View Single Post
Old 13-03-2005, 17:44   #237
Graham
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Re: Muslims should expect to be stopped....

Quote:
Originally Posted by me283
Quote:
Originally Posted by Graham
When the UK first started "importing" workers from the West Indies back in the 1950s there were similar claims that these "coloureds" would form their own "separate cultures" in our cities etc etc.

Somehow, however, it seems that they've become integrated into our society without creating "blacks only" communities.
The big difference is that the Muslim culture is very different from or own,
And that's a bad thing? We seem to be trying to export "Western Culture" all over the world which is also "very different" from the indigenous cultures. Is that also a bad thing and should be stopped?

Or is it a case of "Us: Good. Them: Bad"?

Quote:
not least in that they fundamentally oppose some things that most of us take for granted,
What about all those British ex-Pats out in the Middle East etc who want to drink alcohol against Islamic law? Somehow the Muslim communities seem to have come to an accommodation with them, why can't we do the same with the Muslims here?

Quote:
and many have fought long and hard to achieve.
You mean like not being locked up without charge? The right to challenge evidence in court? The right not to be restricted in your own home on the say-so of a politician...???

Quote:
And by the way, there are actually a lot of "blacks only" communities in the UK.
Care to back that claim up with anything? Yes, there are areas which have high levels of black occupancy, but we're not talking about "no go" areas for whites or "ghettos".

Quote:
Re: your comment about Xaccers, what's that got to do with anything?
It was a belated response to a comment that I meant to make earlier but forgot, so it got tagged on this message.
__________________

Quote:
Originally Posted by timewarrior2001
I really dont see any alternative to random stopping.
I do. It's called "Intelligence based Policing" ie using intelligence (in both senses of the word!) so you don't end up harassing innocent people based solely on what they look like or how they dress or where they pray.

Quote:
Theres a threat from the islamic quarter, youre certainly not going to waste time picking on non islamics so you dont appear racist.
The point is you don't "pick on" *any* group. If you have *reasonable* grounds for stopping someone, that's a different matter from "he looks suspiciously Muslim".

Quote:
And thats the problem, because of certain liberal attitudes, trying to protect innocents of all races, the authorities are branded racist. I still cant figure that out.

Its not like theres a quota, stop 5 non muslims for every 5 muslims. It doesnt work that way and it simply cant work that way.
It seems clear that you can't figure it out because your last paragraph is nonsensical.

Of *course* it can't work that way, but neither can it work, as I keep pointing out, that you simply stop someone based on their religion, looks, clothes etc!

Quote:
We have to do what we can to prevent an attrocity on the scale of 9/11. Some people wont like it, but its tough,
And once again I have little doubt that Osama Bin Laden and friends are sitting in their caves, watching satellite TV and laughing as we throw away the liberties that make our society *FREE* and which they hate so much.

Quote:
I'd much rather feel safe walking the streets visiting landmarks etc than worry about whether my police force was being racist by stopping the people that fit the description.
I'm sure you would, but once again I point out, *YOU* are unlikely to be stopped or harassed, so again it seems a case of "I'm alright, Jack, it's ok to hassle people who aren't *me* so long as *I* feel safe".

Quote:
Look what happened in Gibraltar, all intel stated the IRA were going to kill soldiers and most likely innocent civillians, the SAS shot them dead. Subsequent investigation revealed no remote detonating device. And wow did the liberals cry over that one, you murdered them.
Yes, because what happened was sheer, cold blooded murder, nothing else.

Quote:
Hang on a minute, these people were IRA terrorists, what were the SAS supposed to do, take the risk they were on holiday? Wait for them to kill before taking action? These people were considered armed and extremely dangerous, hence the reason the SAS were called in in the first place.
If these people were *known* IRA terrorists (which they were, as you admit) and they were on UK soil (which, again, you admit they were) they could have been *arrested* for being members of an illegal organisation.

Yet the *excuse* the SAS gave was that "they thought they were going for a gun or a detonator" when challenged, but that simply smacks of incompetence because it would have been possible to isolate and detain all of the victims with proper planning and manpower had they *really* wanted to arrest them.

You appear to think that it's ok to blast people down on the street simply on suspicion, yet if the SAS had been following them for as long as they said, they could have isolated the possible threat of a car bomb and taken the suspects into custody instead of gunning them down.

Quote:
Was it racist because they stopped the Irish, were they racist because the gunned down white people?
Or were they simply doing their job ?
Who said anything about the SAS being "racist"? The Gibraltar murders had nothing to do with race at all. Please don't suggest that they did and please try to stay on topic.
__________________

Quote:
Originally Posted by me283
And I think (correct me if I'm wrong) that in Gibraltar they actually did find explosives in a car, although as you rightly point out no detonating device.
This is an interesting one because searching on this gives results varying from there were "no explosives found" to "no explosives but another car had the equipment to make a detonator" to "140 lbs of high explosives were found".

Quote:
It stands to reason, if there are Muslims who are known to be terrorists, or terrorists who are known to be Muslims, then a good place to look for them might be in the Muslim community. You don't try buying a loaf of bread in a shoe shop, do you?
I don't know about you, but when I go out to buy a loaf of bread, I *already* have some idea of what sort of bread I am going to buy, eg Brown Wholemeal.

I don't go into the bakers and examine *EVERY SINGLE* loaf of bread before I decide "hmm, I'll take this one" and I think the baker would get rather annoyed were I to handle and examine and taste each one...!
__________________

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xaccers
Graham, with regards to the red rep you've given me, exactly how old are you???
Answered by PM to keep the discussion on topic.