View Single Post
Old 30-04-2005, 16:40   #56
Graham
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Re: Designer babies Lords give thumbs up

Quote:
Originally Posted by Russ D
[ So how do you decide if someone should know better or not? How can you be sure that that person cannot make the decision for themselves? Someone has to make that decision for the good of the individual.
Err, excuse me???

You do not "decide if someone should know better or not" as a sort of pro-active decision!

We don't have (nor should we have) competency tests to decide if someone is capable of making a decision or not on a "moral" (or whatever) issue, we *presume* their "innocence" ie that they are capable of doing so.

Or would you prefer we have a sort of "Department of Pre-Crime" putting people on a lie detector and asking them "do you want to have sex with a child?" and locking up anyone who failed??

Quote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Graham
As I said in my original comment: "if nobody's getting hurt by it."
So who are you to decide that "nobody's getting hurt"?
Where did *I* say that *I* was the one to make this decision??
  Reply With Quote