View Single Post
Old 31-10-2005, 08:13   #56
andyl
Guest
 
Location: Bury
Services: NTL 2MB Broadband, x2 phones, digi TV.
Posts: n/a
Re: vandals at it again

Quote:
Originally Posted by timewarrior2001
But he isnt attacking is he, if these people were on HIS property, causing damage to HIS property then he is defending HIS property. It matters not that he may have been waiting for them to do this.
Under English law you can use reasonable force if you believe either you or your property is at risk. Belting someone with a baseball bat would not be classed as over use of force.
Obviously if you decided to mash their skull to a pulpy mess with fragments of brain tissue for afters it would be deamed so, but belting the git on the arm and perhaps breaking his arm is NOT.
repeatedly smashing a bat into someones face would be too much force, swinging and connecting once would not be.
The attacker does not have to be armed, you can defend yourself and your property if you believe it or yourself is at risk. If it turns out there was no risk that does not outlaw your already achieved actions.

Why dont we look at the people commiting crimes and getting that stopped rather than trying to blame the ordinary person for defending what they have worked bloody hard for.
Why does it make me sick to my stomach that some people really believe that criminals are just misguided but the innocent person defending himself and family is an horrific criminal that should strung up.
It bloody well does matter if he's lying in wait. I have no problem with people genuinely defending themselves or their families. Attacking vandals with baseball bats does not fit that bill, especially if that attack is pre-meditated (and I don't care if he lies to the police; it's the action that's deplorable).

Frankly I'm disgusted that people can openly express such a love of violence - however much they dress it up as being a just reacton to criminal activity - and that CF provides a platform for such thuggish nonsense.
__________________

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nidge
Well that Ex con is telling you lies, I can confirm that inmates get their own cells with en suite, playstations, SKY TV and all the other mod cons that go with it. What happend to the real prison with bars on the windows and a bucket to do your stuff in? If the prisons were like that they wouldn't commit crime would they?
Which prison are we talking about here? Not any of the three I've been to, though these were not open prisons designed to hold low risk prisoners and those nearing the end of their sentences who the Prison Service is trying to prepare for a return to society.
  Reply With Quote