View Single Post
Old 02-02-2004, 20:44   #9
Theodoric
Inactive
 
Theodoric's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: London
Posts: 2,974
Theodoric has reached the bronze age
Theodoric has reached the bronze ageTheodoric has reached the bronze ageTheodoric has reached the bronze ageTheodoric has reached the bronze ageTheodoric has reached the bronze ageTheodoric has reached the bronze ageTheodoric has reached the bronze ageTheodoric has reached the bronze age
Re: was this really a good enough punishment ?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramrod
It may be the law but it's not justice
Very true, but how do you suggest getting around it?

The trouble with laws like "Three strikes and you're out" is that, as the Americans have discovered, people are sentenced to 20 years in jail for stealing a pizza.

Or you can try the Texas method of no clemency for capital offences; the problem there is that people who can't afford good lawyers get landed with some incompetent to defend them and are then executed even though innocent. Of course, if you're willing to accept the occasional innocent, poorer citizen being excuted then there's no problem. Although, again, some US states are finding that executing minors and the mentally incompetent does tend to stick in the gullet.
Theodoric is offline   Reply With Quote