Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Lifestyle (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   Question about none English speaking people (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33022)

Jules 04-08-2005 12:42

Question about none English speaking people
 
Ok I have a question how is that that people that do not speak English are allowed to take the theory test in there own Language and have a translator in the car for there practical driving test?
Ok a lot of the roads signs are symbols but what about those that have writing on them they are always in English and I have never heard of any one that can read a language but not speak it :confused:

No flaming please I am genuinely interested

Pø†øƒGøLÐ 04-08-2005 12:46

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Well... I have a theory about that. Live in England, learn to speak English. Most colleges these days have appropriate courses to teach people "English as a foreign language".

We have enough accidents on the road already without them being added to by drivers who can't read the road signs. Matrix boards are in English and contain important information also.

marky 04-08-2005 12:47

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
i suppose road signs dont often say

please dont turn right at the next junction as it is one way :D

Xaccers 04-08-2005 12:49

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Because road signs relating to driving (not directing) are all in the highway code which every driver should have read and be up to date with.
Non-english speaking drivers should also be up to date with all the meanings of signs, and it is up to them to get a translation.

Jules 04-08-2005 12:49

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
But a lot of signs do have writing on them and not just temporary signs. So for instance if I lived in China I can not speak nor read the language so how would I be able to read what the road signs say?

And how do you get a translation of a sign as you are driving down the road? lol

Xaccers 04-08-2005 12:51

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by whyme38
But a lot of signs do have writing on them and not just temporary signs. So for instance if I lived in China I can not speak nor read the language so how would I be able to read what the road signs say?

And how do you get a translation of a sign as you are driving down the road? lol

Can you give an example of a road sign with important writing on it which would not make sense if the writting wasn't there?

danielf 04-08-2005 12:51

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
It may have more to do with being confident/fluent in English than actually being able to speak/read it. For many people the driving test is a rather stressful event.

Also, any British person travelling abroad is allowed to drive a car on a British licence without speaking the local language.

gazzae 04-08-2005 12:52

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Don't really think you need to speak a language to drive in that country.
I didn't had problems driving in France, even though I can't speak French.

Gogogo 04-08-2005 12:53

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by whyme38
Ok I have a question how is that that people that do not speak English are allowed to take the theory test in there own Language and have a translator in the car for there practical driving test?
Ok a lot of the roads signs are symbols but what about those that have writing on them they are always in English and I have never heard of any one that can read a language but not speak it :confused: No flaming please I am genuinely interested

From my experience having lived in Kenya and Zimbabwe. Driving tests are in English, both have highway codes, traffic signs similar to our own: not that it matters as driving licenses can be bought, in Kenya the police do the driving tests and they love being bought.

But, no driver in Kenya drives according to the rules, it can be hell driving in Nairobi, believe me, bl...y matatus a menace. As for Zimbabwe no one can afford the price of fuel these days so the only vehicles moving belong to government ministers, officials party apparatchiks and none of them can drive either! And bl...y Zim army drivers are the worst.


:Yikes:

marky 04-08-2005 12:59

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
1 Attachment(s)
i know its :notopic: but i couldnt resist

the real meaning of road signs:D

Jules 04-08-2005 13:04

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
Can you give an example of a road sign with important writing on it which would not make sense if the writting wasn't there?


Urban clearways with days and times on, bus lanes with days and times on, road closed up ahead signs etc those are just a few that come to mind
__________________

Lol good one Mark

Xaccers 04-08-2005 13:10

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by whyme38
Urban clearways with days and times on, bus lanes with days and times on, road closed up ahead signs etc those are just a few that come to mind
__________________

Lol good one Mark

Well as long as the driver knows the urban clearway sign, it's not going to be any danger if he doesn't park there at any time of the day even if at certain times he's allowed.
Again with bus lanes, no danger if he doesn't use the bus lane during periods when he can, many English speaking people do this.
Road closed, well he'll find out when he gets to the closed part of the road. An inconvenience, but not to anyone else, and no danger

punky 04-08-2005 13:12

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by whyme38
Ok I have a question how is that that people that do not speak English are allowed to take the theory test in there own Language and have a translator in the car for there practical driving test?

Well, to be able to drive successfully, you don't need to read road signs, merely recognise them. You don't need to know what it says on it, but you know if you see the sign with those particularly markings, you know to do, or not to do something.

It works both ways. For example, take the bog standard US stop sign as everyone knows what it looks like. If you replaced the letters, you would still know to stop when you see that sign, because you look at it, not as text but as a picture and remember the markings.

andyl 04-08-2005 13:13

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Anyone know if BMW drivers speak English?

Xaccers 04-08-2005 13:15

Re: Question about none English speaking people
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by punky
Well, to be able to drive successfully, you don't need to read road signs, merely recognise them. You don't need to know what it says on it, but you know if you see the sign with those particularly markings, you know to do, or not to do something.

It works both ways. For example, take the bog standard US stop sign as everyone knows what it looks like. If you replaced the letters, you would still know to stop when you see that sign, because you look at it, not as text but as a picture and remember the markings.


Exactly, this https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2005/08/23.jpg at a junction obviously means stop


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:15.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum