Quote:
Originally Posted by martyh
no-one was asked to comment on one specific incident just comment on bad parents/unruly children in general ...the ones without disorders
|
Actually we were asked to comment on a specific incident. The OP's first sentence was this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Welshchris
Isnt it a wonder that there are so many idiots on the streets now when Parents cant be bothered to correct their kids...
|
... and afterwards he used a
specific incident that he had just witnessed as 'evidence' for his generalisation.
The obvious weakness of his argument is that it is based on one incident, whose background we're unaware of. In arguing that point, commenting on the specific incident is unavoidable.