[qasdfdsaq]

I think you've misunderstood the ASA regulations. The ones we're talking about pertain to usage limits and usage limits only. Nothing to do with traffic management, shaping, or limiting. That's a completely different aspect of the service and covered by completely different guidelines.

As for the consistency, well clearly it isn't consistent if your results are completely different to mine. Last I was on 40/10 P2P was limited to 3Mbps upload some weeks and no limit at all other weeks. Since upgrading to 80/20 it's either 3Mbps or 20Mbps upload and I haven't seen anything in between.

As far as I'm concerned for unlimited products the only limitations that have to be clearly described or absent are usage based limits. Non-usage based limits that apply the same nomatter what service a user's on or how much they used, are entirely irrelevant.

And finally, no, the reason you can't do 200mph is not because of road laws, it's because you don't expect to be able to all the time. There is no road law saying you can never do 200, there are plenty of roads with no speed limits, both in this country and elsewhere. People are used to and fully expect that there will be other limitations in place, and that is perfectly normal. The same goes for your internet connection, everybody expects there will be limitations to most of the time on any service that have nothing to do with your utilization.