Well the defy+ (not the older defy) doesn't have an OLED screen like the galaxy, it does have a hi res LCD one though (854 x 480 pixels)
OLED screens aren't that great anyway, as they only function super efficiently if you use only dark colours, once you inject a bit of colour or white, the super efficient turns to super inefficient..
Here are the original phone specs (incredible S)
http://www.gsmarena.com/htc_incredible_s-3788.php
and the moto defy+ specs here so you can directly compare
http://www.gsmarena.com/motorola_defy+-4098.php
It doesn't have much wasted space around the edges so you get a relatively large screen without having this huge thing in your hands
It DOESN'T have a back cover made out of uhmm paper though unlike the galaxy, nor will it snap in half if you breathe heavily on it.
In fact the only real drawback I've found is that it doesn't have a front camera for video chat.
and Galaxy S II here
http://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_i910..._s_ii-3621.php