View Single Post
Old 19-08-2008, 21:46   #162
Phormic Acid
Inactive
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Services: Still to decide on Aquiss or Be
Posts: 62
Phormic Acid is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Britain's six largest ISPs and BPI join forces to attack illegal filesharing

Quote:
Originally Posted by Maggy J View Post
Simple! I don't file share and the police are perfectly free to look at my PC and all my records...And then I'll get my brother-in-law who is a solicitor onto their case...
It wouldn’t be the police, but a private firm that Davenport Lyons choose and you don’t object to, presumably Logistep AG. Unlike yourself, I doubt that Isabella Barwinska has a brother-in-law expert in English copyright law. Similarly, I have no relatives suitably qualified. And, I do object to having to give up all electronic privacy for something so relatively unimportant. This is not a criminal matter.

If it were to follow the American model, you’d also have to give a list of all your friends and family who could possibly have accessed your computer or network connection, so they can all be vigorously pursued. I don’t know if an English court would allow that or not. It’s also not clear whether you’d be liable in a case where your security had been compromised. Davenport Lyons’ position has been that you are.
Phormic Acid is offline   Reply With Quote