[sherer]

well i've got to say I agree with alot of what Keano says..

despite what the papers say Van Der Sar punches the ball too many times.. do they not realise that if the ball is in your hands no one can touch it but if you punch it it can go in the back of the net.. he's looked shakey a few times

O'Shea 0 has looked rubbish every since his first season when he could do no wrong.. can't believe he was offered a new contract

Fletcher - does well in the odd game then goes missing but never been given a clear defined role for us yet

Ferdinand - never really delivered on his price tag or weekly wages.. happy to get the money and not bothered about putting the effort in

Richardson - not a defender anyway and not great as a winger. might look good at West Brom but not Man U class

Smith- the only one i don't agree with.. he's been played out of position all season but his levels of commitment and passion but the rest of the team to shame.. if he could learn the Keane roll will do a job for us

add in

Scholes - no confidence and showing poor form for the past 2 years

Giggs - plays well in one game every 3 years.. if that

Ronaldo - to greedy and wants to dive all the time ( abit of a Forlan player here.. but him in Spain and will be brilliant each week ) still not really a replacement for Beckham