View Single Post
Old 11-01-2004, 12:15   #12
Bifta
Inactive
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Eglinton, Co. Derry
Posts: 7,640
Bifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny star
Bifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny starBifta has a nice shiny star
Re: Are 'warez' really theft?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xaccers
Copyright infringement: yes
Theft: mumble mumble grey area mumble

I know it is probably just a case of symantics, but personally I don't feel it is theft.
If someone goes into PC World and runs off with a copy of Photoshop that's theft. Not because they've got someting physical in their grubby little mitts, but because it was something which had they not stolen, would have been bought by someone who could afford it.

However, if someone gets hold of a copy through warez because they cannot afford to buy it (there's a difference between cannot afford and cannot be bother to buy) then adobe would never make any money from them, so they have not reduced adobe's profits. They have broken the law because of copyright infringement, but they haven't stolen.

If you photo copy a page from a book, have you stolen that page? No, but you may have commited copyright infringement.
But then there are people who might have thought "ok, so it's 600 quid, I'll save up for it .. oh wait, no, there's a copy on Kazaa ... I'll spend my money on fag's and jam!" ... If you can't afford .. do without or find a cheaper alternative (basically)
Bifta is offline   Reply With Quote