SLM, based on their 1st half performance, I'd agree with you... and yeah they were lucky to not have conceded anything in the first 45, but Rooney and Park didn't hit the target - due as much to Villa's defence as Rooney's & Park's misfortune (I think Rooney was massively under-performing, whereas Park had a good game overall).
In the 2nd half their performance was worthy of a replay, imo (by the way, I
am a Villa fan, so I am being biased
)
Nug, you're probably right, if we'd had a replay then the result would still have been the same, with United going through instead of us. Would still have been nice to have shut up the Man U fans though