View Single Post
Old 31-05-2005, 14:01   #110
etccarmageddon
Inactive
 
etccarmageddon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Manchester
Posts: 5,638
etccarmageddon has a nice shiny star
etccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny staretccarmageddon has a nice shiny star
Re: Star Wars EP3 Discussion WARNING: SPOILERS

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt D
Not so sure about having the Deathstar in it. Would it really take them another 18 years to build it?...
perhaps that scene was set 10 years in the future.


I did like the way the film worked. The only flaw is in the motivation/reasons why Anakin realligned his allegance to be with the dark side - simple dialog changes could have sorted this out. After he helped Palpatine defeat Mace Windu, the dialog from Palpatine should have been along the lines of "Anakin, the Jedi will kill you for defending me, you will have to choose either to stand with me of face a Jedi death sentence.". That should have been the hook that takes him to the dark side.

The fight between Yoda and Sidious was brilliant especially the symbolism of fighting within the democratic chambers - democrasy litterally being destroyed as Sidious throws the seats at Yoda.


Of course we all agree crushing the Jedi revolt was the first step towards ending global terrorism and the new empire will ensure and secure long term peace and stability!
etccarmageddon is offline   Reply With Quote