Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Security & Virus Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   For Smug Mac Users.... (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=41443)

Chris W 17-01-2006 00:03

For Smug Mac Users....
 
And yes i am one :p:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4609968.stm

Graham M 17-01-2006 00:34

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
His article is Spot on IMO.

ScaredWebWarrior 17-01-2006 08:27

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris W

What he's saying is quite true. Mac users are way too smug about the security of their machines. They'll soon point out that it's Unix and that's why it is so secure.

I'm currently reading "The Cuckoo's Egg" and that is a litany of Unix security flaws and bad system management, showing that Unix can certainly be vulnerable to attack.

And yes, I also own a Mac. (And a PC)

Chris 17-01-2006 09:53

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Mac users aren't just smug about security. They're smug about every aspect of their machines.

But why not, they're better. :)

ScaredWebWarrior 17-01-2006 09:57

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Mac users aren't just smug about security. They're smug about every aspect of their machines.

But why not, they're better. :)

Fair enough - just don't be complacent about it.

The Mac is not invulnerable, and you'll rue the day you assumed it was.

Bifta 17-01-2006 09:57

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Mac users aren't just smug about security. They're smug about every aspect of their machines.

But why not, they're better. :)

But they're not better, the ONLY aspect of a Mac that's better than a PC is it's looks, it's performance is dire in comparison and the hardware is pretty much (other than the CPU, which is normally far less powerful than it's x86 alernative) the same as a PC's.

Chris 17-01-2006 10:26

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ScaredWebWarrior
Fair enough - just don't be complacent about it.

The Mac is not invulnerable, and you'll rue the day you assumed it was.

On the contrary, I run McAfee Virex on it, (even though the virus definitions it uses are almost entirely for PCs, just so I don't accidentally pass on a file that might infect you, even though my own machine is immune) so if any viruses do appear I'll get the definition files and stay clean.

I also ran a software firewall until I bought my router, which is configured to allow nothing through. Complacent I aint. :)

---------- Post added at 10:26 ---------- Previous post was at 10:21 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
But they're not better, the ONLY aspect of a Mac that's better than a PC is it's looks, it's performance is dire in comparison and the hardware is pretty much (other than the CPU, which is normally far less powerful than it's x86 alernative) the same as a PC's.

I have a six-year-old iMac, which runs faster today that it did new. It has 640MB of RAM (shipped with 64MB) and has had two major OS revisions installed since the day it was first switched on with OS 9.0.8 onboard. I'm now on 10.2.8 and am told that 10.3 and 10.4 both brought further efficiencies.

Which versions of Winblows can you point to that were leaner and faster than their predecessors? I thought I was led to believe that each revision of that OS demanded ever more powerful machines to run on? What are the expected specs for Vista?

I find Mac OS to be simpler, more intuitive, more elegant and just generally better designed than Windows. And seeing as the OS governs my day-to-day experience of my computer, I regard that as a pretty major plus point.

Man, I can see which way this thread is going ... :p:

Bifta 17-01-2006 10:52

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
On the contrary, I run McAfee Virex on it, (even though the virus definitions it uses are almost entirely for PCs, just so I don't accidentally pass on a file that might infect you, even though my own machine is immune) so if any viruses do appear I'll get the definition files and stay clean.

I also ran a software firewall until I bought my router, which is configured to allow nothing through. Complacent I aint. :)

---------- Post added at 10:26 ---------- Previous post was at 10:21 ----------



I have a six-year-old iMac, which runs faster today that it did new. It has 640MB of RAM (shipped with 64MB) and has had two major OS revisions installed since the day it was first switched on with OS 9.0.8 onboard. I'm now on 10.2.8 and am told that 10.3 and 10.4 both brought further efficiencies.

Which versions of Winblows can you point to that were leaner and faster than their predecessors? I thought I was led to believe that each revision of that OS demanded ever more powerful machines to run on? What are the expected specs for Vista?

I run Windows XP on a rather old laptop (450mhz as I recall and less ram than you have) and it runs better under XP than it ever did under Windows 95 or 98 so I'm failing to see your point.

If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them? (And don't start on about Microsofts monopoly because you can walk into PC world and pick up a Mac if you like)

bmxbandit 17-01-2006 11:01

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them?

because they're overly expensive.

ScaredWebWarrior 17-01-2006 11:10

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them?

The reasons Macs are so much better (also in my opinion) is almost directly why they're not selling as much as PCs - Seems that software writers prefer using software tools with dumb application wizards to produce bad code for Windows, rather than make the effort to write decent portable software that could be made available on either platform.

Yes, I'm admitting to the fact that the lack of availability of software (specifically, very few PC apps also being supported on Mac) as being a major factor.

Having said that, the way so many people use their PCs, they wouldn't notice this on a Mac - with the exception of games and some specific applications, a MAC offers everything a PC does.

And since I generally give games a wide berth, I find either a Mac or PC can fulfill my needs almost entirely. If either offers something the other hasn't got, then it's either my deep pockets/short arms or laziness (i.e. haven't bothered to look) that's stopped me having everything I need on one platform.

It is also true that a Mac can cost quite a bit more than a decent PC - but most people overlook that the annual hardware upgrade for the PC is not necessary for the Mac - and hence they should see the Mac as a longer term purchase vs the PC as a shorter term purchase. But that's quite a hard sell on the general buying public.

The Mac hardware is genarlly also more reliable, but I have found that my home built PCs are equally as reliable - it seems that the PC bundles are less so, however - and since it's these that most people buy, the reliability issue should also factor in.

As for usability - not much in it, until you consider the opportunities for a PC owner to be overwhelmed by the possibilities to mess up their machine by tweaking 'properties'.

But while kids get all their ICT input at school on a PC, the Mac will always remain a bit of an outsider. (Having said that - watching a 12 yo log into a Linux box with as much confidence as her PC and using it without any instructions, tells me that perhaps this will be less of an issue in 10 years or so.)

Chris 17-01-2006 11:23

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
I run Windows XP on a rather old laptop (450mhz as I recall and less ram than you have) and it runs better under XP than it ever did under Windows 95 or 98 so I'm failing to see your point.

If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them? (And don't start on about Microsofts monopoly because you can walk into PC world and pick up a Mac if you like)

First, please reassure me that you have not, in any way, used your better-than-joe-average knowledge of Windows to streamline your XP install, kill processes you don't need or otherwise change its out-of-the-box configuration. In other words, it's operating in the same way as the overwhelming majority of users experience it.

Second - with the greatest of respect to you, that's a pretty dumb question. You know as well as I do that 'better' is seldom the deciding factor in any format war. I could go on at length about canny marketing early on by IBM (licencing the x86), canny dealing by Bill Gates and similarly bad business at Apple. Somehow I think you already know all this though. :)

Bifta 17-01-2006 11:51

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
First, please reassure me that you have not, in any way, used your better-than-joe-average knowledge of Windows to streamline your XP install, kill processes you don't need or otherwise change its out-of-the-box configuration. In other words, it's operating in the same way as the overwhelming majority of users experience it.

It's not streamlined in any way, straight XP Pro SP2 install direct from CD running on a Dell Inspiron 3700 with 512mb memory (the only upgrade it's ever had), a couple of drivers loaded and that's it, the ONLY thing I've found that hogs it is the .NET framework and I've so far managed to avoid having that installed on my desktop too.



Quote:

Second - with the greatest of respect to you, that's a pretty dumb question. You know as well as I do that 'better' is seldom the deciding factor in any format war. I could go on at length about canny marketing early on by IBM (licencing the x86), canny dealing by Bill Gates and similarly bad business at Apple. Somehow I think you already know all this though. :)
And of course .. the cost and lack of modularity; as far as I'm concerned building everything into the monitor is nothing more than an inconvenient and expensive gimmick for anyone who might want to upgrade their machine in the future.

SMHarman 17-01-2006 11:51

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
I have a six-year-old iMac, which runs faster today that it did new. It has 640MB of RAM (shipped with 64MB) and has had two major OS revisions installed since the day it was first switched on with OS 9.0.8 onboard. I'm now on 10.2.8 and am told that 10.3 and 10.4 both brought further efficiencies.

Maybe not so much for XP, but the step change from W98 to W2K was similar. The step change in reliability of my antique Celeron3 runing W2k on 96Mb not W98 was by the sounds of things similar to your experience of the change from X9>10.

Chris 17-01-2006 11:58

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
It's not streamlined in any way, straight XP Pro SP2 install direct from CD running on a Dell Inspiron 3700 with 512mb memory (the only upgrade it's ever had), a couple of drivers loaded and that's it, the ONLY thing I've found that hogs it is the .NET framework and I've so far managed to avoid having that installed on my desktop too.

OK, fair enough. What about Vista though? Am I hearing wrong or are people complaining about the sort of hardware that will be needed to run it?

Quote:

And of course .. the cost and lack of modularity; as far as I'm concerned building everything into the monitor is nothing more than an inconvenient and expensive gimmick for anyone who might want to upgrade their machine in the future.
Its funny, but you seldom hear people complaining about the lack of modularity of TVs, Hi Fis and Microwave ovens. PCs are no longer the plaything of those with special knowledge. They are consumer electronics and the vast majority of people see them as such. I suggest you are in a minority - probably a small minority - of people who even want to think about tinkering with the insides of their PC. Some PC manufcturers have recognised this and while they may not actually pack the electronics into the same box as the monitor, they screw the box shut in a way that's designed to discourage you from getting into it.

Bifta 17-01-2006 12:35

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
OK, fair enough. What about Vista though? Am I hearing wrong or are people complaining about the sort of hardware that will be needed to run it?

From what I gather Vista is scaleable so you can either choose to have all the fancy bells and whistles if you have a PC powerful enough to support them or not .. if you haven't.

Quote:

Its funny, but you seldom hear people complaining about the lack of modularity of TVs, Hi Fis and Microwave ovens. PCs are no longer the plaything of those with special knowledge. They are consumer electronics and the vast majority of people see them as such. I suggest you are in a minority - probably a small minority - of people who even want to think about tinkering with the insides of their PC. Some PC manufcturers have recognised this and while they may not actually pack the electronics into the same box as the monitor, they screw the box shut in a way that's designed to discourage you from getting into it.
Obviously you've never tried to get into the back of a recent Dell machine, it's a plastic clip you push down, no screws, nothing.

As for considering a PC in the same vein as a TV or Microwave .. rubbish, sorry, even the most technophobic person is capable of plugging a new monitor into the back of PC, if they decide they want to upgrade the internals they can simply take it to a computer shop, I hardly think they're going to head down to the microwave shop and get a new & improved magnatron fitted.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:04.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum