Another vote here for the Netgear DG834G
List of supported and recommended router/modems for use with AOL:
http://help.aol.co.uk/what-does-aol-...13053809990001
It's pretty simple to hook up.
One thing worth doing is creating an additonal screename & password that you will enter on the routers setup page.
This means that the router signs on as the new screenname but each computer can still access their own screenames.