Please don't shoot me down if this has been suggested before, but...
For those people who have used their cards on the internet (most of us, right?), is it possible that we share (or shared) a common ISP?
Up until just recently I used Freeserve Anytime.
Presumably there are means of hooking into a dial-up network and using packet-sniffing tools to harvest unencrypted data as it passes by on its way to the great blue yonder (i.e. some other part of the internet). I'm not sure if one dial-up subscriber could do this to another, but it would surely be possible for somebody working for an ISP to do this...
I know this would suggest organised crime, but why shouldn't it be organised. If there's money to be made, you can bet that an organisation will be formed to combine the skills (3xtr3m3 or otherwise

) of like-thinking people to maximise returns.
I'll go back to watching this forum now