Judge Birse has issued a statement (it is on link below)
http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWPCC/2011/6.html
...having speed read it (so not definately accurate) a synopsis would be:-
It seems to be pretty much everything we could have hoped for
...it questions the NPO process was carried out correctly
....it questions the IP address collection process
....it questions how "collecting" an IP address actually proves anything
....it questions the validity of Mediacat`s right to actually claim anything
...it absolutely dam`s crossley`s conduct
...........and more to come in March
think we all deserve a drink tonight