Cable Forum - View Single Post

Lord Nikon · 30-05-2010, 23:20

So far each of the doctors has brought a little something special to the role.

William Hartnell - Old Professor, with a darker side
Patrick Troughton - Clown but knows more than he reveals.
Jon Pertwee - Action Doctor, not afraid of using venusian martial arts.
Tom Baker - Brought an alien touch to the doctor, more mystery
Peter Davidson - Lighter side of the doctor, Not the strongest doctor, but did well
Colin Baker - Dark side of the doctor
Sylvester McCoy - Circus clown doctor
Paul McGann - Doctor who follows his heart
Christopher Ecclestone - The broken doctor who has seen and lost too much, finding love and losing it.
David Tennant - Doctor healing his heart, lonely but determined not to fail
Matt Smith - meh.

Oh, and for the 2 Doctor Who films with Peter Cushing - He was obviously replacing hartnell so see hartnell for a reference.

I can't see what Matt Smith has brought to the role that none of the others have. He seems to have tried to amalgamate several doctors, and missed.

30-05-2010, 23:20	#261
Lord Nikon Inactive Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: NW UK Posts: 3,546	Re: Doctor Who : Season 5 So far each of the doctors has brought a little something special to the role. William Hartnell - Old Professor, with a darker side Patrick Troughton - Clown but knows more than he reveals. Jon Pertwee - Action Doctor, not afraid of using venusian martial arts. Tom Baker - Brought an alien touch to the doctor, more mystery Peter Davidson - Lighter side of the doctor, Not the strongest doctor, but did well Colin Baker - Dark side of the doctor Sylvester McCoy - Circus clown doctor Paul McGann - Doctor who follows his heart Christopher Ecclestone - The broken doctor who has seen and lost too much, finding love and losing it. David Tennant - Doctor healing his heart, lonely but determined not to fail Matt Smith - meh. Oh, and for the 2 Doctor Who films with Peter Cushing - He was obviously replacing hartnell so see hartnell for a reference. I can't see what Matt Smith has brought to the role that none of the others have. He seems to have tried to amalgamate several doctors, and missed.