Cable Forum - View Single Post - Digital Economy Act 2010 [Was "DE Bill Not Passed, BiS Consulting Already"]

Chrysalis · 06-04-2010, 12:34

as I said before we need to agree to disagree.

3rd and final time a letter with an ip address gathered from a torrent tracker and time is 'not' evidence a court would accept, hence them lobbying the government to bypass legal process. You disagree with me which is fine, but there is no point in trying to make me change the way I see this.

End of the day an isp can terminate who they want for any reason after all it is their service, why would I have a problem with this?

You seriously cannot see a difference between an isp choosing to terminate a customer and a 3rd party been able to force them to do so? Sorry but from where I sit all you thinking about is the well been of the media industry.

Not only this but you chose to put in bold some information I already know and is nothing to do with what I said. The isp is obligated to pass on the report, that is not saying the isp can check the evidence and dispute it on behalf of the customer, it says exactly the opposite that the isp without question has to pass on the report even if false. Also isp's are agreeing with me and they do this for a living.

06-04-2010, 12:34	#59
Chrysalis cf.mega poster Join Date: Sep 2003 Posts: 12,047	re: Digital Economy Act 2010 [Was "DE Bill Not Passed, BiS Consulting Already"] as I said before we need to agree to disagree. 3rd and final time a letter with an ip address gathered from a torrent tracker and time is 'not' evidence a court would accept, hence them lobbying the government to bypass legal process. You disagree with me which is fine, but there is no point in trying to make me change the way I see this. End of the day an isp can terminate who they want for any reason after all it is their service, why would I have a problem with this? You seriously cannot see a difference between an isp choosing to terminate a customer and a 3rd party been able to force them to do so? Sorry but from where I sit all you thinking about is the well been of the media industry. Not only this but you chose to put in bold some information I already know and is nothing to do with what I said. The isp is obligated to pass on the report, that is not saying the isp can check the evidence and dispute it on behalf of the customer, it says exactly the opposite that the isp without question has to pass on the report even if false. Also isp's are agreeing with me and they do this for a living.