is false, and is based on a set of unsubstantiated assumptions on your part, due either to ignorance of or unwillingness to acknowledge what the Bible says on the subject. Like it or not, the Bible is the authoritative source here, as you claim to be discussing the Christian worldview.

So, as (13) is not true, there is no contradiction with (14), which is true, and I can sleep sound at night knowing that I have a Lord in heaven who I will meet one day.
Chris is offline   Reply With Quote