Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   General IT Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   DVD writers (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=12423)

bonzoe 16-05-2004 16:40

DVD writers
 
Hi, I'm thinking of getting a DVD writer. I have a few questions:
1) What is the dominant format?
2) Are there any compatibility issues betwen formats (I guess there are)?
3) Any recommendations for a writer?

Thanks

SMHarman 16-05-2004 16:44

Re: DVD writers
 
1) +R and -R are both fairly dominant. +RAM is far more specialised.
2) All three require a compatible player to read the disk, otherwise it's like trying to get a PC to read a mac formatted floppy. Most are now +/- multiread.
-R is normally the most compatible for TV DVD boxes.
3) Pioneer / Sony / NEC / Panasonic (has RAM) are all good to start with.

kronas 16-05-2004 16:55

Re: DVD writers
 
personally i would recommend a -/+ r combined drive and the pionner models are excellent for compatability and reliability.

paulyoung666 16-05-2004 17:08

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman
1) +R and -R are both fairly dominant. +RAM is far more specialised.
2) All three require a compatible player to read the disk, otherwise it's like trying to get a PC to read a mac formatted floppy. Most are now +/- multiread.
-R is normally the most compatible for TV DVD boxes.
3) Pioneer / Sony / NEC / Panasonic (has RAM) are all good to start with.


i thought +r was the most compatible , never mind , at the price they are now they are virtually throwaway items , get a dual or including ram one :)

punky 16-05-2004 17:30

Re: DVD writers
 
SMH said it all pretty well, but i'd just add that a DVD-RAM disk is just like a removable hard disk, but can only be read by a DVD-RAM drive, and they are few and far between. Also, -R tends to be cheaper so more heavily used/easier to find disks for.

I've got the NEC 2500. Burns great, no coasters so far, even with the dirt cheap Ritek disks. It's reading isn't so good though, but for burning it is probably the best. I'd recommend it if you already have a good DVD reader in the computer already. Best for reading/writing balance is the Pioneer A06/A07. Pioneer has managed to turn it into a dual layer (9 gig on 1 CD side) burner by altering the firmware, so even if they don't release it, some clever bloke will probably release hacked firware for it, therefore future proofing it.

Defiant 16-05-2004 18:16

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulyoung666
at the price they are now they are virtually throwaway items , get a dual or including ram one :)

Thats because there loosing the race for domination ;)

The - brand is winning so far

Matth 16-05-2004 21:04

Re: DVD writers
 
The ND2500 appears to be hackable for dual layer support, at least, the CD/DVD forums seem to be full of converting 2500 to 2510 with a firmware hack - does it make a GOOD dual layer writer though, not quite so certain.

check out www.cdrinfo.com - they've reviewed quite a number of them.

Tricky 16-05-2004 22:24

Re: DVD writers
 
- Media tends to be a little cheaper I've found
I personally use two devices:
Sony DRU500A which seems to do every format under the sun!
HP DVD Writer??? that only does +

I have had compatibility issues with the - Media on one device (not listed above) but I ain't saying which!

andygrif 17-05-2004 10:22

Re: DVD writers
 
I'm waiting on the new Plextor PX-712 - which is the first drive to burn at 12 speed. I may not actually buy it, but hopefully when it's introduced it will lower the cost of the PX-708 (8 speed) drive which always does very well in every review.

sherer 17-05-2004 11:20

Re: DVD writers
 
can anyone explain the difference between the Pioneer A07 and DVR107.. they both seem to be the same but abit different in price.. apart from quicker speed what do you get for buying a dearer model..

can't find any in blue though and i got a blue case if anyone knows a made that sells in this colour let me know..

altis 17-05-2004 11:56

Re: DVD writers
 
This document describes the five different formats (although some of the info is a bit old):
http://homepage.ntlworld.com/altisuk/temp/dvdformat.pdf

For a cheap drive that supports ALL formats try this (currently £50.75 + delivery and VAT from Scan - and often available in 'Today Only' deals):
http://www.lge.co.uk/mod_perl/go.pl/...oduct_uid=2741

punky 17-05-2004 12:11

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sherer
can anyone explain the difference between the Pioneer A07 and DVR107.. they both seem to be the same but abit different in price.. apart from quicker speed what do you get for buying a dearer model..

can't find any in blue though and i got a blue case if anyone knows a made that sells in this colour let me know..

The 107 is what is called retail. It is an all inclusive kit. You get software with it, mounting screws everything. The A07 is what is called OEM. It is for advanced people that build computers, and is literally just the bare drive. No software, screws, cables, etc.

Mr_love_monkey 17-05-2004 12:14

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
(currently £50.75 + delivery and VAT from Scan - and often available in 'Today Only' deals)

Scan have currently got a week long special on DVD writers. might be worth taking a look

sherer 17-05-2004 12:17

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
This document describes the five different formats (although some of the info is a bit old):
http://homepage.ntlworld.com/altisuk/temp/dvdformat.pdf

For a cheap drive that supports ALL formats try this (currently £50.75 + delivery and VAT from Scan - and often available in 'Today Only' deals):
http://www.lge.co.uk/mod_perl/go.pl/...oduct_uid=2741

thanks for the link.. gone for the LG one on scan.. saw that cheaper elsewhere but you get the discs and nero etc with scan and this does RAM as well. not sure if i will use all of that but looked like the best deal..

bonzoe 17-05-2004 20:00

Re: DVD writers
 
Thanks everyone, interesting reading


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:52.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum