Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   How will you vote at next election? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=9636)

Damien 17-03-2004 20:26

How will you vote at next election?
 
How will you vote?

Also is it possible to prevent rep from being used to topics?

This is a senstive topic and no one should be given negitive rep based on political belifs

I may have to take that back if someone says BNP :mad:

MadGamer 17-03-2004 20:32

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
How will you vote?

Also is it possible to prevent rep from being used to topics?

This is a senstive topic and no one should be given negitive rep based on political belifs

I may have to take that back if someone says BNP :mad:

IMO The Conservatives.

Damien 17-03-2004 20:35

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
? Not suggesting the torys are bad as the BNP are you :)

wheeliebin 17-03-2004 20:42

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
? Not suggesting the torys are bad as the BNP are you :)


I will be voting for Labour.
However i have to accept that this two party system we have in place means that a change feels somewhat inevitable. Especially as we as a nation tend to be guided by the media.

paulyoung666 17-03-2004 20:42

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
just a small point , but , why is this in PC Gaming & Discussion :D :D :D :D , haway mods , get it shifted :D :D :D :D

Damien 17-03-2004 20:43

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
was it?

Oppps sorry, theres a lot of forums here :)

Kneebs 17-03-2004 21:04

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
What about an option for non voting !!

They're all as bad as each other, however, I shall more than likely be voting for a party other than labour

Damien 17-03-2004 21:49

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Because i dont care about people who are not voting, :) Whats the ppoint of including them?

Why not labpur anyway they've done good

paulyoung666 17-03-2004 21:50

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Because i dont care about people who are not voting, :) Whats the ppoint of including them?

Why not labpur anyway they've done good



labour done good , obviously your opinion only :(

dilli-theclaw 17-03-2004 21:52

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Because i dont care about people who are not voting, :) Whats the ppoint of including them?

Why not labpur anyway they've done good

So you don't care about people who don't vote - and you don't like people who vote for the bnp.

Very democratic of you.

hairy_mick 17-03-2004 22:07

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Have voted labour all my life do not trust tory's have been around remember the 70's 80's and 90's under tory rule dont trust michael howard remember him from maggies days.

Damien 17-03-2004 22:08

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I meant that I wanted to see about which partys where ahead. Otherwise the pages would be filled with pages about voter aperthy

Also, I dont really think that anyone can defend the BNP

dilli-theclaw 17-03-2004 22:11

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
I meant that I wanted to see about which partys where ahead. Otherwise the pages would be filled with pages about voter aperthy

Also, I dont really think that anyone can defend the BNP

I DO vote btw.....

I don't think anyone can defend the BNP either - BUT it IS a party and so is an option for people to vote for.

Just my opinion - but if you really want a proper poll you should not exclude a party just because you don't like it.

aliferste 17-03-2004 22:11

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
If you dont vote then do not moan!!

Mick 17-03-2004 22:31

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Because i dont care about people who are not voting, :) Whats the ppoint of including them?

Why not labpur anyway they've done good

You might not care about it but when making a poll you should consider all the options from every angle. The way people feel about voting these days is that no party can appeal to voters. :cool:

Dave Stones 17-03-2004 22:35

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
i will vote as i always have done (ok only voted once in my life before but shh) and that is secretly. thats why you cant go reading what people put on the ballot forms you know, so your vote is secret ;)

gary_580 17-03-2004 22:40

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kneebs
What about an option for non voting !!

They're all as bad as each other, however, I shall more than likely be voting for a party other than labour


theres is, dont vote in the poll :D

Paul 17-03-2004 22:51

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
As it's a public poll I shall not be voting. :)

aliferste 17-03-2004 23:19

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
As it's a public poll I shall not be voting. :)


LOL I just realised you could see who voted for what!

Russ 17-03-2004 23:22

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
How will you vote?

Wisely :)

Ignition 17-03-2004 23:23

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I on the other hand am happy to say I will vote Liberal Democrat.

Why? This is a Lib Dem ward already, and unlike either of the other parties they were against the horrifying events in the Middle East, and even have the gall to admit they will raise taxes to improve things, rather than just sneakily and dramatically increasing the tax burden.

Labour have even managed to increase income tax on the sly - the top rate's barrier has not gone up with inflation, more people are paying top rate than would be had this happened.

Makes me laugh I'm not far AT ALL from top rate tax, but can't afford to buy a house, even though I apparently am on a higher salary than 90% of the UK adult population. Meanwhile my tax is being used to play monkey boy to George Bush and the rest of his Neo-Con virtual fascists.

New Labour my botty to be honest, they are no more Labour than the Conservatives - the only remotely Socialist party left is the Lib Dems, the other two are doing their utmost to become Neo-Conservative / Neo-Zionist with no regard for either the cost or their own people they alienate trying to be the 52nd state. Amusing that there is no money for this, or that, but Gee Dubbya comes calling and a few billion soon materialises. Terror politics rubbish that Tony is throwing at us mixed in with lies doesn't really appeal either.

OP - I note you are 17. I'm not that much older than you but I remember when the political landscape was very very different. Now we are just America Junior - Tony even seems to be planning on trying to terrorise us to vote for him to cover up the failures domestically and most of all with foreign policy. I have voted Labour twice but frankly I'd rather not vote at all that vote for that bunch of scheming fibbing neo-Con whores that are the Nu Labour party, at least not while Tony is in charge.

Stuart 17-03-2004 23:26

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I voted Lib Dem. I think that in the last few years, the Labour Party have c*cked it up. The Tories did before them. It's time for someone else to see how well they can c*ck it up.

philip.j.fry 17-03-2004 23:29

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I'm thinking that the party system has had its day and am thinking of spoiling my ballot paper, just hope I can write small enough to fit everything I want to say on :)

Julian 17-03-2004 23:48

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I live in an area where historically on the face of it my vote will make little difference to the eventual outcome.

Having said that, if I do not vote then I do not feel I will have the moral right to comment on the party in power.

All I would say is that everyone who is entitled to vote, should vote.

Remember that the present government achieved its 62.5% of seats on the basis of support from 24.2% of the electorate. So over 75% of the electorate didn't vote for them.

MovedGoalPosts 17-03-2004 23:59

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Julian
I live in an area where historically on the face of it my vote will make little difference to the eventual outcome.

Having said that, if I do not vote then I do not feel I will have the moral right to comment on the party in power.

All I would say is that everyone who is entitled to vote, should vote.

Remember that the present government achieved its 62.5% of seats on the basis of support from 24.2% of the electorate. So over 75% of the electorate didn't vote for them.

Exactly, one has to remember that only a couple of generations ago a lot of ppl gave their lives to be able to maintain the freedom of the right to vote.

Unfortunately these days, the party system and the manifestos offered are so complex, that a choice of the voting option is frequently not about which party has the best policy, but which will, on balance, do the least damage to you the individual.

For example, you might agree with the concept of spending more on schools and NHS, and so vote labour or Lib dem, but you also want better law and order and clamp downs on asylum seekers traditionally an area where the conservatives have better ideas. So you end up voting Monster Raving Loony :dozey:

Russ 18-03-2004 00:00

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
But then again if it ever came to pass that voting was compulsary, it would end any traces of the UK being a democracy.

Ignition 18-03-2004 00:05

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
But then again if it ever came to pass that voting was compulsary, it would end any traces of the UK being a democracy.

Australia isn't a democracy?

Russ 18-03-2004 00:06

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JustAnotherN00b
Australia isn't a democracy?

This isn't Australia? :spin:

danielf 18-03-2004 00:10

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Julian
I live in an area where historically on the face of it my vote will make little difference to the eventual outcome.

Having said that, if I do not vote then I do not feel I will have the moral right to comment on the party in power.

All I would say is that everyone who is entitled to vote, should vote.

Remember that the present government achieved its 62.5% of seats on the basis of support from 24.2% of the electorate. So over 75% of the electorate didn't vote for them.

Proportional representation anyone?

sir_drinks_alot 18-03-2004 00:10

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
well the Fact that labour's majority is so big thay can't
lose 101-seat over all makes the election a bit of a joke
really :mad: right now am what the pollsters call a swing voter
i just can't make up my mind

Julian 18-03-2004 00:13

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
Proportional representation anyone?


LOL - not my political leaning at all m8. :)

Just making the point that if people don't vote...... look what you could end up with. ;)

danielf 18-03-2004 00:24

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Julian
LOL - not my political leaning at all m8. :)

Just making the point that if people don't vote...... look what you could end up with. ;)

Second one, I agree. First one, we differ :).

Stuart 18-03-2004 00:36

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Julian
Having said that, if I do not vote then I do not feel I will have the moral right to comment on the party in power.

All I would say is that everyone who is entitled to vote, should vote.

Surely a person should only vote if they happen to agree with any party? I didn't vote at the last election, not because of apathy, but I didn't agree with any of the main parties being in government. I still don't think either the Tories or Tory Lite (Labour) party should be in power.

philip.j.fry 18-03-2004 00:41

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scastle
Surely a person should only vote if they happen to agree with any party? I didn't vote at the last election, not because of apathy, but I didn't agree with any of the main parties being in government. I still don't think either the Tories or Tory Lite (Labour) party should be in power.

It is in those situations that you should 'spoil' you ballo paper. The way they say spoil it makes it sound like a childish thing to do when in fact it is showing that you're not apathetic but don't believe any of the candidates to be suitable. Just my personal opinion, but if they get enough spoiled ballots they are going to have to take notice.

Julian 18-03-2004 00:41

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Sorry, I think my post has been misinterpreted. :blush:

I didn't mean that people should be forced to vote.... just that if more people did vote the result would be more representative. :)

Marge 18-03-2004 00:49

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Any talk of voting brings to mind my history teacher, 4' 11" and the voice of a sargeant major on drill parade. She drummed into us girls the importance of voting and how people had died to give us the right to vote. Having said that I can't see any party that impresses so it might be the Monster Raving Looney mob (I'll fit in well there ;) )

sir_drinks_alot 18-03-2004 01:05

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
hell why don't i just stand for Parliament am way more
inTouch with the People than all the politicians could
ever wish to be so what to you say gang SDA for mp :cool:

Ignition 18-03-2004 04:09

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
But then again if it ever came to pass that voting was compulsary, it would end any traces of the UK being a democracy.

OK best mention to the following that they are not democracies:

Argentina
Australia
Austria
Belgium
Bolivia
Brazil
Cyprus
Dominican Republic
Egypt
Greece
Guatemala
Honduras
Liechenstein
Luxembourg
Panama
Philippines
Singapore
Switzerland (some cantons only)
Uruguay
Venezuela

zendawn 18-03-2004 06:34

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I always vote GREEN, thanks to PR we now have 2 MEPs which would never have gotten in with First Past the Post.

I've always thought the 'None of the above' option should be added, like in Brewsters Millions. I was gonna stand, as the 'None of the above' Party, giving people the option of showing that they wanna vote but not for anyone on the balot paper. At the moment there isnt a way to register a protest vote, as spiolt papers dont really count.

Damien 18-03-2004 07:53

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Theres an 'other' section ya know?

All other partys can go in there and again if you dont wanna vote they this is not the topic for you as it will just lead to people complaining about the system and such.

Damien 18-03-2004 07:56

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sir_drinks_alot
well the Fact that labour's majority is so big thay can't
lose 101-seat over all makes the election a bit of a joke
really :mad: right now am what the pollsters call a swing voter
i just can't make up my mind

Thats the system over here :D

It wouldnt be so good if labour had to agree with the torys or libb dem.

Its doent make the election a joke, a overwealming amount of people voted them in so they have more control

Xaccers 18-03-2004 08:12

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I'll be voting how I always do.
By going into the booth and putting an X against the party I support :D

Damien 18-03-2004 08:37

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I will vote laboour or monster raving loony party! now theres a party with iits head stuck on right

My view is that if you dont vote you cant really use that to moarn about there not be a party or the system doesnt work. If you dont like it vote for a inderpendent MP and then try to change the system.

Personnally I dont see whats actually wrong with the system? The countrys doing ok, The system is doing alright

Mr_love_monkey 18-03-2004 09:07

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Who will I vote for next time? - That's a tough one.

At the moment I'm toying with the idea of getting together a campaign to get people to deface their ballot papers - with the hope being that if we get enough people to do it, then maybe it would show the general unhappiness with all the options on offer - It's idealistic and would probably have no effect, but I can dream.... :)

These days, it's hard to tell the difference between Lab and Con, since Lab has gone to the right, Con has gone to the left, and they've met in the middle. Policies between the 2 these days seem to consist of one party saying "we're going to do X" and the other party saying "Oh yes, we were going to do that", or "That's what we thought too". - Look at this budget just gone by - The amount being saved in public spending by reducing the civil service jobs, is exactly the same amount that the conservatives were planning on cutting it by.

The Lib Dems, to me, are still an nothing party - perhaps if one day they get a leader who has something going for him, rather than just a large backside, which is needed so that he can sit on all those fences - maybe I'll think that voting for them won't be a waste of a vote - at the end of the day, I don't see how you can vote for a party that won't actually decide what it is they stand for, other than the usual nah-saying of whatever the government does. I lost track of the number of things that Charles Kennedy refused to give an opinion on. How can you have any political respect for a party that basically says 'we have some opinions, but we're not going to tell you what they are'.

The rest of the parties are all seat fillers, that have zero chance of ever getting elected.

So basically the answer is, I don't know....

Maybe I'll stand, and try and make Waddon a Repulic.

timewarrior2001 18-03-2004 09:27

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
I meant that I wanted to see about which partys where ahead. Otherwise the pages would be filled with pages about voter aperthy

Also, I dont really think that anyone can defend the BNP

I dont think people can defend labours track record either, they are just as bad as the conservatives were when they got voted out.
What you have to realise with the likes of the BNP is that the BNP is the political party, the NF, C18 etc are all hangers on, the ones that commit the violence are NOT the BNP.
The people that are so against right wing parties need to realise that a lot of people are against left wing parties also. The people that claim racism is rife need to look at the poor white charity worker who was not allowed to attend a charity dinner because of the colour of her skin (was in the papers yesterday). The BNP is going to gain more power because the law allows situations like these to happen. Many people in this country do not want the asylum seekers, they do not want migrant workers, look at the political parties on offer, who do you think will get the vote from these people?

However this is not important, If I vote BNP then thats my choice, If I dont vote thats also my choice.

What we need is a section on the ballot that says "None of the above" which is a way to register that the party manifestos are not convincing and are not what the public wants.

Mr_love_monkey 18-03-2004 09:47

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by timewarrior2001
Many people in this country do not want the asylum seekers, they do not want migrant workers, look at the political parties on offer, who do you think will get the vote from these people?

This, I think, is going to be why, eventually, a party like the BNP will come to power. People are so fed up with the influx of migrants, asylum seekers, etc, whom, they feel, rightly or wrongly, are responsible for the high council tax, bad public services, lack of jobs (after all, despite what the figures say, has unemployment gone down? - I don't think so - juggling the figures so that people on a 'find a job' scheme don't show up as unemployed, is not the same as making sure people have work).

So what will happen is the BNP (or someone) will say, yes, we'll stop the influx, we'll get council tax down, we'll stop Johnnie Foreigner taking all the jobs - and people will be disillusioned and angry enough to want to show they they have had enough, and that they want something done about the issues - and they will vote for them. Of course they won't see the small print - which says 'oh yes, and after we've done that - we start forcibly repatriating people, that we don't consider to be 'pure' british, never mind if you've been here all your life, eventually it will be if you're not what we consider to be the ideal white person, then chances are you're being removed' - and when it does start happening, and when they do start knocking on my door, on my neighbours door, by then it will be too late.

I'm reminded of a poem by Reverend Martin Niemoller
Quote:

First they came for the Communists, but I was not a Communist so I did not speak out.
Then they came for the Socialists and the Trade Unionists, but I was neither, so I did not speak out.
Then they came for the Jews, but I was not a Jew so I did not speak out. And when they came for me, there was no one left to speak out for me.
A country that is politically unhappy and politically unstable is a dangerous country - it leaves the field open for extremists - would Hitler's National Socialist party come to power if Germany hadn't been in such economic strife, if they weren't so unhappy with the (then) current political set up? Hitler came along and gave them an easy target to blame all the troubles on - someone they could vent their resentment at - and when people realised what was going on, it was too late.

timewarrior2001 18-03-2004 09:59

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_love_monkey
This, I think, is going to be why, eventually, a party like the BNP will come to power. People are so fed up with the influx of migrants, asylum seekers, etc, whom, they feel, rightly or wrongly, are responsible for the high council tax, bad public services, lack of jobs (after all, despite what the figures say, has unemployment gone down? - I don't think so - juggling the figures so that people on a 'find a job' scheme don't show up as unemployed, is not the same as making sure people have work).

So what will happen is the BNP (or someone) will say, yes, we'll stop the influx, we'll get council tax down, we'll stop Johnnie Foreigner taking all the jobs - and people will be disillusioned and angry enough to want to show they they have had enough, and that they want something done about the issues - and they will vote for them. Of course they won't see the small print - which says 'oh yes, and after we've done that - we start forcibly repatriating people, that we don't consider to be 'pure' british, never mind if you've been here all your life, eventually it will be if you're not what we consider to be the ideal white person, then chances are you're being removed' - and when it does start happening, and when they do start knocking on my door, on my neighbours door, by then it will be too late.

I'm reminded of a poem by Reverend Martin Niemoller


A country that is politically unhappy and politically unstable is a dangerous country - it leaves the field open for extremists - would Hitler's National Socialist party come to power if Germany hadn't been in such economic strife, if they weren't so unhappy with the (then) current political set up? Hitler came along and gave them an easy target to blame all the troubles on - someone they could vent their resentment at - and when people realised what was going on, it was too late.

I agree to an extent, the government can be sacked by the queen so I dont think it would get as far as forcibly repatriating. Although it is alarming something has to be done, the warning signs are there. I will never condemn the BNP but I also will never condone them. They are after all a representation of some of the populous.

Mr_love_monkey 18-03-2004 10:03

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by timewarrior2001
I agree to an extent, the government can be sacked by the queen so I dont think it would get as far as forcibly repatriating.

I'd be very interested to see what happened if the Queen tried to sack the/any government.....

The Royal family really has a figure head role these days, who knows what would happen if they actually tried to use some of the old influence they had?

Quote:

Originally Posted by timewarrior2001
I will never condemn the BNP but I also will never condone them. They are after all a representation of some of the populous.

Yes, that's the thing really, inorder to be a free country you have to allow people their views even if you find them distasteful - their political views are just as valid as ours - As Voltare said "I don't believe in what you say, but I will fight for your right to say it" - if we start excluding parties from the process, that makes us no better than they are.

Russ 18-03-2004 10:25

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JustAnotherN00b
OK best mention to the following that they are not democracies:

Argentina
Australia
Austria
Belgium
Bolivia
Brazil
Cyprus
Dominican Republic
Egypt
Greece
Guatemala
Honduras
Liechenstein
Luxembourg
Panama
Philippines
Singapore
Switzerland (some cantons only)
Uruguay
Venezuela


With the greatest of respect, what's that got to do with anything? I don't live in any of those countries?

punky 18-03-2004 11:07

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I'd vote Tory, but i'm still not happy about that fool Howard running the country. He's gotta be better than Blair thought.

I so wish IDS was still the leader of the conservatives, He' would be a good PM IMHO.

Stuart 18-03-2004 11:38

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
With the greatest of respect, what's that got to do with anything? I don't live in any of those countries?


I think JANoob was making a point that compulsory voting doesn't stop a democracy.

MovedGoalPosts 18-03-2004 12:03

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Since there's clearly so many who feel unable to vote, as the current options offer no real choice, or through the party system, you like part of the manifesto, but hate other parts, we need something different. So a suggestion, albeit I'm not sure how practical it is.

Voters are presented with a range of policies for each issue, and options on those policies, at the ballot, the voter selects their preference for each option, do it, don't do it, spend more, spend less, etc. It's not a case of having one separate ballot for each different issue, like is proposed if we ever do go for ditching the pound. There would be one ballot dealing with lots of issues. Yes ballots might need to be held every year, instead of every 4-5 years, but effectively we do that for local councils.

As to how we then choose our MPs or whoever, it would probably be some sort of proportional representation, based on the supporters of the different policies.

Ignition 18-03-2004 12:10

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
With the greatest of respect, what's that got to do with anything? I don't live in any of those countries?

Just with greatest of respect pointing out that compulsory voting certainly doesn't kill off a democracy. I don't live in any of them either but would imagine I'd be quite offended if someone accused my country of not being democratic because I am required to go to the polling booth (not actually required to vote, once in the booth can do whatever you wish with the paper, secret ballot!)

It's viewed as a civic duty along with paying your taxes, etc. I wouldn't mind seeing it introduced here... we'd be in with a chance of getting a Government that was actually voted for by a majority instead of low turnouts as people don't want to choose between the helpless and the hopeless.

zendawn 18-03-2004 12:11

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Theres an 'other' section ya know?

All other partys can go in there and again if you dont wanna vote they this is not the topic for you as it will just lead to people complaining about the system and such.

Eh? What's got up you?

I was on about the real elections, not your vote. :)

There should be a 'NONE of the Above' section on the REAL election ballot. IMHO

Then there would be no excuse for apathy, as a non vote could be registered.

zendawn 18-03-2004 12:17

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JustAnotherN00b
It's viewed as a civic duty along with paying your taxes, etc. I wouldn't mind seeing it introduced here... we'd be in with a chance of getting a Government that was actually voted for by a majority instead of low turnouts as people don't want to choose between the helpless and the hopeless.

Yes I agree, voting is a right as well as a duty, one which many people have fought (sp?) and died for.
Altho I dont agree with compulsory voting, I think PR would go a long way to redressing the apathy most people feel when they vote on the FPTP system.

If your stuck in a strongly one sided constituency, it so easy to feel your vote is futile, But with PR even a relative small number of votes can make a difference.

I like the Starship Troopers approach too, where you have to have served in the army before you can vote. :)
Or at least the Peace corps if not the army, so as to gain a sense of civic responsibility.

erol 18-03-2004 12:17

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
I am reminded of that great Gore Vidal quote that goes along the lines of

'Don't vote - it only encourages them' :)

Personaly I would like to see an option of 'none of the above' on ballot forms. I rarely voted in the UK, not because I was too lazy or unconcerned to do so, but simply because there was no one that I wanted to vote ofr. I would have voted however if I could have actively shown that there was no one that I wanted to vote for, if you see what I mean. A general election where the biggest single 'winner' was 'none of the above' would send a pretty clear signal to the existing parties imo.

Mr_love_monkey 18-03-2004 12:27

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by erol
A general election where the biggest single 'winner' was 'none of the above' would send a pretty clear signal to the existing parties imo.

It's an idea I like as well..... but what would you do afterwards? - who would be incontrol of the country afterwards? - and how long would that state last?

erol 18-03-2004 12:34

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_love_monkey
It's an idea I like as well..... but what would you do afterwards? - who would be incontrol of the country afterwards? - and how long would that state last?

the party with the most votes would still win the election - it's just they would not be able to swagger around thinking they had a mandate from the majority of the electorate, if more people had said 'none of the above' than voted for the winning party. It _might_ bring a bit of humility to them and mediate their behviour. Least thats how I see it.

Mr_love_monkey 18-03-2004 12:41

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by erol
the party with the most votes would still win the election - it's just they would not be able to swagger around thinking they had a mandate from the majority of the electorate, if more people had said 'none of the above' than voted for the winning party. It _might_ bring a bit of humility to them and mediate their behviour. Least thats how I see it.

Nice idea, but I don't think it would work that way. There's no humility in politics (I feel anyway) - I'm sure they'd still see it as a 'storming victory' - because they still got more votes than the other parties. The only way it would work would be for 'none of the above' to be a valid result - and that no one be in power. That's the only way they would ever listen.

...but it comes back to my question of what you would do if there was no clear winner. A coalition of political parties? - each one having a voice - no matter how distasteful it might be (a la BNP) - the 2 strongest forming a coalition?

Does anyone else have any ideas?

zendawn 18-03-2004 12:50

Re: How will you vote at next election?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_love_monkey
Nice idea, but I don't think it would work that way. There's no humility in politics (I feel anyway) - I'm sure they'd still see it as a 'storming victory' - because they still got more votes than the other parties. The only way it would work would be for 'none of the above' to be a valid result - and that no one be in power. That's the only way they would ever listen.

Does anyone else have any ideas?

Yes its a tuff one, off course you would hope that the other parties would take some sort of notice and change, but like you said Politicians arent well know for their humility.

But they do need some sort of 'bloody nose' cuz even with the beating the Conservatives got in the last 2 elections they still havent learnt any lessions, and Labour are still too cocky to take any notice of anything sort of a landslide lose.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:28.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum