Having played across all of your choices and a few more, I would say that it was down to 1, pc, end of, yes, the controls can be a bit overwelming on some games but when you get the basic move configs off to a tee then there's no beating a pc IMHO, I have an xbox that has only ever played one game

splinter cell, enjoyed it but then got into CoD, Moh etc etc tomb raider........I could go on, at the end of the day, its down to personal choice