Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   There is graffiti and then there is graffiti (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=50151)

Maggy 19-07-2006 19:39

There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/bristol/5193552.stm

Quote:

A piece of graffiti by Bristol artist Banksy has been allowed to stay after what the city council described as "overwhelming support" from the public.
I must say it's not really graffiti..it's modern art.:)

AndrewJ 19-07-2006 19:40

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
I like it, not the normal rubbish you see on walls :) someones took some time to make that.

Wicked_and_Crazy 19-07-2006 20:03

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Incognitas
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/bristol/5193552.stm



I must say it's not really graffiti..it's modern art.:)

Contemporary art ;) but as it unauthorized defacing of a building it has to be graffiti

Xaccers 19-07-2006 22:29

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
What ever happened to the really good graffiti artists of the 80's?
Now all I see are simple things like "Baz woz ere" repeated 20 times and very little art

Gareth 19-07-2006 22:45

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Banksy has done some fantastic stuff. Check out his website... www.banksy.co.uk - he really is a truly talented artist.

Saying that, it is graffiti... but so are the street artists you get in Bath city centre. I tolerate this style, as would most people, cause at least it is artistic and not just a plain nuisance.

Gareth 17-09-2006 22:21

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
:bump:

I'm a big fan of Banksy's work, but I just saw this... http://supertouchblog.com/?p=317

There's something not quite right when A-List celebs like Brad and Angelina are snapping up pieces of Banksy's "revolutionary" art to adorn their Hollywood mansions. :( Has he finally sold out...?

Kliro 17-09-2006 22:24

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
'fraid it looks like he has...

Cobbydaler 17-09-2006 22:38

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Well two different viewpoints on it from the comments on that site:

Quote:

Some of it is great work, but how many wisecracks do you need to make a point, to me most of the work has a subversive/ revolutionairy context but on the other hand how revolutionairy can you get when selling art for 100k and up to industrials, actors and other media figures. If it would be 100$ a piece it would be way more radical, if you catch my drift.
Quote:

Well done Banksy. 100k price tags! Ha ha ha. You totally ripped the pish oot these rich Hollywood knobbers. Love and Respect

Kliro 17-09-2006 22:45

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Interesting. But I've heard he takes legal advice n' that before doing any piece - so is he truly trying to make a statement, or just doing it for the moolah?

It would make a statement if he replicated the pieces he sold for 100k and sold them for 100 quid.

danielf 17-09-2006 22:52

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Do you have to be poor to have a conscience then?

(I should add I'm not very familiar with Banksy's work)

Kliro 17-09-2006 22:58

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
I don't really get that statement?

danielf 17-09-2006 23:03

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kliro (Post 34118825)
I don't really get that statement?

Why is he accused of 'selling out'? Why is he not credible (apparently) when his work fetches big money?

Kliro 17-09-2006 23:10

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
He was at first seen as someone who took a stand, made political points - he was like the voice of the 'small people'

Now people feel he's pandering to clients - working for companies etc. he's not their voice anymore and he doesn't give a damn about them. etc.

Cobbydaler 17-09-2006 23:11

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
As far as I can see, his artworks aren't overtly political (even though he's done pieces on the wall separating Israel from the West Bank), therefore he can't be accused of 'selling out' in that sense...

If, however, you see all graffiti type art as radical or revolutionary then you could hold to that opinion...

Kliro 17-09-2006 23:17

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
A lot of it takes some sort of political stance.

The 'dead' red phone box to sybolise their 'killing' off

Kissing policemen - as gayness in the police was/is taboo.

etc.

Maggy 17-09-2006 23:50

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
He is an artist who merely uses graffitti as his medium of choice.As to selling out how the hell do you draw that inference?People have to eat and have a place to sleep.Art has always come at a price and too many artists have starved in garrets.Too right that he sells his work at the highest price he can.

Frankly I'd like to step back in time and buy a Van Gogh or two..He might not have died thinking he was despised as an artist then and I'd have a fantastic work of art.

Gareth 18-09-2006 00:11

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
It's more to do with the fact that he's a radicalist, a self-declared "art terrorist", which makes me beg the question as to whether he has "sold out".

The NY Times apparently considered it too
Quote:

Originally Posted by NY Times
Such a show — complete with advance publicity, an opening party with valet parking and Hollywood glitterati, including Jude Law and his posse, and sales of numbered prints at $500 each — would seem to go against Banksy’s rebel image.

“Yes, there probably is some contradiction,” Banksy’s spokesman, Simon Munnery, said on Thursday in an interview at the warehouse in a commercial district east of downtown. (Details on the exhibition site can be found at www.banksy.co.uk.)

“It depends on what he does with the money, right?” Mr. Munnery added. “Maybe he makes more art. Maybe he’s getting more ambitious.”

source: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/16/ar...gn/16bank.html (subscription)


Maggy 18-09-2006 00:20

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
But it's a bit much to expect someone to have a talent and not profit by it...I mean you could say it about anyone really.What about people who take to a sport and become good at it and play for the sheer love of it..Then someone wants them to play for them professionally..would you consider that selling out?

Sometimes I think we are a bit too 'precious' about art.Frankly much as I love doing art for arts sake IF someone wanted to buy anything of mine I'd sell it in a heartbeat.:tu:

Kliro 18-09-2006 01:19

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
It's not the talent though - it was what people saw him as standing for before.

I can only use a fairly bad analogy here because it's late and I'm listening to country music (god knows why)

Say there was a small town/village where you lived. And there was a very talented councellor(sp?) who stood up for the village and made sure the voices were heard - you felt they made a difference.

Then they opted for a position of working for someone else, for more money - and no longer had your interests at heart.

bad analogy, but it makes sense to me.

SlackDad 18-09-2006 06:49

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Incognitas (Post 34118874)
But it's a bit much to expect someone to have a talent and not profit by it...I mean you could say it about anyone really.What about people who take to a sport and become good at it and play for the sheer love of it..Then someone wants them to play for them professionally..would you consider that selling out?

Sometimes I think we are a bit too 'precious' about art.Frankly much as I love doing art for arts sake IF someone wanted to buy anything of mine I'd sell it in a heartbeat.:tu:

Agree with you about being too precious about art. I don't particularly think the fact he's an artist makes any difference at all. It all depends on what type of statement he was making with his art. As I don't know too much about his work it is difficult for me too say, but if, for instance, his work took an anti-capitalist/establishment stance then you can see where the claims are coming from. I suppose also that supporters are worried that his work may lose its edge, in the same way that a young, more radical politician may soften their stance and supposed beliefs when they rise the ranks.

He may of course be taking the **** out of people with more money than sense, and if that is the case good luck to him. Interesting that Bristol Council have decided to keep his work. Wonder what came first? The Brad/Angelina sale or Bristol's decision?

hatedbythemail 18-09-2006 07:52

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
sold out? his paris hilton work was a subversive masterpiece! http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/5310416.stm

Gareth 18-09-2006 09:10

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad (Post 34118893)
He may of course be taking the **** out of people with more money than sense, and if that is the case good luck to him.

Yep, judging by this piece, I think you may be right.

https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2006/09/12.jpg

gazzae 18-09-2006 09:55

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
I see nothing wrong with him selling his art.
How come he is only selling out now when he has been producing books of his art for years?

Is there a certain threshold that you can earn up to before "selling out"?

Kliro 18-09-2006 13:46

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad (Post 34118893)

He may of course be taking the **** out of people with more money than sense, and if that is the case good luck to him. Interesting that Bristol Council have decided to keep his work. Wonder what came first? The Brad/Angelina sale or Bristol's decision?

bristols decision, it was made a good while ago now.

budwieser 18-09-2006 19:50

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
I don`t think `Banksy` is selling out at all, He`s a damn fine artist and if he can make some money out of it, Why not? :shrug:

me283 21-09-2006 18:15

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
I bought his book "Wall and Piece" a while back, and have to say it's amazing. Where the guy gets his ideas from is anybody's business; but not only that, to put them into such visuals is just genius.

Has he sold out? I don't think so. In this day and age, why not make a profit from something you can do well? After all, life is getting very expensive.

admars 15-10-2013 20:23

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Banksy Sells Original Artwork for $60 in Central Park

http://mashable.com/2013/10/14/banks...rtwork-cheap/#

Russ 15-10-2013 20:28

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Bump of the year...

tizmeinnit 15-10-2013 20:35

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by admars (Post 35632658)
Banksy Sells Original Artwork for $60 in Central Park

http://mashable.com/2013/10/14/banks...rtwork-cheap/#

and the world told banksy what they think lol

Hugh 15-10-2013 20:40

Re: There is graffiti and then there is graffiti
 
And look how much free advertising he got....


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:05.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum