Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media Internet Service (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   New DSLReports speedtester (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33700526)

qasdfdsaq 14-09-2015 12:41

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrysalis (Post 35797889)
something up with your system qas, is consistent here.

Also its a test probably aimed at consumer's not university connections? why are you using your work connection?

Yes, clearly it's my system because other speedtests work fine on my system...

There's specifically multiple options for gigabit, fibre, and work/corporate connections though as you can clearly see from the ISP box I am not using a university or work connection. But if it wasn't aimed at all connections (not just consumer) there shouldn't be a 32-stream option or big buttons for "Corporate" "Edu" "Fibre" "Gigabit" and "10Gigabit"

tl;dr: It's a beta. It can't be expected to be consistent and reliable all the time.

Kushan 14-09-2015 14:19

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Your connection is probably faster than theirs :)

qasdfdsaq 14-09-2015 15:35

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kushan (Post 35797985)
Your connection is probably faster than theirs :)

They use 4-6 servers including between 4-8 connections to each server, and that's for the non-10G test. 32 connections across 6 1G+ servers should certainly be enough to max out any connection I have. I dunno what they use for the 10G test, that's members only.

Given 4 streams is enough (on my line) to hit 900M+ I find 32-streams is rather excessive, but should have no problem with "my connection is probably faster than theirs".

Martyn 14-09-2015 15:46

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Sky Fibre Pro
https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2015/09/14.png

http://www.dslreports.com/speedtest/1350371

Kushan 14-09-2015 15:47

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35798000)
They use 4-6 servers including between 4-8 connections to each server, and that's for the non-10G test. 32 connections across 6 1G+ servers should certainly be enough to max out any connection I have. I dunno what they use for the 10G test, that's members only.

Given 4 streams is enough (on my line) to hit 900M+ I find 32-streams is rather excessive, but should have no problem with "my connection is probably faster than theirs".

Depends how their load balancing those connections and there's a bit more to it than total bandwidth available per stream. I'd like some more technical details of how they are generating their test data.

qasdfdsaq 14-09-2015 17:46

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kushan (Post 35798005)
Depends how their load balancing those connections and there's a bit more to it than total bandwidth available per stream. I'd like some more technical details of how they are generating their test data.

The whole thing is HTML5 - just look at the source yourself?

Kushan 15-09-2015 09:42

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Me and HTML5/CSS/Javascript don't get along :(

qasdfdsaq 15-09-2015 12:05

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kushan (Post 35798101)
Me and HTML5/CSS/Javascript don't get along :(

Well then you may have difficulty "getting along" with the technical details of how the test works - i.e. HTML5 websockets.

Kushan 15-09-2015 12:19

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35798117)
Well then you may have difficulty "getting along" with the technical details of how the test works - i.e. HTML5 websockets.

More interested in the technical aspects of packet size, UDP vs TCP, etc.

qasdfdsaq 15-09-2015 12:23

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kushan (Post 35798123)
More interested in the technical aspects of packet size, UDP vs TCP, etc.

That's defined in the HTML5 websocket.

Kushan 15-09-2015 14:04

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
And the nature and configuration of the NIC's accepting those sockets? There's a lot of variables to consider.

qasdfdsaq 15-09-2015 14:12

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Given there's dozens of servers across just as many countries, the NIC configuration is going to be different between all of them.

Kushan 15-09-2015 14:25

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
That doesn't sound like it's going to produce reliable, consistent results then. NIC configuration can make a hell of a difference.

qasdfdsaq 15-09-2015 16:48

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Hence the brute force method, pile in 32 streams from 6 different servers.

For reference, Speedtest.net have no control over NIC parameters either, or even what kind of web server or connection is used, let alone the settings within. All servers there are just set up whatever way the sponsor/provider feels like.

Ignitionnet 15-09-2015 17:13

Re: New DSLReports speedtester
 
Comcast's 2Gb service.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:29.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.