[orangebird]

Originally Posted by Neil

Thanks for that-I find getting personal always help a discussion.

I wasn't getting personal, just making an observation

1) What if you simply don't want a phone line from ntl?

Then go to sky, and get a phone line from BT that Sky force you to take

2) What if you have just signed with BT & entered into a contract (3 months is minimum I think) & are happy with the service BT provide?

Then go to Sky or FreeView

3) What if you choose to route your calls elsewhere via CPS through someone like Talk Talk for example, & are happy with the service they provide too?

Then you'll have to go to Sky or FreeView

4) What if you just don't want to switch telco providers just to get DTV?

Then you'll have to go to Sky or Freeview

5) What about if you want CLI & ntl don't offer it in your area?

Then stay with BT and get Sky or Freeview

6) What about if you have ADSL on your existing BT line & don't want to cancel it just for the sake of getting DTV from ntl?

Then get Sky or Freeview

It all comes down to choice,

Good one, I noticed that too - you have a choice to get ntl dtv, but you must have the ntl phone line, or go to sky dtv, but you must have A N OTHER phone line - not much difference in choice to me?
Or you can go to FreeView.

& that is something that ntl do not offer in this situation, so that pretty much craps over your argument.

Not really Neil, as

1) You still haven't addressed the fact (despite THREE members pointing out to you) that you can't get Sky without paying for a telehone line (regardless of supplier).

2) this thread has bugger all to do with what you're arguing about.

3) You omitted FACTS about what else you need to purchase in order to receive Skys DTV, and therefore did not do a fair comparison

4) I don't know what. I'm frankly bored of the same lame arguments. I have stated nothing but FACT and left nothing out at all, you have been very economic with the truth to suit yourself (ie to make ntl look bad).