Damien

Scotland's NHS is a different organisation so I don't think English people pay (we might do for Wales however). It's also absurd to suggest Scotland would be 'Europe's first third world country'. Scotland currently contributes more than it gets so it won't suddenly find itself in dire circumstances if they vote Yes.

However I think they won't be able to afford what the SNP are promising, that they'll need to find alternative sources of income when the Oil becomes too expensive to extract (and alternative energy may not be enough to compensate), and that their currency plans are flawed.