Laptops dont use Deskstars, they use travelstars.
I have three different travelstar drives, 2x 10gb & 1x 40gb and they are all nice, quiet and reliable.
I also have 1x 120GB deskstar can't remember if it is 180GXP or 120GXP and that has been working great in my machine (Wich doubles up as a file server) my machine runs 24/7 and has done so since I had this drive installed over a year and a half ago.
So there