Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Lifestyle (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   What happens when you die? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=4242)

ZrByte 15-11-2003 14:35

What happens when you die?
 
So what do you think happens when you die?
Just like people to post about what they think happens in those few moments it takes between life and death, and your views on what may happen afterwards.
As an Athiest I really dont believe in an afterlife, a lot of athiests I know say things like "I dont think there is a heaven but there must be something" I dont really agree with this, I dont think there has to be something, I kinda hope there is but I really cant imagine it, seems to go against everything I dont believe / Believe in.
Now the last few moments in life intrigue me, I wonder if you do see your entire life flash before your eyes? I really dont know what I believe, guess thats one of the biggest problems with not having a faith of sorts, the end for me is truley unknown, it does intrigue me though to hear other peoples views, maybe even get some ideas of my own.
Now I dont want this to turn into a flamewar (thats the dumbest thing I have ever heard, etc)
I just want constructive conversation, if there is something you dont like or understand about someones view try asking them to elaborate rather than smacking them down with goofy Smilies and lol's.
Oh and no short answers like "We goto Heaven" if thats all your gonna say then dont bother posting ;) :p now it would be interesting if you are going to say that if you could tell us what your view on heaven would be as im sure everyones view would be different (One mans Heaven is another mans Hell, etc)

Paul 15-11-2003 14:45

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Generally you get buried or cremated and that's the end of it. I don't, and never have, believed in anything more than this.

handyman 15-11-2003 15:11

Re: What happens when you die?
 
I don't belive in life after death, as for the life flashing before you, one would assume this is the last throws of your brain as it runs out of oxygen. I would imagine that this would create al sorts of dilusional images and what not.

Marge 15-11-2003 15:16

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Having had a near death experience a couple of years ago (car crash) I'm sorry to say I had no life flashing before my eyes etc nor did I feel frightend. I was aware of what was happening but had I kicked the bucket I firmly believe I wouldn't have known anything about it.

Bex 15-11-2003 15:50

Re: What happens when you die?
 
this is a fantastic topic, and one that i have studied in a philosophical sense.....i spent a year doing a course called "matters of life and death" very interesting stuff...

ok.....as for the thing that happens a moment before death, i do not know, i think that as hm said the lack of oxygen can cause you to have images and thoughts which you could perceive to be real but aren't

as for life after death, i believe in heaven....i do not know what heaven is like, but i know that i will come face to face with Jesus....i don't think of heaven as a place in the clouds, with angels with harps and such forth, but i do think that it will be a place of peace and glory

Bex 15-11-2003 15:52

Re: What happens when you die?
 
hell: ok my physics teacher once described hell in a very interesting way....his idea was that hell is continually living your life over and over again, making all the same mistakes and never being able to change them

ian@huth 15-11-2003 16:00

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Can there really be a near death experience? You can either be dead or alive and if you're dead you cannot tell others about it, unless there is something after death.

How does the brain store information? Is it stored in electrical form or chemical form or a combination of the two? Does the stored information vanish when you die or does it remain? Could a brain be transplanted and if so whose memory would it have?

Paul 15-11-2003 16:13

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
as for life after death, i believe in heaven....i do not know what heaven is like, but i know that i will come face to face with Jesus....i don't think of heaven as a place in the clouds, with angels with harps and such forth, but i do think that it will be a place of peace and glory

How do you know this, what proof or evidence do you have ?

Bex 15-11-2003 16:17

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianathuth
Can there really be a near death experience? You can either be dead or alive and if you're dead you cannot tell others about it, unless there is something after death.

How does the brain store information? Is it stored in electrical form or chemical form or a combination of the two? Does the stored information vanish when you die or does it remain? Could a brain be transplanted and if so whose memory would it have?

ok that depends on what your view is on the mind/body problem

materalism = the mind is something chemical......it is just impulses etc

dualism = mind and body are two disctinct entities, the mind is non-material, non-spatial, non-dividable, whereas the body is material, spatial and divisable

epi-phenominonalism = the mind and body are different entities but they are conencted normally this connection is ascribed to the amagadala )or something)

why am i saying this? no its not to show of, if one believes in either of the top two it will effect how one sees the afterlife

Bex 15-11-2003 16:18

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
How do you know this, what proof or evidence do you have ?

i believe in God, i believe in jesus, i believe that the bible is the "breathed word of God"

Russ 15-11-2003 16:22

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Hell = a lifetime of listening to Celine Dion :eek:

Actually I'd just consider hell to be an eternity without Big G.

And as been stated many times before, us Jesus-freaks don't need evidence or proof :)

peachey 15-11-2003 16:23

Re: What happens when you die?
 
It would be typical if nothing happened when you die

and all the arguing about it was just wishful thinking

still, you never really know

dilli-theclaw 15-11-2003 16:27

Re: What happens when you die?
 
I haven't got a clue either way - but it would be nive to meet my mum and my 1st son again.

But I can't choose to believe in something just for my own gratification.

I don't think I've really thought about it a lot.

Paul 15-11-2003 16:27

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
i believe in God, i believe in jesus, i believe that the bible is the "breathed word of God"

That's certainly an awful lot to believe in without any actual evidence to back it up.

Just in case you are wondering, I'm not going to say you are right or wrong, but I certainly don't believe in any of them as no one has offered me proof, or even evidence.

Even evidence is not always proof - Children believe in the Tooth Fairy and Santa Claus because all the evidence seems to suggest to them that they exist - but of course, this evidence is not really proof.

Bex 15-11-2003 16:30

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
<snip>Actually I'd just consider hell to be an eternity without Big G.

And as been stated many times before, us Jesus-freaks don't need evidence or proof :)

that indeed would be hell :(

Tricky 15-11-2003 16:32

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Having watched the Core on DVD last night - I don't think Hell exists as on the way to the centre of the earth they didn't pass any folk with red pointy horns and pitchforks. Therefore based on this evidence and the fact that the space shuttle has been around abit and never spotted the pearly gates. I think it's just over and out - Ya dead.

In a previous life I was a believer in the afterlife though!

Bex 15-11-2003 16:34

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
That's certainly an awful lot to believe in without any actual evidence to back it up.

Just in case you are wondering, I'm not going to say you are right or wrong, but I certainly don't believe in any of them as no one has offered me proof, or even evidence.

Even evidence is not always proof - Children believe in the Tooth Fairy and Santa Claus because all the evidence seems to suggest to them that they exist - but of course, this evidence is not really proof.

right ok i can totally see where you are coming from, not only did i used to think i needed pure and utter fact before i would believe in anything, i have also spoken to many people

you may think i am a bit :dunce: to believe in something which i can not see in front of me, but i have experienced God's presence, His peace and His power

i can not prove to you that God exists in the sense that you want it to be proven to you but i can lie out why i believe he exists, but since this is not a thread dedicated to that (and i dont want to be accused of tkaing over the thread) but as im sure most people know you are always welcome to discuss it with myself, and im sure russ and towny would not mind either

homealone 15-11-2003 16:35

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
ok that depends on what your view is on the mind/body problem

materalism = the mind is something chemical......it is just impulses etc

dualism = mind and body are two disctinct entities, the mind is non-material, non-spatial, non-dividable, whereas the body is material, spatial and divisable

epi-phenominonalism = the mind and body are different entities but they are conencted normally this connection is ascribed to the amagadala )or something)

why am i saying this? no its not to show of, if one believes in either of the top two it will effect how one sees the afterlife

Hi Bexy

it's amygdala

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...ygdala&spell=1

- and that's not intended to correct you, I just found it interesting (as was your post):)

Personally I would like to believe in the dualism theory - the materialism one smacks too much of us being governed by instinct only, for me, and I prefer to think our consciousness is more than that.

- I also like to think that something of that conciousness survives beyond death, but as to what "happens" to it, is another story. The Buddist theory of karma & re-incarnation is interesting, for example - but that isn't to say it's the "correct" one - we simply don't know.

Rubber Duck 15-11-2003 16:36

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
That's certainly an awful lot to believe in without any actual evidence to back it up.

Just in case you are wondering, I'm not going to say you are right or wrong, but I certainly don't believe in any of them as no one has offered me proof, or even evidence.

Even evidence is not always proof - Children believe in the Tooth Fairy and Santa Claus because all the evidence seems to suggest to them that they exist - but of course, this evidence is not really proof.


I think u just die & thatââ‚ ¬Ã¢â€žÂ¢s it,. I donââ‚Âà ‚¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â‚¬Å¾Ã‚¢t believe it god or an afterlife. I agree it hard to believe in anything religious (especially those days with all the horrible things that happen in the world) but I do respect other peopleââ‚Ãâ €šÂ¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â‚¬Å¾Ã‚¢s beliefs

Bex 15-11-2003 16:36

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tricky
Having watched the Core on DVD last night - I don't think Hell exists as on the way to the centre of the earth they didn't pass any folk with red pointy horns and pitchforks. Therefore based on this evidence and the fact that the space shuttle has been around abit and never spotted the pearly gates. I think it's just over and out - Ya dead.

In a previous life I was a believer in the afterlife though!

the idea that heaven is up there and hell down there is afaik not biblical......it doesnt state where these places are, but people have come to illustrate it this way

Bex 15-11-2003 16:38

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by homealone
Hi Bexy

it's amygdala

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...ygdala&spell=1

- and that's not intended to correct you, I just found it interesting (as was your post):)

Personally I would like to believe in the dualism theory - the materialism one smacks too much of us being governed by instinct only, for me, and I prefer to think our consciousness is more than that.

- I also like to think that something of that conciousness survives beyond death, but as to what "happens" to it, is another story. The Buddist theory of karma & re-incarnation is interesting, for example - but that isn't to say it's the "correct" one - we simply don't know.

gaz if you are interested in the theories i outlined and want to read up on them, pm me and i will point u in the direction of some good books

Tricky 15-11-2003 16:43

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
the idea that heaven is up there and hell down there is afaik not biblical......it doesnt state where these places are, but people have come to illustrate it this way

Agreed, except things associated with hell tend to indicate fire and warmth - I.e. closer to the core of the earth and on the same basis the higher you get the colder you become.

Russ 15-11-2003 16:44

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Well why not, we haven't had a thread on Christianity in ohhhh.....2 weeks? :D

So who wants to be this threads' first person to say religion causes wars??? :D :D

Tricky 15-11-2003 16:47

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Interesting:
Performing a www.googlefight.com for heaven and hell
then HELL wins...
But the fight between god and satan is won by god...

Bex 15-11-2003 16:47

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tricky
Agreed, except things associated with hell tend to indicate fire and warmth - I.e. closer to the core of the earth and on the same basis the higher you get the colder you become.

but that is merely the imagery that is created to explain hell.......
it comes originally from the greek mythology of the underworld......hades etc

Tricky 15-11-2003 16:53

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
but that is merely the imagery that is created to explain hell.......
it comes originally from the greek mythology of the underworld......hades etc

Wasn't that a room in Jet Set Willy (now that was a game) :notopic: Sorry!

dilli-theclaw 15-11-2003 16:57

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Drudge
Pretentious and inaccurate quote by Bexy
"epi-phenominonalism = the mind and body are different entities but they are conencted normally this connection is ascribed to the amagadala )or something)"

The accurate definition is:-

"The doctrine that mental activities are simply secondary occurances or facts that are directly perceptable by the senses, whether their underlying existance is proven or their natures understood, and are a result of the neural processes of the brain and have no causal influence"
Sorry Bexy but if you are out to impress then please get it right..

Never mind getting it right - can you please explain that to little thicky me - in ENGLISH :dunce:

Bex 15-11-2003 16:57

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Drudge
Pretentious and inaccurate quote by Bexy
"epi-phenominonalism = the mind and body are different entities but they are conencted normally this connection is ascribed to the amagadala )or something)"

The accurate definition is:-

"The doctrine that mental activities are simply secondary occurances or facts that are directly perceptable by the senses, whether their underlying existance is proven or their natures understood, and are a result of the neural processes of the brain and have no causal influence"
Sorry Bexy but if you are out to impress then please get it right..

excuse me i wasnt out to impress.....wtf is wrong with people on this site at the moment?

that definition i gave was a very simplfied version of the theory......believe me mate ive been studying this stuff for about 5years

ian@huth 15-11-2003 16:59

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Is there life after death is something that you can neither prove or disprove. Because you cannot prove it doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.

It is a bit like "do you believe there are UFOs and aliens". There is no concrete evidence that these exist, but logical thinking says that they probably do exist. It is hard to believe that there is no other planet somewhere that has life similar to ours. If there is such another planet sustaining life then would that planet have our God?

That leads to another question. Who or what is God?

Paul 15-11-2003 16:59

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
you may think i am a bit :dunce: to believe in something which i can not see in front of me, but i have experienced God's presence, His peace and His power

I don't think any such thing, everyone is entitled to believe in what they like as long as they don't expect me to believe the same.

Rubber Duck 15-11-2003 17:10

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
you may think i am a bit :dunce: to believe in something which i can not see in front of me, but i have experienced God's presence, His peace and His power



When, how & where?????

Bex 15-11-2003 17:11

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
I don't think any such thing, everyone is entitled to believe in what they like as long as they don't expect me to believe the same.

and i respect you not holding the same belief as me, as long as people are polite to each other and don't cuss each others beliefs then i have no problem

Bex 15-11-2003 17:12

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rubber Duck
When, how & where?????

that is something i am not willing to go into on a public forum....sorry

Rubber Duck 15-11-2003 17:28

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
that is something i am not willing to go into on a public forum....sorry


OK thatâ₠¬Ã‹Å“s fine. But if u don't want to go into it here why say u have felt gods strength in the first place if u are not willing to back your statement up by telling us none believers the positive ways god has affected your life??

Bex 15-11-2003 17:34

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rubber Duck
OK that‘s fine. But if u don't want to go into it here why say u have felt gods strength in the first place if u are not willing to back your statement up by telling us none believers the positive ways god has affected your life??

i was sim0ply illustrating that i can not prove to you that God exists or that i have actual facts but i have felt Gods presence.........the reason i will not post it here is because some people on this forum have made it clear that they like nothing more than to pick apart other peoples lives and beliefs and i am not willing to let people do that in this occasion

Bex 15-11-2003 18:33

Re: What happens when you die?
 
thanks for that drudge, but how dare you......

i was asked my opinon and i stated it, i have never said that someone who does not believe as i do is irrational.....

if you dont like what i believe then ignore it, there is no reason for you to do such things

i am entitled to believe what i believe without being ridiculed for it..

Bifta 15-11-2003 18:49

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
i was sim0ply illustrating that i can not prove to you that God exists or that i have actual facts but i have felt Gods presence

Can you prove to yourself or anyone else that "Gods presence" wasn't a trick of the mind? I think the answer is no.

Rubber Duck 15-11-2003 19:03

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
thanks for that drudge, but how dare you......


What do u mean †œHow dare youââ‚Âà ‚¬Ãƒâ€šÃ‚ to Drudge. Does this mean that in your opinion that people are not entitled to write what they think on the forum if it differs from YOUR thoughts? You do not have the authority to say such things.

Russ 15-11-2003 19:08

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Can you prove to yourself or anyone else that "Gods presence" wasn't a trick of the mind? I think the answer is no.

Personally I don't think a 'trick of the mind' exsists. My view is the experiences I have had with God were very real. He's communicated with me and I know it has only come from Him. Remember there is no requirement for us to prove anything to anyone. This defines 'faith'.

Quote:

What do u mean †œHow dare youââ‚Âà ‚¬Ãƒâ€šÃ‚ to Drudge. Does this mean that in your opinion that people are not entitled to write what they think on the forum if it differs from YOUR thoughts? You do not have the authority to say such things.
I think Bexy was just a little tired at the reasoning that Drudge came out with which to me shows someone (probably not Drudge) has gone to some lengths to show a theory which displays horrendous lack of knowledge and research.

Russ 15-11-2003 19:25

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

I strongly object to the "Probably not Drudge".
I apologise for any offense caused, it certainly wasn't intended. It's just I did not want to make it look as if I was singling you out.

Quote:

I am now 64 years of age and have spent many years in degree and ABOVE education.
A mature and educated debate is always welcome :)


Quote:

I am quite capable of decrying "fairy stories" without resort to extraneous sources.
And I strongly object to you referring to my faith as a 'fairy story'. You are entitled to believe whatever you see fit but common decency dictates you respect the beliefs of others.


Quote:

It is not acceptable in educated circles to merely state "A horrendous lack of knowledge" without the evidence and arguements needed to back up such a statement.

Agreed, allow me to elaborate slightly. I made that comment as I could not understand how someone as intelligent as yourself would come out with points 6, 7, 10 and 11 in your post. After all, I'm assuming you've researched the Bible on why there is evil in the world.

And I'm honoured that you see Nthellworld as an 'educated circle' - we've never been referred to in that way before :)

Jerrek 15-11-2003 19:35

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Personally I don't think a 'trick of the mind' exsists. My view is the experiences I have had with God were very real. He's communicated with me and I know it has only come from Him. Remember there is no requirement for us to prove anything to anyone. This defines 'faith'.

Likewise.

If you die knowing Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, you will resurrect with his return and enter Heaven. If you're alive at that time, you will disappear too. Then starts the 7 years of Tribulation.

If you die not knowing Jesus Christ, you will be resurrected at Judgment Day, when the rest of the people, even those that came to know Jesus during the Tribulation, will appear before God. If your name is not in the Book of Life, you will be cast into Hell forever.


You want proof? I think we will see proof in our lifetime. Laugh at me now, but when the Tribulation comes (thousands of people disappearing would be a sign), remember what I wrote here.


An excellent series of books to read is Left Behind.

Russ 15-11-2003 19:38

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Yes, the Left Behind books are incredible. Numerous best sellers and more than 50 million sold in series :)

peachey 15-11-2003 19:41

Re: What happens when you die?
 
I reckon that humans can believe
just about anything

Bex 15-11-2003 19:50

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Yes, the Left Behind books are incredible. Numerous best sellers and more than 50 million sold in series :)

:D awesome books....

Bifta 15-11-2003 20:19

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Personally I don't think a 'trick of the mind' exsists. My view is the experiences I have had with God were very real.

As I'm fairly confident that like even the greatest mind's in this world you do not have full working knowledge of how the brain function's in it's entirety then that's what it will remain "you don't think" it exists. You can also only realistically say that you "believe" God exists, you cannot 100% categorically say that he(she) does, however, I'm sure the bible stresses that you not deny God's existance. I believe in God (in some form or another, I'm not quite sure what) but that's all it is, belief, I cannot state outright that there is some all powerful being watching over us.

peachey 15-11-2003 20:24

Re: What happens when you die?
 
some of the ancient scholars
thought that god was 'unknowable'

ie - was not possible to get your head round it all

Russ 15-11-2003 20:24

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
As I'm fairly confident that like even the greatest mind's in this world you do not have full working knowledge of how the brain function's in it's entirety then that's what it will remain "you don't think" it exists. You can also only realistically say that you "believe" God exists, you cannot 100% categorically say that he(she) does, however, I'm sure the bible stresses that you not deny God's existance. I believe in God (in some form or another, I'm not quite sure what) but that's all it is, belief, I cannot state outright that there is some all powerful being watching over us.


You are absolutely right. I cannot say He DOES exist and have never done so. What I HAVE said is that I believe He's there, I have faith. Again you correctly say we don't know how the mind works but in my mind (pardon the pun) God uses all kinds of ways to communicate. It would be human to expect Him to do it only vocally but then again, He is more than just a human.

Quote:

Logical, intelligent discussion now dies, (UN)common sense flies out of the window. It is time to leave as no further discussion is possible against such strange, primitive beliefs
So because what Jerrek (and others) believe is not concurrant with how you see the world, it is any less valid? If you chose to leave this discussion it would indeed be a shame as you appeared to have the potential to bring some interesting angles to the table however if you are only willing to listen to and acknowledge one version then perhaps you have made the right decision.

ZrByte 15-11-2003 20:55

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

So because what Jerrek (and others) believe is not concurrant with how you see the world, it is any less valid? If you chose to leave this discussion it would indeed be a shame as you appeared to have the potential to bring some interesting angles to the table however if you are only willing to listen to and acknowledge one version then perhaps you have made the right decision.
I think the problem with Jerreks post is that he says it so 'Matter of Factly' theres no IMO or I believe in his post (Appologies if there are Jerrek ;) )

I do like some of the comments so far, Glad to see im not the only Athiest who doesnt see some light at the end of the tunnel. A Pitty some peoples minds are allready so set in stone though, you dont neccessarily need a yes/no answer, there is a whole Grey area in the middle.

Quote:

Personally I don't think a 'trick of the mind' exsists. My view is the experiences I have had with God were very real. He's communicated with me and I know it has only come from Him. Remember there is no requirement for us to prove anything to anyone. This defines 'faith'.
I do believe in things such as a trick of the mind (You get drunk right now and tell me your mind doesnt play tricks on you then ;) )
Not to disprove you in anyway, as you said this defines your faith, the possibility always exists though that this was simply a trick of your mind (One of many possibilities including the one you believe)

I would like if anyone is willing to post, some of your own Deffinitions of Heaven :angel: and some of your own deffinitions of hell :batty: (Or any alternatives you may have)
As said earlier I do not personally believe in an afterlife but I have been thinking about this all day. Your Brain uses Chemical electricity to work doesnt it? (I may be completeley wrong here) this energy has to go somewhere so what happens to the energy when you die? is it simply released? is it released containing your essence where you wonder the earth as a ghost or move onto an afterlife? does this energy exist on a higher plane? (Not like afterlife, more of a higher level of existance that does not require the presence of an omnipotent being)

So many questions and so few answers, as said previously we will not know until we die, though not to mock the Christians here I do find Judgement day one of the least likley possibilities, I just dont buy into this whole 'gods coming to get ya' motif it has (Wont the egg be on my Face if it happens :D )

Jerrek 15-11-2003 21:08

Re: What happens when you die?
 
How about What if?

What will you guys do if you suddenly find millions of people missing? (Pulled away by Jesus) Would you believe? Would you grab a Bible and start reading?

Those seven years are not going to be a whole lot of fun.

Xaccers 15-11-2003 21:14

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jerrek
How about What if?

What will you guys do if you suddenly find millions of people missing? (Pulled away by Jesus) Would you believe? Would you grab a Bible and start reading?

Those seven years are not going to be a whole lot of fun.

In all honesty? I'd hope I had a chance to punch god up the bracket and be grateful that I'm not one of those to be picked for resurrection

peachey 15-11-2003 21:17

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
In all honesty? I'd hope I had a chance to punch god up the bracket and be grateful that I'm not one of those to be picked for resurrection


I overheard a teenager arguing with her father about church
and stuff a while back

"I don't want eternal life", she said "I'm bored enough as it is"

Bex 15-11-2003 21:19

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
In all honesty? I'd hope I had a chance to punch god up the bracket and be grateful that I'm not one of those to be picked for resurrection

why?

Xaccers 15-11-2003 21:26

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
why?


Because if the bible is to be believed he is a genocidal tyrant.

Remember Bex, I'm not a christian, so I can't ignore the awful things that the bible says he has done (and I'm not getting confused with things done in his name, those were done by idiots who were just human).

"Live my way or die" that's basically what the bible says.
I guess a simplified view would be as Eddie Izzard put it, death or cake, and I can't agree with that.

Bex 15-11-2003 21:32

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
Because if the bible is to be believed he is a genocidal tyrant.

Remember Bex, I'm not a christian, so I can't ignore the awful things that the bible says he has done (and I'm not getting confused with things done in his name, those were done by idiots who were just human).

"Live my way or die" that's basically what the bible says.
I guess a simplified view would be as Eddie Izzard put it, death or cake, and I can't agree with that.

thats fair enough i respect your view...i wasnt asking you to repsond in a christian way hun, i just wondered why...i am not going to say whether you are right or wrong, at the end of the day it is your belief.........

has anyone ever heard of pascal's wager? he basically says that if we believe in God and he doesnt exist then we don't lose anything, and if we believe in him and he does we gain
if we don't believe and he does exist then we lose out
therefore, he concludes we should believe in god

personally i think this is a terrible basis for belief, but i thought i would throw it into the discussion

peachey 15-11-2003 21:36

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
thats fair enough i respect your view...i wasnt asking you to repsond in a christian way hun, i just wondered why...i am not going to say whether you are right or wrong, at the end of the day it is your belief.........

has anyone ever heard of pascal's wager? he basically says that if we believe in God and he doesnt exist then we don't lose anything, and if we believe in him and he does we gain
if we don't believe and he does exist then we lose out
therefore, he concludes we should believe in god

personally i think this is a terrible basis for belief, but i thought i would throw it into the discussion

there shrodingers cat aswell

that's a conundrum

Xaccers 15-11-2003 21:37

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
thats fair enough i respect your view...i wasnt asking you to repsond in a christian way hun, i just wondered why...i am not going to say whether you are right or wrong, at the end of the day it is your belief.........

has anyone ever heard of pascal's wager? he basically says that if we believe in God and he doesnt exist then we don't lose anything, and if we believe in him and he does we gain
if we don't believe and he does exist then we lose out
therefore, he concludes we should believe in god

personally i think this is a terrible basis for belief, but i thought i would throw it into the discussion


I know bex, and I'm not belittling you for your own beliefs, as an athiest it's important to me that people come to their own beliefs through their own research and path, and deserve respect for that.

I've heard of pascal's wager, and you're right, it does seem a daft basis for belief.
You would be believing for the sake of the prize, not for the sake of faith

Bex 15-11-2003 21:37

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peachey
there shrodingers cat aswell

that's a conundrum

care to elaborate?

Bex 15-11-2003 21:39

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
I know bex, and I'm not belittling you for your own beliefs, as an athiest it's important to me that people come to their own beliefs through their own research and path, and deserve respect for that.

I've heard of pascal's wager, and you're right, it does seem a daft basis for belief.
You would be believing for the sake of the prize, not for the sake of faith

indeed, if one is accepting God because of the fact that they might just go to heaven they don't really believe..but then i should not judge

peachey 15-11-2003 21:40

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
care to elaborate?

http://www.phobe.com/s_cat/s_cat.html

he used it as an example about quantum mechanics in a lecture

and was quizzed about it for the rest of his life

I don't think he kept an actual cat in real life though

Stuart 15-11-2003 21:52

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Well, this may already have been posted (I got an error posting it).

We are all entitled to our beliefs.

I personally think that logic would suggest we were created by some force or being (I refuse to believe that this universe and those living within it were created by a set of coincidences), that being or force doesn't necessarily exist in any form we can measure or detect now.

As to what happens when we die, I don't know (and I don't think we will ever find conclusive evidence of what happens), but I would like to think there is an after life. I find it sort of comforting thinking that the people & pets I have known that have died have some sort of afterlife.

peachey 15-11-2003 21:57

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scastle
Well, this may already have been posted (I got an error posting it).

We are all entitled to our beliefs.

I personally think that logic would suggest we were created by some force or being (I refuse to believe that this universe and those living within it were created by a set of coincidences), that being or force doesn't necessarily exist in any form we can measure or detect now.

As to what happens when we die, I don't know (and I don't think we will ever find conclusive evidence of what happens), but I would like to think there is an after life. I find it sort of comforting thinking that the people & pets I have known that have died have some sort of afterlife.

I remember reading something about some guy who was held in some regard somewhere - can't remember who or where

but he seemed to think that the 'design' of a kidney indicated the presence of a god

such was the meticulous nature of its function


not sure what frey bentos and peter's pies thought about that

Xaccers 15-11-2003 21:59

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scastle
I personally think that logic would suggest we were created by some force or being (I refuse to believe that this universe and those living within it were created by a set of coincidences),

I dissagree, logic suggests we were created by a series of physical laws, ie this atom joins with that one and forms a molecule which joins with that other molecule and hey presto you get amonio acids, and then proteins and dns etc.
A force or being (other than nuclear forces :D ) are not required.

The example the JW's use to backup the "can't be coincidence" stance is a garden rake in a washing machine.
Removed the head from a garden rake, bung both parts in a washing machine and no matter what, that head isn't going to fix to the end of the shaft.

I pointed out that if the head and end of shaft were oppositly charged (such as the charge on ions) they'd quite happily fix together.

Bex 15-11-2003 22:01

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peachey
I remember reading something about some guy who was held in some regard somewhere - can't remember who or where

but he seemed to think that the 'design' of a kidney indicated the presence of a god

such was the meticulous nature of its function


not sure what frey bentos and peter's pies thought about that

similar to paley's watch analogy

Stuart 15-11-2003 22:02

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
I dissagree, logic suggests we were created by a series of physical laws, ie this atom joins with that one and forms a molecule which joins with that other molecule and hey presto you get amonio acids, and then proteins and dns etc.
A force or being (other than nuclear forces :D ) are not required.

Something defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Bex 15-11-2003 22:02

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
I dissagree, logic suggests we were created by a series of physical laws, ie this atom joins with that one and forms a molecule which joins with that other molecule and hey presto you get amonio acids, and then proteins and dns etc.
A force or being (other than nuclear forces :D ) are not required.

The example the JW's use to backup the "can't be coincidence" stance is a garden rake in a washing machine.
Removed the head from a garden rake, bung both parts in a washing machine and no matter what, that head isn't going to fix to the end of the shaft.

I pointed out that if the head and end of shaft were oppositly charged (such as the charge on ions) they'd quite happily fix together.

:dunce: i don;t get the jw thing

Stuart 15-11-2003 22:05

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
:dunce: i don;t get the jw thing

Bexy, I think Xaccers is assuming both head and handle are metal. Therefore magnetism would attract them.

peachey 15-11-2003 22:08

Re: What happens when you die?
 
so what is the point of mankind?

why take the risk inventing 'it'

from the bible it seems that several attempts were made at it
each malfinctioning one being 'wiped out'
by this and that sort of disaster - apparently due to it not being able to tow the line

where is god's gain?

why not stick with rabbits and trees and stuff?

Xaccers 15-11-2003 22:08

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scastle
Something defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Did it?
Why did something have to conciously define the laws, why can't it be that the way the laws work are the only way they can work?

Xaccers 15-11-2003 22:11

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scastle
Bexy, I think Xaccers is assuming both head and handle are metal. Therefore magnetism would attract them.

Yup, like ions attract each other, hence why we have chemical reactions :)

idi banashapan 15-11-2003 22:11

Re: What happens when you die?
 
all matter is merely energy condensed to a slow vibration. We are all one consciousness experiencing itself subjectively. There is no such thing as death, life is only a dream and we are the imagination of ourselves.

ZrByte 15-11-2003 22:13

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Ahem!
Original: Something defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Edited to be PC: Something May have defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Please stop stating things like they are correct or fact when they clearly are not ;)

Things seem to happen in a chain reaction, It makes me think that only one Key event needed to happen for the universe as we know it to cascade out, so what you see as a series of highly inprobable coincidences is actually just one slightly more probably incident. A damn sight more believable IMO (I dont know what this action was but I believe 100% that this is how it happened).

Stuart 15-11-2003 22:15

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
Did it?
Why did something have to conciously define the laws, why can't it be that the way the laws work are the only way they can work?

Logic would suggest that something caused those laws to be created, even if they can only work in one way.

Thinking like this makes my head hurt... :(

peachey 15-11-2003 22:17

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZrByte
Ahem!
Original: Something defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Edited to be PC: Something May have defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Please stop stating things like they are correct or fact when they clearly are not ;)

Things seem to happen in a chain reaction, It makes me think that only one Key event needed to happen for the universe as we know it to cascade out, so what you see as a series of highly inprobable coincidences is actually just one slightly more probably incident. A damn sight more believable IMO (I dont know what this action was but I believe 100% that this is how it happened).

some guy also reckoned space was 'curved'
and it was theoritically possible to see the other side of, say, a building if you approached it at the speed of light

which is all fair and good but no help telling it to an irate cmr on the line in a crappy call centre on low wages

Stuart 15-11-2003 22:33

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZrByte
Ahem!
Original: Something defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Edited to be PC: Something May have defined the physical laws which make that happen.

Please stop stating things like they are correct or fact when they clearly are not ;)

I am not stating it as fact, merely as logic. Everything has a start and an end (in theory anyway). Everything is also created (apart from energy which is merely converted from another form). Every effect has a cause.

peachey 15-11-2003 22:38

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scastle
I am not stating it as fact, merely as logic. Everything has a start and an end (in theory anyway). Everything is also created (apart from energy which is merely converted from another form). Every effect has a cause.

not strictly true

there is a symbol of a snake swallowing its own tail
as a sort of symbol of eternity

either that or ntl have a new staffing policy

Bex 15-11-2003 22:41

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peachey
not strictly true

there is a symbol of a snake swallowing its own tail
as a sort of symbol of eternity

either that or ntl have a new staffing policy

what?

Stuart 15-11-2003 22:45

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peachey
not strictly true

there is a symbol of a snake swallowing its own tail
as a sort of symbol of eternity

either that or ntl have a new staffing policy

But the snake still has a start and an end.

But apart from that: Eh? What?

Xaccers 15-11-2003 22:46

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Is there a way to configure my profile to ignore posts from certain people? :rolleyes:

Bex 15-11-2003 22:49

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers
Is there a way to configure my profile to ignore posts from certain people? :rolleyes:

we can live in hope..that would be a grand idea actually :D:idea:

peachey 15-11-2003 22:52

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
we can live in hope..that would be a grand idea actually :D:idea:


so you can hear only what you want to hear?

I was just illustrating where the infinity symbol came from

ZrByte 15-11-2003 22:57

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Click profile on the person you want to ignore then under contact details click add user to ignore list.....
But that really is just burrying your head in the sand.

Mick 15-11-2003 22:58

Re: What happens when you die?
 
My mum went to see a medium a few years after her dad died, she sat in this room not sure of what was to follow and not being a great believer in this life after death stuff. Mum never gave long answers it was either a yes or no response the medium was after. - Mum did not want to give anything away.

If there is no life after death, then I want to know how this lady managed to discuss really private information that only her and her dad were aware of, nothing written down, only in the heart. Mum felt the room go cold and this lady was just belting out loads of information that was so accurate that I believe my mother made contact with her dad.

Bex 15-11-2003 23:07

Re: What happens when you die?
 
dr p i am not saying anything about your belief in this

but mediums is something i am sceptical about

homealone 15-11-2003 23:15

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scastle
I am not stating it as fact, merely as logic. Everything has a start and an end (in theory anyway). Everything is also created (apart from energy which is merely converted from another form). Every effect has a cause.

have you been watching the 'Theory of Everything' series on Ch4?

The last episode in the series tomorrow 20.00 - clashes with Top Gear :mad:

- string theory is cool - one thought of mine is that theology could be "inside out", rather than "outside in" - i.e "God" is the concept of the ultimate organisation of the Universe, for example? - I mean how it's built, not who built it? - and I sincerely don't want to offend anyone by my speculative remark.

Mick 15-11-2003 23:16

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
dr p i am not saying anything about your belief in this

but mediums is something i am sceptical about

I'm in the same boat bexy, I'm sceptical, but how did the medium know what she knew and able to pass this on to my mum ? The only way is if she connected to my grandad. Some say these mediums go about looking through peoples rubbish bins looking for clues or tricking people into telling them more for the medium to turn it around and say this this and this. But I repeat that nothing was ever written down, the information could of only been passed to my mum to validate that the medium was connected to my grandad.

My mum tried to get a second booking with this medium, but she is so busy, she was booked up for a whole year before she was taking any further bookings. :erm:

Bex 15-11-2003 23:20

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Plummer
I'm in the same boat bexy, I'm sceptical, but how did the medium know what she knew and able to pass this on to my mum ? The only way is if she connected to my grandad. Some say these mediums go about looking through peoples rubbish bins looking for clues or tricking people into telling them more for the medium to turn it around and say this this and this. But I repeat that nothing was ever written down, the information could of only been passed to my mum to validate that the medium was connected to my grandad.

My mum tried to get a second booking with this medium, but she is so busy, she was booked up for a whole year before she was taking any further bookings. :erm:

well i think that we give of certain signs and movements which let them know they are on the right track...

but i think it is dabbling with the occult and i keep well away from it (let me just reiterated that i said I THINK)

peachey 15-11-2003 23:20

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Plummer
I'm in the same boat bexy, I'm sceptical, but how did the medium know what she knew and able to pass this on to my mum ? The only way is if she connected to my grandad. Some say these mediums go about looking through peoples rubbish bins looking for clues or tricking people into telling them more for the medium to turn it around and say this this and this. But I repeat that nothing was ever written down, the information could of only been passed to my mum to validate that the medium was connected to my grandad.

My mum tried to get a second booking with this medium, but she is so busy, she was booked up for a whole year before she was taking any further bookings. :erm:


there are some smart cookies around
that draw information from all sorts of ways

Chris 15-11-2003 23:21

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Drudge
It can be shown that religious beliefs are positively irrational, that several parts of the theological doctrine are inconsistent with one another.
Christians claim the following

It's late, I'm tired, I don't know why I'm bothering to answer this but here goes anyway ... guess I'm too stupid not to. Seeing as Drudge has made the explicit claim 'Christians claim the following', I am going to try to give a Christian answer. I make no apologies for the assumptions I am about to make about the nature of the universe. Just bear with me.

1) God is omnipotent (i.e., all-powerful).
correct.

2) God is omniscient (i.e., all-knowing).
yep.

3) God is perfectly good.
Still on track here.

4) Evil exists.
clearly, it does. So still full marks.

5) Any two or three of them might be true at the same time; but there was no way that all of them could be true.
And you were doing so well. Let's see how you back up this bold statement of opinion.

6) If God is omnipotent, he would be able to prevent all of the evil and suffering in the world.
He is capable of doing this and has made adequate arrangements. See below.

7) If God is omniscient, he would know about all of the evil and suffering in the world and would know how to eliminate or prevent it.
He is fully aware, and has already done everything necessary to put a stop to it.

8) If God is perfectly good, he would want to prevent all of the evil and suffering in the world.
He is, and he does. In fact, he has already taken steps to address this.

Statements (6) to (8) jointly imply that if the perfect God existed, there would not be any evil or suffering. However, as we all know, our world is filled with a staggering amount of evil and suffering. If we think about (6) to (8) in light of the fact of evil and suffering in our world, we should be led to the following conclusions:
Now, I just know your conclusions are going to be skewed, because the statement above makes absolutely no attempt to give God a chance to explain himself and his actions. You can't sum up the prosecution before the defence has had a chance to answer the charges. If you are as well-read as you say you are, you could very easily have dropped in the answers a number of religions give to the points you have raised, before telling us all why you disagree with them. The fact that you have not done this is very telling. In fact, all you have done is state some observations about the world, and then claimed (very boldly indeed) that God must address them in the way you see fit if you are to accept his claims to omniscience, omnipotence, etc.

9) If God knows about all of the evil and suffering in the world, knows how to eliminate or prevent it, is powerful enough to prevent it, and yet does not prevent it, he must not be perfectly good.
True, although as I said above you have not mentioned any of the possible 'answers' to this provided by religions. Let me give you the answer from my religion, Christianity, seeing as that is the religion you set out to address. God knows about evil, answered it by offering eternal life through his son Jesus, and gives it to anyone who asks. Evil persists in the world because people refuse to take the remedy, not because God is powerless to offer one.

10) If God knows about all of the evil and suffering, knows how to eliminate or prevent it, wants to prevent it, and yet does not do so, he must not be all- powerful.
Having absolute power is one thing. Using it with absolute wisdom is something else. The USA is getting a hammering in another thread on this forum for 'imposing' its view of things on another sovreign nation, regardless of the fact that a great deal of evil is being done in that nation (Iraq). 'The ends don't justify the means' is a common theme. So would you be happy if God just forced his way of doing things on you? I thought not.

11) If God is powerful enough to prevent all of the evil and suffering, wants to do so, and yet does not, he must not know about all of the suffering or know how to eliminate or prevent itâ₠¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â€šÂ¬Ã‚that is, he must not be all-knowing.
You are dancing yourself round in philosophical circles, but as I've been illustrating above, your previous statements are based on some very false assumptions indeed. If your previous statements are untrue, then this conclusion is completely wide of the mark. As is what follows:

From (9) to (11) we can state:
12) If evil and suffering exist, then God is either not omnipotent, not omniscient, or not perfectly good.

Since evil and suffering obviously do exist, we get:
13) God is either not omnipotent, not omniscient, or not perfectly good.

Putting the point more bluntly, this line of argument suggests thatââ‚ ¬Ã¢â‚¬Âin light of the evil and suffering we find in our worldââ‚ÆšÂ¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â€šÂ¬Ã‚if God exists, he is either impotent, ignorant or wicked.

It is obvious that (13) conflicts with (1) to (3) above.

To make the conflict more clear, we can combine (1), (2) and (3) into the following single statement.

14) God is omnipotent, omniscient and perfectly good.

Statement (14) is simply the conjunction of (1) to (3) and expresses the central belief of christian.

There is no way that (13) and (14) could both be true at the same time. These statements are contradictory.

Philosophers have always believed it is never rational to believe something contradictory. So, the existence of evil and suffering makes christians' belief in the existence of a perfect God IRRATIONAL.


It's very clever, the way you spin a complex web of interdependent statements, which build into a set of contradictions which are then easy for you to 'prove' irrational. It's just a pity you didn't spend the time actually reading what the Bible says about these issues instead. Your statement (13) is false, and is based on a set of unsubstantiated assumptions on your part, due either to ignorance of or unwillingness to acknowledge what the Bible says on the subject. Like it or not, the Bible is the authoritative source here, as you claim to be discussing the Christian worldview.

So, as (13) is not true, there is no contradiction with (14), which is true, and I can sleep sound at night knowing that I have a Lord in heaven who I will meet one day. :)

Mick 15-11-2003 23:28

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peachey
there are some smart cookies around
that draw information from all sorts of ways

Sorry, I just fail to see that. How can anyone suggest right away, what really happened that was personal between two people, remember nothing was written down and my mum only gave yes or no answers, I fail to see how anyone, let alone a medium - can suggest, 1st time that this this and this happened and it really did. :shrug:

Bex 15-11-2003 23:28

Re: What happens when you die?
 
towny you are soooooo wise.....must remember to ask you if i have any questions in future :p

peachey 15-11-2003 23:32

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Plummer
Sorry, I just fail to see that. How can anyone suggest right away, what really happened that was personal between two people, remember nothing was written down and my mum only gave yes or no answers, I fail to see how anyone, let alone a medium - can suggest, 1st time that this this and this happened and it really did. :shrug:

yeah I know

but a medium once related issues to me relating to problems with the birth of our second child that were not knowable to other parties

dilli-theclaw 15-11-2003 23:34

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
It's late, I'm tired, I don't know why I'm bothering to answer this but here goes anyway ... guess I'm too stupid not to. Seeing as Drudge has made the explicit claim 'Christians claim the following', I am going to try to give a Christian answer. I make no apologies for the assumptions I am about to make about the nature of the universe. Just bear with me.

1) God is omnipotent (i.e., all-powerful).
correct.

2) God is omniscient (i.e., all-knowing).
yep.

3) God is perfectly good.
Still on track here.

4) Evil exists.
clearly, it does. So still full marks.

5) Any two or three of them might be true at the same time; but there was no way that all of them could be true.
And you were doing so well. Let's see how you back up this bold statement of opinion.

6) If God is omnipotent, he would be able to prevent all of the evil and suffering in the world.
He is capable of doing this and has made adequate arrangements. See below.

7) If God is omniscient, he would know about all of the evil and suffering in the world and would know how to eliminate or prevent it.
He is fully aware, and has already done everything necessary to put a stop to it.

8) If God is perfectly good, he would want to prevent all of the evil and suffering in the world.
He is, and he does. In fact, he has already taken steps to address this.

Statements (6) to (8) jointly imply that if the perfect God existed, there would not be any evil or suffering. However, as we all know, our world is filled with a staggering amount of evil and suffering. If we think about (6) to (8) in light of the fact of evil and suffering in our world, we should be led to the following conclusions:
Now, I just know your conclusions are going to be skewed, because the statement above makes absolutely no attempt to give God a chance to explain himself and his actions. You can't sum up the prosecution before the defence has had a chance to answer the charges. If you are as well-read as you say you are, you could very easily have dropped in the answers a number of religions give to the points you have raised, before telling us all why you disagree with them. The fact that you have not done this is very telling. In fact, all you have done is state some observations about the world, and then claimed (very boldly indeed) that God must address them in the way you see fit if you are to accept his claims to omniscience, omnipotence, etc.

9) If God knows about all of the evil and suffering in the world, knows how to eliminate or prevent it, is powerful enough to prevent it, and yet does not prevent it, he must not be perfectly good.
True, although as I said above you have not mentioned any of the possible 'answers' to this provided by religions. Let me give you the answer from my religion, Christianity, seeing as that is the religion you set out to address. God knows about evil, answered it by offering eternal life through his son Jesus, and gives it to anyone who asks. Evil persists in the world because people refuse to take the remedy, not because God is powerless to offer one.

10) If God knows about all of the evil and suffering, knows how to eliminate or prevent it, wants to prevent it, and yet does not do so, he must not be all- powerful.
Having absolute power is one thing. Using it with absolute wisdom is something else. The USA is getting a hammering in another thread on this forum for 'imposing' its view of things on another sovreign nation, regardless of the fact that a great deal of evil is being done in that nation (Iraq). 'The ends don't justify the means' is a common theme. So would you be happy if God just forced his way of doing things on you? I thought not.

11) If God is powerful enough to prevent all of the evil and suffering, wants to do so, and yet does not, he must not know about all of the suffering or know how to eliminate or prevent itâ₠¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â€šÂ¬Ã‚that is, he must not be all-knowing.
You are dancing yourself round in philosophical circles, but as I've been illustrating above, your previous statements are based on some very false assumptions indeed. If your previous statements are untrue, then this conclusion is completely wide of the mark. As is what follows:

From (9) to (11) we can state:
12) If evil and suffering exist, then God is either not omnipotent, not omniscient, or not perfectly good.

Since evil and suffering obviously do exist, we get:
13) God is either not omnipotent, not omniscient, or not perfectly good.

Putting the point more bluntly, this line of argument suggests thatââ‚ ¬Ã¢â‚¬Âin light of the evil and suffering we find in our worldââ‚ÆšÂ¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â€šÂ¬Ã‚if God exists, he is either impotent, ignorant or wicked.

It is obvious that (13) conflicts with (1) to (3) above.

To make the conflict more clear, we can combine (1), (2) and (3) into the following single statement.

14) God is omnipotent, omniscient and perfectly good.

Statement (14) is simply the conjunction of (1) to (3) and expresses the central belief of christian.

There is no way that (13) and (14) could both be true at the same time. These statements are contradictory.

Philosophers have always believed it is never rational to believe something contradictory. So, the existence of evil and suffering makes christians' belief in the existence of a perfect God IRRATIONAL.


It's very clever, the way you spin a complex web of interdependent statements, which build into a set of contradictions which are then easy for you to 'prove' irrational. It's just a pity you didn't spend the time actually reading what the Bible says about these issues instead. Your statement (13) is false, and is based on a set of unsubstantiated assumptions on your part, due either to ignorance of or unwillingness to acknowledge what the Bible says on the subject. Like it or not, the Bible is the authoritative source here, as you claim to be discussing the Christian worldview.

So, as (13) is not true, there is no contradiction with (14), which is true, and I can sleep sound at night knowing that I have a Lord in heaven who I will meet one day. :)


And the reason 'god' let my mother die begging for my dad to kill her because of the amount of pain she was in - can you tell me that?

I'd love to know what kind of loving god would allow this.

Chris 15-11-2003 23:37

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
And the reason 'god' let my mother die begging for my dad to kill her because of the amount of pain she was in - can you tell me that?

I'd love to know what kind of loving god would allow this.

Any answer short enough to post in a forum would sound deeply patronising to you dilligaf. These are painful, personal issues ... I have had some pretty rough times in my own life too. :( If you do want to talk it over, I'm happy to swap PMs with you.

dilli-theclaw 15-11-2003 23:42

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
Any answer short enough to post in a forum would sound deeply patronising to you dilligaf. These are painful, personal issues ... I have had some pretty rough times in my own life too. :( If you do want to talk it over, I'm happy to swap PMs with you.

I don't know if there's any point in discussing it to be honest.

I'm not having a personal go at you - it's just the way I feel.

My sister lost her son at 4 - My missus has had 3 miscarriages and lost a child at birth.....

So I guess I'm just pretty f**ked up about it all.

As it happens - I used to be a believer untill all this happneded.

But right now - I can't see myself ever becoming one again. :(

Mick 15-11-2003 23:43

Re: What happens when you die?
 
I salute the thread starter of this topic. Well done. It is a topic often avoided but a good one nonetheless. It can bring back bad and painful memories to those who have lost a loved one. But it can also let people have a say on such matters or talk about personal issues that have effected their belief in life after death.

peachey 15-11-2003 23:45

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Plummer
I salute the thread starter of this topic. Well done. It is a topic often avoided but a good one nonetheless. It can bring back bad and painful memories to those who have lost a loved one. But it can also let people have a say on such matters or talk about personal issues that have effected their belief in life after death.


yes ..well done that poster

Bex 15-11-2003 23:47

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
I don't know if there's any point in discussing it to be honest.

I'm not having a personal go at you - it's just the way I feel.

My sister lost her son at 4 - My missus has had 3 miscarriages and lost a child at birth.....

So I guess I'm just pretty f**ked up about it all.

As it happens - I used to be a believer untill all this happneded.

But right now - I can't see myself ever becoming one again. :(

i'm really sorry that you have been through all this, terrible stuff....believe it or not ive been through a lot in my life, and yes it stopped me believing...life is tough *sigh*

tbh atm, i have a lot of fmaily members terminally ill, so i can relate:(

dilli-theclaw 15-11-2003 23:52

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
i'm really sorry that you have been through all this, terrible stuff....believe it or not ive been through a lot in my life, and yes it stopped me believing...life is tough *sigh*

tbh atm, i have a lot of fmaily members terminally ill, so i can relate:(


Thanks for the thought it's nice :)

.....and now I've managed to get myself all upset again. I REALLY shouldn't read this type of stuff - it happens every time.

I think I'm going to back out of this thread now.

homealone 15-11-2003 23:52

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
I don't know if there's any point in discussing it to be honest.

I'm not having a personal go at you - it's just the way I feel.

My sister lost her son at 4 - My missus has had 3 miscarriages and lost a child at birth.....

So I guess I'm just pretty f**ked up about it all.

As it happens - I used to be a believer untill all this happneded.

But right now - I can't see myself ever becoming one again. :(

believer or not, I hope it helps to discuss it.

There are people on here who can help - this is the strength of this site - respect to Towny for offering support.

Mick 15-11-2003 23:53

Re: What happens when you die?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
i'm really sorry that you have been through all this, terrible stuff....believe it or not ive been through a lot in my life, and yes it stopped me believing...life is tough *sigh*

tbh atm, i have a lot of fmaily members terminally ill, so i can relate:(

At times like this we need to have a *Group hug*.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:41.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum