Just announced on the Rage3D forums is that Doom 3 has scored an astounding 94% in the latest issue of PC Gamer, which has just shipped to subscribers. They say the atmosphere rocks and that the graphics are top notch, but the few attempts at humor fall short. Nonetheless, they say it's a must buy!
You can check out a scan of the mag's front cover here:
Click
Rage3D Forum link
Here
Also included is a scan from a GamePro Ad
Notice the "M" rating at the bottom right corner. ESRB usually reviews games subsequent to their completion apparently.
Here