![]() |
170 villages in the Amazon have 3G coverage..
Something that's sure to irritate some of our rural members is that an organisation called "Extreme Project Brazil" is in the process of connecting 170 villages (and some 25 million people) in the Amazon to a 3G network.
Actually, joking aside, I think it's good that someone is willing to put commercial concerns aside (although 25 potential customers would be a hell of a draw for any company). It's just a shame some of the telecoms providers in this so called first world country are willing to ignore a lot of it's residents. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programme...ne/9753821.stm |
Re: 170 villages in the Amazon have 3G coverage..
3G is easy, even Mount Everest has 3G these days.
But before drawing comparisons with the UK lets just clarify. According to that news report, "Extreme Project Brazil" has so far set up a grand total of... two transmitters. They're not in the process of connecting 170 villages 25 million people. They've set up two transmitters which covers 170 villages. 25 million people is what they could cover if they installed thousands more, which nobody has any intention or funding to do - yet. While a good idea in principle, there are dozens of other, cheaper, and more widespread solutions that do the same thing already out there as well. Some of the worlds largest and longest range community wifi deployments are in similar countries. Now the reason we shouldn't compare what they have to what we have here is because of the massive differences in technology and geography. The area they've covered is extremely flat. They're using different frequencies and different equipment that provides 6-10x the range of those we have in the UK. The two combined means they can use just two transmitters to cover 44,000km2, 170 communities and >10000 people. Some of the most remote 3G transmitters in Scotland (situated here and here) have a hard time covering ten communities, 1000 people and 250km2 between them (maybe 8000km2 if you count the sea), let alone 44,000. If that sort of scale was possible in the UK, we'd have 100% 3G land coverage with just 11 transmitters. Two transmitters would cover half of Scotland. Right now, we've got 15,000+ and we're not even close. |
Re: 170 villages in the Amazon have 3G coverage..
3G in the Amazon & on Everest, but not in my place of work, you've got to laugh.
|
Re: 170 villages in the Amazon have 3G coverage..
As far as the Amazon coverage goes it's only outdoors and across treetops - chances are no different from that of your place of work, you'll probably get 3G standing on the roof.
In none of the 3 scenarios would it work indoors through several feet of concrete or metal. |
Re: 170 villages in the Amazon have 3G coverage..
And yet we can receive an excellent signal from Mars! :D
|
| All times are GMT. The time now is 02:21. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum