Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on". (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33677225)

Mr Angry 30-04-2011 02:12

Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Ooops! Seems like Mark isn't happy with every type of free speech.

AaronCooper 30-04-2011 02:23

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
This has been happening a long time, with groups such as the hacktivist group ANONYMOUS & Wikileaks.

Pierre 30-04-2011 04:26

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr Angry (Post 35225472)
Ooops! Seems like Mark isn't happy with every type of free speech.

Good.

Sirius 30-04-2011 06:53

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35225474)
Good.

You might think that but what of this countries right to free speech which btw a lot of people have died to protect.

Would you like us to be like some foreign countries and rewrite history every day depending on who is in power. ???

I might not like those groups but they do have the right of free speech and by removing there pages just gives them publicity for free

beeman 30-04-2011 07:01

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35225485)
You might think that but what of this countries right to free speech which btw a lot of people have died to protect.

Would you like us to be like some foreign countries and rewrite history every day depending on who is in power. ???

I might not like those groups but they do have the right of free speech and by removing there pages just gives them publicity for free

There is NO right to free speech on facebook or any other 3rd party website. Facebook is private property and as such they can decide what speech to allow or not. If people want free speech online they will need to setup their own website on their own server.

Maggy 30-04-2011 07:42

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Well 38 Degrees is still up..So not every activist group has been a target.

martyh 30-04-2011 08:06

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by beeman (Post 35225486)
There is NO right to free speech on facebook or any other 3rd party website. Facebook is private property and as such they can decide what speech to allow or not. If people want free speech online they will need to setup their own website on their own server.

Exactly ,people also forget that Facebook is a money making corporation not a public service ,it is only there to make money ,why would they allow anti capitalist activists to further their cause on that site .

Russ 30-04-2011 08:19

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Is there any evidence Facebook has done anything to these groups?

Sirius 30-04-2011 08:47

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35225515)
Is there any evidence Facebook has done anything to these groups?

No idea as i chose not to read there sites, I just looked at Mr A's link

Russ 30-04-2011 08:54

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
So it's possible this is all a case of people with an agenda jumping to conclusions?

Sirius 30-04-2011 08:57

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35225530)
So it's possible this is all a case of people with an agenda jumping to conclusions?

Could be as lets be truthful one sees agendas in the press everyday depending which side of the divide your on.:)

martyh 30-04-2011 08:59

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

A Facebook spokeswoman explained that the profiles were suspended because they had not been registered correctly and denied that the removal of pages was politically motivated or instigated by law enforcement concerns before the royal wedding.
Facebook accounts that claim to represent individual people but are in fact groups or organisations contravene the company's "statement of rights and responsibilities".
The company said a number accounts were suspended at the same time.
A later edition of the story to Mr A's
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology...ctivists-pages

Russ 30-04-2011 09:01

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
So at this point is appears that yes those pages were suspended but so were others. Some will shout "conspiracy!!", others will say "nothing to see here".

Sirius 30-04-2011 09:04

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35225537)
So at this point is appears that yes those pages were suspended but so were others. Some will shout "conspiracy!!", others will say "nothing to see here".

Agreed

martyh 30-04-2011 09:07

Re: Facebook...perhaps not entirely "right on".
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35225537)
So at this point is appears that yes those pages were suspended but so were others. Some will shout "conspiracy!!", others will say "nothing to see here".

Indeed ,all the activist pages need to remember that they are breaking Facebooks T&C's so don't have an argument really ,and as has been mentioned it is a privately owned site and as such can shut down what they like and have whatever content they like within the law ,as indeed this site can


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:05.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum