[Perfect Choice]

Everybody has their own view, personally the V+ is far superior to Sky+HD for me as the additional tuner is of high priority to me, would never have a Sky+ for that issue alone. Its all down to perception and what is really important to you, I have a SA V+ which is reliable and responsive so don't have the slow EPG issue others have had, so I suppose I am lucky as well.

Lets just say each have their strengths where the only one of significance to me on Sky+ is the better looking EPG and larger HDD, which will not be the case now from how Tivo appears to me + larger HDD as well.