View Single Post
Old 21-10-2005, 15:36   #33
andyl
Guest
 
Location: Bury
Services: NTL 2MB Broadband, x2 phones, digi TV.
Posts: n/a
Re: Victory for Common Sense

Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris T
In court, the prosecution can press for bail to be denied, or granted only on certain conditions, and they can submit expert testimony to back up their demands. You never hear much about it in the media because reporting of bail arguments is largely prohibited by law. However, where the BBC says that "bail conditions imposed by the court and social services..." I take that to mean that Social Services were pushing for the conditions that were imposed, through the prosecution. Magistrates are not legal experts. They are advised on the law by the court clerk and then weigh up the arguments from the legal representatives in the same way a Jury does. I don't imagine many magistrates would stray far from advice from social services, not least because in my experience, a good number of magistrates are also local councillors (county, district or parish), so they know who the social services people are!
Well my question would be why were Social Services pushing for such conditions? Having said that my partner has to work with out local SS and she's not in the least bit impressed, though that's more to do with there shirking of care responsibilities than, say, being overly cautious.

Magistrates for their part presumably assess the need, or otherwise, for such bail conditions, something for which they are trained.
  Reply With Quote