Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Science & Technology (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33688655)

tvout 07-07-2012 21:24

Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Hi all,
I've heard favourable comments on the HTC One S & X and the Galaxy S II but can't decide and wondered if anyone had any of the above and can say what they're like? The Galaxy S II seems smaller, I fear the HTC One models, especially the X are a bit big, not really that pocket sized...
I've had a HTC Wildfire (not S) for 2 years now so am looking for a worthy upgrade and think any of the above would be a nice step up...
I only pay £10 a month at the moment though so probably looking at hiking that up to possibly £30 for one of the above phones or considering sticking with the £10 plan and getting the phone sim free online...

Just wondered if anyone had any advice on any of those models? Still considering the Sensation or even the Desire possibly as they're cheaper now...

qasdfdsaq 07-07-2012 21:35

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Of the two you mention, I would take the One S over the S II. It's actually smaller and to me, feels a lot smaller and more comfortable. The HTC user experience is much better out of the box, and the wifi, 3G, and CPU all perform better.

The only limitations are the non-removable battery and lack of expandable memory.

tvout 07-07-2012 22:01

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Cheers qasdfdsaq, sounds good. Non-removable battery? What would you do if it freezes if you can't take the battery out?

qasdfdsaq 08-07-2012 01:14

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Hold down the power button for 10 seconds (though I'm yet to ever see it happen on any of my 4 Android phones)

Tali 08-07-2012 23:20

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
My HTC One X, while I admit, is on the large side, has no problems sitting in my pocket, and I'm more than happy with it so far.

alferret 08-07-2012 23:37

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Galaxy SII is as fast as a One X. My Mrs has a Galaxy Note, super phone with a cracking screen (if a little large @ £20pm) The Galaxy SIII whilst fast IMO is no better than the SII or SIII the only thing HTC has going for it is the Sense front end.

At the end of the day its down to what you need from your provider min/txt/web as that will dictate price.
I have my SII on Orange with 100/UL/500 for £15.50pm (free phone)
Some good deals are to be had, you just need to search them out.

Stephen 09-07-2012 09:30

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 35451026)
Galaxy SII is as fast as a One X. My Mrs has a Galaxy Note, super phone with a cracking screen (if a little large @ £20pm) The Galaxy SIII whilst fast IMO is no better than the SII or SIII the only thing HTC has going for it is the Sense front end.

At the end of the day its down to what you need from your provider min/txt/web as that will dictate price.
I have my SII on Orange with 100/UL/500 for £15.50pm (free phone)
Some good deals are to be had, you just need to search them out.

No its not. The S3 is as fast as a One X as they have quad core CPUs. The S2 only uses a Dual core CPU.

Have to disagree, I upgraded from the S2 and the S3 is so much better in every way. Much faster and smoother and also runs the latest version of touchwiz, which I think IMO is a lot better than Sense now.

qasdfdsaq 09-07-2012 10:42

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
I think he means in general use, rather than simply benchmarks.

I'll agree to some extent, the S2 was never a particularly slow phone (at least not till Samsung screwed up ICS) and web browsing is as fast or faster than on the One X, as the HOX has quite a buggy and sluggish browser that the extra CPU fails to make up for. For example, when loading Speedtest.net (flash based web version), the One X takes about eight times longer than the S2.

Ultimately most apps are still single threaded, with the only time my HOX or GS3 exceeding 30% CPU usage since I got it is in benchmarks and CPU tests. And there, the S2 has a more efficient-per-clock processor than the One X bringing the real difference down to 10-20% at best.

alanbjames 09-07-2012 17:27

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
i can honestly recommend either.

I Have the Samsung Galaxy Ace and my wife has a HTC Wildfire S and both brands are reliable, well built and hard working.

tvout 10-07-2012 18:04

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35450819)
Hold down the power button for 10 seconds (though I'm yet to ever see it happen on any of my 4 Android phones)

You're lucky, I've had to do it loads with my Wildfire. Real bargain basement phone that was but at £10 a month line rental it was ok for free!

---------- Post added at 18:04 ---------- Previous post was at 17:59 ----------

I'm really considering the S2 or S3 now, the S3 with the quad core CPUs does seem very attractive. If I stayed with my current provider it shows them on contracts at about £26-£33...
My current plan was 24 months and only £10 a month, with that I got:
HTC Wildfire free
300 minutes to mobiles
300 texts
unlimited landline calls
unlimited internet

The above suited me perfectly, I don't think I went over my allowance at all, I make more calls to landlines than mobiles and don't send that many texts either.

qasdfdsaq 10-07-2012 21:14

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
I'd take the S3 over the S2, and the One S over the S2 as well.

tvout 14-07-2012 12:31

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
How about between the S3 and One X? I can get the One X for £50 cheaper than the S3 and the spec seems very similar but the S3 seems so appealing I think...

tizmeinnit 14-07-2012 13:10

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
if you are going to pay £30 a month get the SIII from buymobilephones.net 600 mins unlimted text and plenty of internet £26 per month and prt your mumber

qasdfdsaq 14-07-2012 14:00

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tvout (Post 35452580)
How about between the S3 and One X? I can get the One X for £50 cheaper than the S3 and the spec seems very similar but the S3 seems so appealing I think...

I'd take the S3 anyday, but you're welcome to buy my One X - nobody wants it because it's crappier in every way other than the screen (and wifi performance)

tvout 14-07-2012 14:05

Re: Decent upgrade phone on T-Mobile - HTC or Samsung?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35452606)
I'd take the S3 anyday, but you're welcome to buy my One X - nobody wants it because it's crappier in every way other than the screen (and wifi performance)

Sounds like you've sold the S3 to me :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:23.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum