Quote:
Originally Posted by OLD BOY
What are you on about? Yes, there are jobs that the Brits tend not to want to do, such as fruit picking. We must not create an immigration policy that does not take into account the need for employers to employ people from overseas where it is impossible to recruit people from within the UK. That stands to reason, doesn't it? All I am saying is that we don't want to let people in who are going to steal the jobs that our own people with the appropriate skills are willing and able to do - that simply drives down wages and creates unemployment.
I don't see that constituting mistreatment. There are separate laws to cover that, anyway.
---------- Post added at 07:25 ---------- Previous post was at 07:18 ----------
The Acquired Rights Directive (the basis for our TUPE Regulations)
The Working Time Directive
The General Data Protection Regulations...
To name but three. All of these regulations take a sledgehammer to crack a nut. The basic principlefor each might have merit, but then they have so much bureaucracy and jargonistic language around them that the whole thing becomes a drag.
Most employers do not understand legislation from the EU and need an army of lawyers to interpret it. UK law can be an ass, but it was never like this.
---------- Post added at 07:27 ---------- Previous post was at 07:25 ----------
No, he's not, and I've just answered it. Sometimes it can be tiresome having to explain the obvious, that's all.
---------- Post added at 07:30 ---------- Previous post was at 07:27 ----------
Well, given that we have close to full employment in this country and only a small proportion of them are zero hours contracts, you wouldn't have to accept such employment.
---------- Post added at 07:33 ---------- Previous post was at 07:30 ----------
Yes it is, and they want to do it what's more. What's your solution? Who do you think should be doing these jobs?
If you are going to keep criticising like this, you need to come up with alternative solutions. But you don't...
---------- Post added at 07:36 ---------- Previous post was at 07:33 ----------
[/B]
I disagree with you there. However, some employers have been abusing this, which is why we need to ensure that unfair practices are outlawed.
Zero hours contracts (which we used to call 'casual employment) can be useful to both employer and employee as they provide flexibility. However, they are not suitable for those who want stable hours and a stable income.
|
If you're unemployed, and there's a role such as picking fruit. then unless there's a medical or other valid reason for not taking the position then you should take and do the the job. That is simple.
There are some genuine reasons for people who can't do roles such as fruit or vegetable picking, yhere are also some people with no work ethic or aptitude for hard work. These people should not get to decide what type of job they want.
By saying that unemployed British people can reject a job because they don't want it but saying it's acceptable for a migrant to do it. you are creating a two tier system. People will be treat differently because of this. I have seen it many times before.
Regarding your comment on there are suitable laws to cover mistreatment, they also have them in Singapore, China & Australia but that doesn't stop the inherent racism towards migrant workers
From the Belfast Telegraph;
February 9 2018
Britain’s horticulture farms suffered a 12.5% shortfall in seasonal workers in 2017 as numbers coming from continental Europe fell, it has been revealed.
The first full year following the Brexit referendum was the first time since the National Farmers Union began compiling figures in 2014 that growers were unable to recruit sufficient workers.
Opponents of Brexit said the figures proved that the Government’s position on EU withdrawal had resulted in fruit and vegetables being left to rot for lack of workers to pick them.
The NFU’s labour survey for December 2017 showed a shortfall of 15.6% in the number of seasonal workers in the horticultural sector that month, bringing the average over the course of the year to 12.5%.
The worst month was September, when growers reported a 29.3% shortage at a time when many crops are being harvested.
Over the course of the year, some 30,585 out of 34,962 seasonal vacancies were filled.
bpanews_74641ecf-aa87-4bea-942c-f669c75d0bc5_embedded297543
Recruitment of seasonal workers in UK horticulture farms. (National Farmers Union labour survey, December 2017)
Almost 67% of seasonal workers were from Romania and Bulgaria, with 32% from eight other EU countries in eastern and central Europe.
Fewer than 1% of the seasonal workers carrying out jobs such as fruit-picking were UK nationals – 169 individuals in the survey.
NFU deputy president Minette Batters said: “It is clear that solutions are still needed to ensure that farmers and growers have access to sufficient numbers of workers for both forthcoming seasons and post-Brexit.
“Access to both seasonal and permanent workers is crucial across all farming sectors and they are incredibly important to ensuring farmers can continue producing food to feed the nation.
“The NFU’s survey of labour providers shows that the availability of workers continues to tighten and I would urge Government to find a solution for the whole industry that ensures it has access to the people it needs.”
Green MP Caroline Lucas, a leading supporter of the Open Britain campaign for close ties with the EU, said: “The Government’s zealotry on Brexit and immigration is leading to a crisis in the British fruit industry.
“Fruit and veg is literally being left to rot in the fields because workers from the EU are increasingly unwilling to work here thanks to Brexit.”
The “minuscule” proportion of seasonal farm workers being recruited in the UK showed that it was “wishful thinking” to believe that local employees could fill the gap left by absent EU nationals, she said.
But according to you were in a position for British people for somehow to be above the role of fruit and veg picking?
I'm quite looking forward to watching people who have no work ethic crying after being in a field picking carrots for one hour....
Finally, exactly what jobs are migrant workers taking from the British?
'Sorry Dave with your GCSEs the reason you can't be a hospital porter isn't because you can't be bothered to get up on time or attend work trials, or even answer the phone to the DWP is because some migrant came over here and dared to work hard, showed willing and aptitude'