They aren't exactly loading instantly but they do load. Unlike your site though, they seem to be basic forum installs without many hacks and mods. Have you tried removing your hacks etc to see if load times return to normal? Also do you have any advertising on the site which may be trying to use pop ups etc?
__________________
Just loaded it in IE on server 2003 and it behaved very strangely, a couple of times it loaded fine but it gave a few "Page cannot be displayed" errors and on a couple of occassions it loaded, the page flashed blank a couple of times and then it settled back on the page and spontaneously reloaded

Anyone been tinkering with the site coding that might have de-stabilised it since it's install?