Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Security & Virus Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   For Smug Mac Users.... (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=41443)

Chris W 17-01-2006 00:03

For Smug Mac Users....
 
And yes i am one :p:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4609968.stm

Graham M 17-01-2006 00:34

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
His article is Spot on IMO.

ScaredWebWarrior 17-01-2006 08:27

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris W

What he's saying is quite true. Mac users are way too smug about the security of their machines. They'll soon point out that it's Unix and that's why it is so secure.

I'm currently reading "The Cuckoo's Egg" and that is a litany of Unix security flaws and bad system management, showing that Unix can certainly be vulnerable to attack.

And yes, I also own a Mac. (And a PC)

Chris 17-01-2006 09:53

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Mac users aren't just smug about security. They're smug about every aspect of their machines.

But why not, they're better. :)

ScaredWebWarrior 17-01-2006 09:57

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Mac users aren't just smug about security. They're smug about every aspect of their machines.

But why not, they're better. :)

Fair enough - just don't be complacent about it.

The Mac is not invulnerable, and you'll rue the day you assumed it was.

Bifta 17-01-2006 09:57

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Mac users aren't just smug about security. They're smug about every aspect of their machines.

But why not, they're better. :)

But they're not better, the ONLY aspect of a Mac that's better than a PC is it's looks, it's performance is dire in comparison and the hardware is pretty much (other than the CPU, which is normally far less powerful than it's x86 alernative) the same as a PC's.

Chris 17-01-2006 10:26

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ScaredWebWarrior
Fair enough - just don't be complacent about it.

The Mac is not invulnerable, and you'll rue the day you assumed it was.

On the contrary, I run McAfee Virex on it, (even though the virus definitions it uses are almost entirely for PCs, just so I don't accidentally pass on a file that might infect you, even though my own machine is immune) so if any viruses do appear I'll get the definition files and stay clean.

I also ran a software firewall until I bought my router, which is configured to allow nothing through. Complacent I aint. :)

---------- Post added at 10:26 ---------- Previous post was at 10:21 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
But they're not better, the ONLY aspect of a Mac that's better than a PC is it's looks, it's performance is dire in comparison and the hardware is pretty much (other than the CPU, which is normally far less powerful than it's x86 alernative) the same as a PC's.

I have a six-year-old iMac, which runs faster today that it did new. It has 640MB of RAM (shipped with 64MB) and has had two major OS revisions installed since the day it was first switched on with OS 9.0.8 onboard. I'm now on 10.2.8 and am told that 10.3 and 10.4 both brought further efficiencies.

Which versions of Winblows can you point to that were leaner and faster than their predecessors? I thought I was led to believe that each revision of that OS demanded ever more powerful machines to run on? What are the expected specs for Vista?

I find Mac OS to be simpler, more intuitive, more elegant and just generally better designed than Windows. And seeing as the OS governs my day-to-day experience of my computer, I regard that as a pretty major plus point.

Man, I can see which way this thread is going ... :p:

Bifta 17-01-2006 10:52

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
On the contrary, I run McAfee Virex on it, (even though the virus definitions it uses are almost entirely for PCs, just so I don't accidentally pass on a file that might infect you, even though my own machine is immune) so if any viruses do appear I'll get the definition files and stay clean.

I also ran a software firewall until I bought my router, which is configured to allow nothing through. Complacent I aint. :)

---------- Post added at 10:26 ---------- Previous post was at 10:21 ----------



I have a six-year-old iMac, which runs faster today that it did new. It has 640MB of RAM (shipped with 64MB) and has had two major OS revisions installed since the day it was first switched on with OS 9.0.8 onboard. I'm now on 10.2.8 and am told that 10.3 and 10.4 both brought further efficiencies.

Which versions of Winblows can you point to that were leaner and faster than their predecessors? I thought I was led to believe that each revision of that OS demanded ever more powerful machines to run on? What are the expected specs for Vista?

I run Windows XP on a rather old laptop (450mhz as I recall and less ram than you have) and it runs better under XP than it ever did under Windows 95 or 98 so I'm failing to see your point.

If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them? (And don't start on about Microsofts monopoly because you can walk into PC world and pick up a Mac if you like)

bmxbandit 17-01-2006 11:01

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them?

because they're overly expensive.

ScaredWebWarrior 17-01-2006 11:10

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them?

The reasons Macs are so much better (also in my opinion) is almost directly why they're not selling as much as PCs - Seems that software writers prefer using software tools with dumb application wizards to produce bad code for Windows, rather than make the effort to write decent portable software that could be made available on either platform.

Yes, I'm admitting to the fact that the lack of availability of software (specifically, very few PC apps also being supported on Mac) as being a major factor.

Having said that, the way so many people use their PCs, they wouldn't notice this on a Mac - with the exception of games and some specific applications, a MAC offers everything a PC does.

And since I generally give games a wide berth, I find either a Mac or PC can fulfill my needs almost entirely. If either offers something the other hasn't got, then it's either my deep pockets/short arms or laziness (i.e. haven't bothered to look) that's stopped me having everything I need on one platform.

It is also true that a Mac can cost quite a bit more than a decent PC - but most people overlook that the annual hardware upgrade for the PC is not necessary for the Mac - and hence they should see the Mac as a longer term purchase vs the PC as a shorter term purchase. But that's quite a hard sell on the general buying public.

The Mac hardware is genarlly also more reliable, but I have found that my home built PCs are equally as reliable - it seems that the PC bundles are less so, however - and since it's these that most people buy, the reliability issue should also factor in.

As for usability - not much in it, until you consider the opportunities for a PC owner to be overwhelmed by the possibilities to mess up their machine by tweaking 'properties'.

But while kids get all their ICT input at school on a PC, the Mac will always remain a bit of an outsider. (Having said that - watching a 12 yo log into a Linux box with as much confidence as her PC and using it without any instructions, tells me that perhaps this will be less of an issue in 10 years or so.)

Chris 17-01-2006 11:23

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
I run Windows XP on a rather old laptop (450mhz as I recall and less ram than you have) and it runs better under XP than it ever did under Windows 95 or 98 so I'm failing to see your point.

If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them? (And don't start on about Microsofts monopoly because you can walk into PC world and pick up a Mac if you like)

First, please reassure me that you have not, in any way, used your better-than-joe-average knowledge of Windows to streamline your XP install, kill processes you don't need or otherwise change its out-of-the-box configuration. In other words, it's operating in the same way as the overwhelming majority of users experience it.

Second - with the greatest of respect to you, that's a pretty dumb question. You know as well as I do that 'better' is seldom the deciding factor in any format war. I could go on at length about canny marketing early on by IBM (licencing the x86), canny dealing by Bill Gates and similarly bad business at Apple. Somehow I think you already know all this though. :)

Bifta 17-01-2006 11:51

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
First, please reassure me that you have not, in any way, used your better-than-joe-average knowledge of Windows to streamline your XP install, kill processes you don't need or otherwise change its out-of-the-box configuration. In other words, it's operating in the same way as the overwhelming majority of users experience it.

It's not streamlined in any way, straight XP Pro SP2 install direct from CD running on a Dell Inspiron 3700 with 512mb memory (the only upgrade it's ever had), a couple of drivers loaded and that's it, the ONLY thing I've found that hogs it is the .NET framework and I've so far managed to avoid having that installed on my desktop too.



Quote:

Second - with the greatest of respect to you, that's a pretty dumb question. You know as well as I do that 'better' is seldom the deciding factor in any format war. I could go on at length about canny marketing early on by IBM (licencing the x86), canny dealing by Bill Gates and similarly bad business at Apple. Somehow I think you already know all this though. :)
And of course .. the cost and lack of modularity; as far as I'm concerned building everything into the monitor is nothing more than an inconvenient and expensive gimmick for anyone who might want to upgrade their machine in the future.

SMHarman 17-01-2006 11:51

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
I have a six-year-old iMac, which runs faster today that it did new. It has 640MB of RAM (shipped with 64MB) and has had two major OS revisions installed since the day it was first switched on with OS 9.0.8 onboard. I'm now on 10.2.8 and am told that 10.3 and 10.4 both brought further efficiencies.

Maybe not so much for XP, but the step change from W98 to W2K was similar. The step change in reliability of my antique Celeron3 runing W2k on 96Mb not W98 was by the sounds of things similar to your experience of the change from X9>10.

Chris 17-01-2006 11:58

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
It's not streamlined in any way, straight XP Pro SP2 install direct from CD running on a Dell Inspiron 3700 with 512mb memory (the only upgrade it's ever had), a couple of drivers loaded and that's it, the ONLY thing I've found that hogs it is the .NET framework and I've so far managed to avoid having that installed on my desktop too.

OK, fair enough. What about Vista though? Am I hearing wrong or are people complaining about the sort of hardware that will be needed to run it?

Quote:

And of course .. the cost and lack of modularity; as far as I'm concerned building everything into the monitor is nothing more than an inconvenient and expensive gimmick for anyone who might want to upgrade their machine in the future.
Its funny, but you seldom hear people complaining about the lack of modularity of TVs, Hi Fis and Microwave ovens. PCs are no longer the plaything of those with special knowledge. They are consumer electronics and the vast majority of people see them as such. I suggest you are in a minority - probably a small minority - of people who even want to think about tinkering with the insides of their PC. Some PC manufcturers have recognised this and while they may not actually pack the electronics into the same box as the monitor, they screw the box shut in a way that's designed to discourage you from getting into it.

Bifta 17-01-2006 12:35

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
OK, fair enough. What about Vista though? Am I hearing wrong or are people complaining about the sort of hardware that will be needed to run it?

From what I gather Vista is scaleable so you can either choose to have all the fancy bells and whistles if you have a PC powerful enough to support them or not .. if you haven't.

Quote:

Its funny, but you seldom hear people complaining about the lack of modularity of TVs, Hi Fis and Microwave ovens. PCs are no longer the plaything of those with special knowledge. They are consumer electronics and the vast majority of people see them as such. I suggest you are in a minority - probably a small minority - of people who even want to think about tinkering with the insides of their PC. Some PC manufcturers have recognised this and while they may not actually pack the electronics into the same box as the monitor, they screw the box shut in a way that's designed to discourage you from getting into it.
Obviously you've never tried to get into the back of a recent Dell machine, it's a plastic clip you push down, no screws, nothing.

As for considering a PC in the same vein as a TV or Microwave .. rubbish, sorry, even the most technophobic person is capable of plugging a new monitor into the back of PC, if they decide they want to upgrade the internals they can simply take it to a computer shop, I hardly think they're going to head down to the microwave shop and get a new & improved magnatron fitted.

Damien 17-01-2006 12:45

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
But they're not better, the ONLY aspect of a Mac that's better than a PC is it's looks, it's performance is dire in comparison and the hardware is pretty much (other than the CPU, which is normally far less powerful than it's x86 alernative) the same as a PC's.

:o:

Heard it all before. Point is, I love my mac so :p: to you

I have the inbuilt firewall on to top level and am still hoping the a decent anti-virus. Virex is only for .mac isnt it?

Many people in the mac world know about the llikelyhood of an attack, although macs are more secure it doesnt not make them invicible

---------- Post added at 12:45 ---------- Previous post was at 12:41 ----------

Quote:

As for considering a PC in the same vein as a TV or Microwave .. rubbish, sorry, even the most technophobic person is capable of plugging a new monitor into the back of PC, if they decide they want to upgrade the internals they can simply take it to a computer shop, I hardly think they're going to head down to the microwave shop and get a new & improved magnatron fitted.
We get the point you do not like macs. But they are a good system. I am happy with mine since i switched and its not a worse system

Chris 17-01-2006 12:46

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
As for considering a PC in the same vein as a TV or Microwave .. rubbish, sorry, even the most technophobic person is capable of plugging a new monitor into the back of PC, if they decide they want to upgrade the internals they can simply take it to a computer shop, I hardly think they're going to head down to the microwave shop and get a new & improved magnatron fitted.

Yes, they can. My point is not whether they can, it's whether they do. Further, because they don't upgrade their microwaves or their tellys, they will not upgrade their PCs. You're just looking at it based on your own knowledge and experience and not that of someone who has bought a PC just because everyone's got one and you have to have one these days.

Honest, I overheard the bloke next door (where I used to live, in Hemel) raving about the PC he was planning to buy. He was reading out the specs from the advert to an equally clueless but admiring visitor. He positivley cooed over the '56k modem'. He plainly didn't have a scooby doo what it, or anything else, was for, and whether any of it was any good (it wasn't much good). To be fair, actually, his visitor later pointed out that dial-up internet was not the big thing any more, but on being asked what was, he said 'you want broadband, minimum' - suggesting he didn't have much more of a clue.

The times they are a-changing. The iMac is a product that more closely matches what Joe Average actually does with his home computer. That is, buys it, plugs it in, switches it on, expects it to do what it says on the box, and when it gets old, buys another.

Bifta 17-01-2006 12:52

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Yes, they can. My point is not whether they can, it's whether they do. Further, because they don't upgrade their microwaves or their tellys, they will not upgrade their PCs. You're just looking at it based on your own knowledge and experience and not that of someone who has bought a PC just because everyone's got one and you have to have one these days.

Honest, I overheard the bloke next door (where I used to live, in Hemel) raving about the PC he was planning to buy. He was reading out the specs from the advert to an equally clueless but admiring visitor. He positivley cooed over the '56k modem'. He plainly didn't have a scooby doo what it, or anything else, was for, and whether any of it was any good (it wasn't much good). To be fair, actually, his visitor later pointed out that dial-up internet was not the big thing any more, but on being asked what was, he said 'you want broadband, minimum' - suggesting he didn't have much more of a clue.

The times they are a-changing. The iMac is a product that more closely matches what Joe Average actually does with his home computer. That is, buys it, plugs it in, switches it on, expects it to do what it says on the box, and when it gets old, buys another.

Sorry, I think you're wrong. I get at least 4 or 5 calls a month from people asking me how much it'll cost to upgrade their machines, calls people who know absolutely nothing about computers, not one of them ask "how much is a new PC"; no-one in their right mind is going to fall (hopefully) for more Apple bullsh*t marketing (remember that G5 advert the ASA forced them to pull?) and spend a wadge of cash in the knowledge that they'll have to throw it out and buy a new one if they need to upgrade.like his mac, please discuss"

Damien 17-01-2006 12:55

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Chris how did you get Viruex? Is it an oold version or did you get licences or what?

Norton is crap on the mac

---------- Post added at 12:55 ---------- Previous post was at 12:53 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Sorry, I think you're wrong. I get at least 4 or 5 calls a month from people asking me how much it'll cost to upgrade their machines, calls people who know absolutely nothing about computers, not one of them ask "how much is a new PC"; no-one in their right mind is going to fall (hopefully) for more Apple bullsh*t marketing (remember that G5 advert the ASA forced them to pull?) and spend a wadge of cash in the knowledge that they'll have to throw it out and buy a new one if they need to upgrade.like his mac, please discuss"

You are clueless about macs. Some of us here are actually using the OS and love it. Are you telling us we are wrong and you are right?

ScaredWebWarrior 17-01-2006 12:56

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Norton is crap on the mac

The last 3 of those words are not required.

Bifta 17-01-2006 12:57

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Chris how did you get Viruex? Is it an oold version or did you get licences or what?

Norton is crap on the mac

---------- Post added at 12:55 ---------- Previous post was at 12:53 ----------



You are clueless about macs. Some of us here are actually using the OS and love it. Are you telling us we are wrong and you are right?

Sorry, but in case you hadn't noticed "mac" isn't an OS, and nowhere in my post did I mention anything other than hardware, wise up.

Damien 17-01-2006 13:03

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Sorry, but in case you hadn't noticed "mac" isn't an OS, and nowhere in my post did I mention anything other than hardware, wise up.

Well 'mac' is a broad term. You could be talking about the OS or the computer it runs on. I see mac, as many people do, as the OS.

The hardware cost is to off-set the massive amount of research and development the OS costs. My powerbook is very well built (expect some trouble with the HD a while back but that stopped), good screen, firewire and so on.

LostintheNW 17-01-2006 13:12

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
I have both a PC and one of those iMac which are taking a good old slagging off in this post. I love my iMac way more than my pc! the fact the machine runs faster, doesn't crash, or when an application does decide to fail it does not take the whole frigging OS with it, like Windows does!

I used to be afraid to go anywhere near a mac as I had no idea about them, but I find the machine much easier to use, installing programs is a doddle on the machine compared to windows, and as for removing them you just throw the program in the trash...none of this crap uninstaller programs like windows that leaves all kinds of rubbish behind to trip up XP at any point! As for XP making machines run faster? since when has this been going on? Run XP on some 400mhz celeron and you tell me you can live with that slowness of that, at least you can install Jaguar/Panther and even Tiger on older g3 and g4 processors and this gives the machine a considerable speed boost.

It is true that macs are expensive, but at the same point you never need upgrade the mac as it can quite happily cope with whatever is thrown at it (so in the long run you actually save money). People assume PC's are the only thing to go for as they are so dominant in the market place, but those times will change.

Oh and give a technophobe an iMac and a pc all boxed up new and see which one they get up and running first - guarantee you it will be the mac!

Chris 17-01-2006 13:26

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Chris how did you get Viruex? Is it an oold version or did you get licences or what?

McAfee Virex is part of the subscription to .Mac ('DotMac' for those who don't know). I've been a .Mac subscriber for years and I get good use out of it.

Damien 17-01-2006 13:28

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
McAfee Virex is part of the subscription to .Mac ('DotMac' for those who don't know). I've been a .Mac subscriber for years and I get good use out of it.

You do that it is no longer offered by .mac and your updates will stop in may right?

SMHarman 17-01-2006 14:06

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Its funny, but you seldom hear people complaining about the lack of modularity of TVs, Hi Fis and Microwave ovens.

True, but wouldn't it be nice to add in a DTV card to your TV or for DTV cards / hardware to be modular so you could slot a sky+ / NTL / Freeview card into your TV, far more elegant than another box under the telly.
Modularity of microwaves, well the magnatron is about equivilant to a CPU and if you are considering replacing that it is normally time for a system change.
I'd have to agree that even with the systems I have bought the upgrades have been very limited and a long way down the product life cycle. I added and ISDN card and I have added a 120Gb hdd to a 6 yr old machine. Looking at the machine upgrading vs replacement mean replacement is the option.

Chris 17-01-2006 14:08

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
You do that it is no longer offered by .mac and your updates will stop in may right?

Wrong. Barstewards. :afire:

Ah well, back to passing on infected files to my windoze friends. :rolleyes:

Damien 17-01-2006 14:19

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Yup, Started being pulled a while back due to some problems it has having and it will stop updating for current users in may. Its somewhere on the apple site.

Virux v7.7 is still around but McAfee will only offer 5 licences. So you pay $200 hardly worth it.

Chris 17-01-2006 14:38

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Yup, Started being pulled a while back due to some problems it has having and it will stop updating for current users in may. Its somewhere on the apple site.

Virux v7.7 is still around but McAfee will only offer 5 licences. So you pay $200 hardly worth it.

From my hurried read-up on it (and these are deductions, not facts stated by Apple, who are being very coy), the version of Virex I use was always going to be dicontinued in May. This presumably was a ploy to get laggards like me to upgrade to OSX 10.4. However, there have been some serious compatibility issues with Virex 7.7 and 10.4 - so serious, they have pulled it, "for the time being". I think they will reintroduce it, but when they do it will still only be Virex 7.7 for OSX 10.4 users.

Meantime, some users at Apple's own forums are recommending this:

http://www.clamxav.com/

Hey, we're back on topic!! :D

Damien 17-01-2006 16:47

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Excellent! Thanks for that

I never seen the benfit of .mac. I like the email address and idisk but the online iinterface for mail is poor and there is not a lot of space 1gb!!! Thats poor considering it includes iDisk

If they continue with the improvments they making to .mac and introduce virex again then yay!

Macsecure is a good site and include mac scan which is a spyware/malware scanner

Chris 17-01-2006 16:54

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Excellent! Thanks for that

I never seen the benfit of .mac. I like the email address and idisk but the online iinterface for mail is poor and there is not a lot of space 1gb!!! Thats poor considering it includes iDisk

If they continue with the improvments they making to .mac and introduce virex again then yay!

Macsecure is a good site and include mac scan which is a spyware/malware scanner

I like it for the email addy - I have two. The email service is extremely reliable. The iDisk is not massive but it is way more than I need for publishing my homepage, the tools for which are also part of the service. I also use the idisk for uploading files I can link to on here, and sometimes for transferring large files between work and home. It integrates very nicely with the OS as well.

There are also nice freebies from time to time. I have plenty of games free from .Mac, including Sims 2.

Damien 17-01-2006 17:10

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
sims 2 free! Civ 3 complete will come though post soon, wish that was 3. iWeb is good for making sites albeit a bit toooo simple.

I did like virux thoug :(

Gareth 17-01-2006 17:29

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
You are clueless about macs. Some of us here are actually using the OS and love it. Are you telling us we are wrong and you are right?

tsk tsk tsk, no need to resort to personal insults. It's a sign of weakness in discussions, imo. Don't they teach anything at university these days?!? :p:

Considering Bifta's numerous informative posts, I'd disagree with you, Damien, and would suggest that he does have a clue. The fact that he chooses to not use a product does not mean that he is ill-informed about the said product. In fact, the reason he doesn't use a product could be because he is informed about it.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
The hardware cost is to off-set the massive amount of research and development the OS costs.

If that is the case, why is OS X so expensive? Froogle just returned this ' Mac OS X Tiger Family Pack... £79 - £142'. That's as expensive as Windows XP Professional, which isn't subsidised by hardware sales. :shrug:
Quote:

Originally Posted by LostintheNW
I have both a PC and one of those iMac which are taking a good old slagging off in this post. I love my iMac way more than my pc! the fact the machine runs faster, doesn't crash, or when an application does decide to fail it does not take the whole frigging OS with it, like Windows does!

Surely this should read 'I have a PC running Windows and one of those iMac...<snip>'..? I have a PC running Linux ;) and it runs faster than Windows, doesn't crash unlike Windows, and when an application does decide to fail it does not take the whole frigging OS with it... unlike Windows ;) ...or am I just being pedantic? :angel:

Damien 17-01-2006 18:08

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

If that is the case, why is OS X so expensive? Froogle just returned this ' Mac OS X Tiger Family Pack... £79 - £142'. That's as expensive as Windows XP Professional, which isn't subsidised by hardware sales

one licence

Mac OSX: £75 Windows XP home: £85 Windows XP Pro: £194

http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/...514787-6349542
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/...514787-6349542
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/...514787-6349542

The version you looked at was for multiple computers, Apple give a discount for that. Those are all fair like-for-like products. All upgrades.

Quote:

Considering Bifta's numerous informative posts, I'd disagree with you, Damien, and would suggest that he does have a clue. The fact that he chooses to not use a product does not mean that he is ill-informed about the said product. In fact, the reason he doesn't use a product could be because he is informed about it.
Sorry no, Where you refer to people being 'falling for more Apple bullsh*t marketing' then thats not a informed opinion. Also macs do not need as much upgrading as a PC box. You can keep them for years, and you can upgrade the Ram, the HD and you can get mac graphic cards*

*only on the Power Mac.

Also i was not calling what he used crap i was defending the system I use from that label.

And from a perfectly techinical point of view. Mac can and usually does refer to the OS

Stuart 17-01-2006 18:33

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta

If Macs are so much better (in your opinion) with a far better operating system (in your opinion) then why aren't people buying them? (And don't start on about Microsofts monopoly because you can walk into PC world and pick up a Mac if you like)


Inertia. Also a case of "Better the devil you know".

Most people know PCs (whether from work, school or whatever), so they may see the Mac as untried, and therefore frightening.

Also, bear in mind that better sales does not necessarily equal a better product. Anyone who knew anything about video production at the beginning of the 80s knew that Betamax was far superior to VHS, but which standard sold best, and is still on sale today? VHS. Similarly, "The Sun" outsells "The Telegraph" by almost ten to one. I don't see anyone seriously arguing that "The Sun" is a better newspaper.

I still have the same opinion that I have expressed in the past. Macs are better for some things (anything to do with the various Media industries for example), and PCs are better for others (Games, general business etc).

One thing I am happy to see though is a warning that Macs are not as secure as Mac users think. They are intrinsically more secure than PCs, but that does not mean they are very secure.

Must show this article to one of our technicians at work. He runs a load of macs, 5 of which are networked. The other 8 are not networked, so to use them, the hacker would need to break into the patch room, patch the connections, then hack into the DHCP server and enter the MAC address. If they are able to do that then them getting into our Macs is the least of our problems.

---------- Post added at 18:33 ---------- Previous post was at 18:23 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gareth
Considering Bifta's numerous informative posts, I'd disagree with you, Damien, and would suggest that he does have a clue. The fact that he chooses to not use a product does not mean that he is ill-informed about the said product. In fact, the reason he doesn't use a product could be because he is informed about it.

No one is querying Bifta's knowledge of PCs. I don't know how much he has used Macs, but the way he posts about them suggests he hasn't actually used them an awful lot.
Quote:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
The hardware cost is to off-set the massive amount of research and development the OS costs.

If that is the case, why is OS X so expensive? Froogle just returned this ' Mac OS X Tiger Family Pack... £79 - £142'. That's as expensive as Windows XP Professional, which isn't subsidised by hardware sales. :shrug:
The family pack is either 3 or 5 licences. How much would 3 or 5 copies of XP cost?
Quote:

Quote:

Originally Posted by LostintheNW
I have both a PC and one of those iMac which are taking a good old slagging off in this post. I love my iMac way more than my pc! the fact the machine runs faster, doesn't crash, or when an application does decide to fail it does not take the whole frigging OS with it, like Windows does!

Surely this should read 'I have a PC running Windows and one of those iMac...<snip>'..? I have a PC running Linux ;) and it runs faster than Windows, doesn't crash unlike Windows, and when an application does decide to fail it does not take the whole frigging OS with it... unlike Windows ;) ...or am I just being pedantic? :angel:
Can we get back to the topic please?

Damien 17-01-2006 19:07

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Excellent post! Macs are very secure (not one osx virus yet) and come with v good firewall but they are not 100% unbreakible as apples updates show.

homealone 17-01-2006 19:10

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Excellent post! Macs are very secure (not one osx virus yet) and come with v good firewall but they are not 100% unbreakible as apples updates show.

seems topical ;)

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4620548.stm

:)

Damien 17-01-2006 19:42

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
yeah,i recommend the site that he recommended earlyer in the post.

The important thing to remember is this: Macs Rock.

:)

Graham M 17-01-2006 19:47

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
I like the O/S, the hardware is kinda Stylish, sometimes somewhat tacky and not as upgradable as a PC plus the price is a bit of a wallet breaker.

Bifta 17-01-2006 20:45

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Sorry no, Where you refer to people being 'falling for more Apple bullsh*t marketing' then thats not a informed opinion.

Yes, I'm the clueless one, so were the ITC for banning apples advertisement claiming the G5 was "the world's fastest, most powerful personal computer"

http://www.out-law.com/page-4610

It's only people like you that actually believe the rubbish they churn out. (maybe someone should change the topic title from 'smug' to 'mug' just for you)

Damien 17-01-2006 20:57

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Yes, I'm the clueless one, so were the ITC for banning apples advertisement claiming the G5 was "the world's fastest, most powerful personal computer"

http://www.out-law.com/page-4610

It's only people like you that actually believe the rubbish they churn out.

Yeah. Again someone telling a mac user about macs.

I know about that advert and while it may not have been true it does not mean that there is a computer that was more powerful. That does nothing to back up the claim that macs are under powered. For some apps mac is faster, especially design programs. Photoshop runs much faster on my 1.33ghz g4 with 512mb ram than it does on the uni systems computers.

You can jump on every new story you can, it does not prove that macs are underpowered while I have not said they are the most powerful computers around so i 'dont belive all the rubbish they churn out'. Power in computing is such a misleading term.

I use windows and macs. I prefer macs, people can tell me all they want to about me using a rubbish, underpowered, system but I know what I am using (i also used to be anti-macs until I actually used them for long peroids) and I will continue to use it and I would like to point out that we are talking about software not hardware.

Stuart 17-01-2006 21:01

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Can we keep the Mac Vs Pc debate for another thread, and the arguements to PM please?

MadGamer 17-01-2006 21:14

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Quote:

Originally Posted by ScaredWebWarrior
Fair enough - just don't be complacent about it.

The Mac is not invulnerable, and you'll rue the day you assumed it was.

On the contrary, I run McAfee Virex on it, (even though the virus definitions it uses are almost entirely for PCs, just so I don't accidentally pass on a file that might infect you, even though my own machine is immune) so if any viruses do appear I'll get the definition files and stay clean.

I also ran a software firewall until I bought my router, which is configured to allow nothing through. Complacent I aint. :)

---------- Post added at 10:26 ---------- Previous post was at 10:21 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
But they're not better, the ONLY aspect of a Mac that's better than a PC is it's looks, it's performance is dire in comparison and the hardware is pretty much (other than the CPU, which is normally far less powerful than it's x86 alernative) the same as a PC's.

I have a six-year-old iMac, which runs faster today that it did new. It has 640MB of RAM (shipped with 64MB) and has had two major OS revisions installed since the day it was first switched on with OS 9.0.8 onboard. I'm now on 10.2.8 and am told that 10.3 and 10.4 both brought further efficiencies.

Which versions of Winblows can you point to that were leaner and faster than their predecessors? I thought I was led to believe that each revision of that OS demanded ever more powerful machines to run on? What are the expected specs for Vista?

I find Mac OS to be simpler, more intuitive, more elegant and just generally better designed than Windows. And seeing as the OS governs my day-to-day experience of my computer, I regard that as a pretty major plus point.

Man, I can see which way this thread is going ... :p:

I was told by my tutor today, what OS he preferred and he said 2000 as its faster. Seen as ive never used 2000 i cant comment on speed. But, Microsoft claims that every one of its Windows versions is better than the last. Somehow i dont think so. Windows XP all the way for me.

I know Macs can be powerful depending on what you are doing i.e. graphics work etc. But then again as ive only used a Mac once, for general browsing again i cant comment.

Paul K 17-01-2006 21:20

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MadGamer
I was told by my tutor today, what OS he preferred and he said 2000 as its faster. Seen as ive never used 2000 i cant comment on speed. But, Microsoft claims that every one of its Windows versions is better than the last. Somehow i dont think so. Windows XP all the way for me.

XP came after 2000 Wayne ;) If you are saying MS are wrong in stating that each evolution of OS is better than the last but are also stating that XP is better than 2000 then you are actually agreeing with MS ;)

MadGamer 17-01-2006 21:28

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Chris how did you get Viruex? Is it an oold version or did you get licences or what?

Norton is crap on the mac

---------- Post added at 12:55 ---------- Previous post was at 12:53 ----------



You are clueless about macs. Some of us here are actually using the OS and love it. Are you telling us we are wrong and you are right?

Sorry, but in case you hadn't noticed "mac" isn't an OS, and nowhere in my post did I mention anything other than hardware, wise up.

Well to be fair now it is MacOS X, so therefore it has the word mac in it.

---------- Post added at 21:28 ---------- Previous post was at 21:25 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul
Quote:

Originally Posted by MadGamer
I was told by my tutor today, what OS he preferred and he said 2000 as its faster. Seen as ive never used 2000 i cant comment on speed. But, Microsoft claims that every one of its Windows versions is better than the last. Somehow i dont think so. Windows XP all the way for me.

XP came after 2000 Wayne ;) If you are saying MS are wrong in stating that each evolution of OS is better than the last but are also stating that XP is better than 2000 then you are actually agreeing with MS ;)

Sorry i didnt make myself clear (i tend to do that), i havent used 2000, and went from Windows 98 to XP, i found 98 to be slow, and XP to be much faster. I dont like the way M$ say that each OS is faster than its predecessor, but at the end of the day its the users that judge performance and you have made a very valid point and i accept that :tu:.

SMHarman 17-01-2006 21:33

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MadGamer
I was told by my tutor today, what OS he preferred and he said 2000 as its faster. Seen as ive never used 2000 i cant comment on speed. But, Microsoft claims that every one of its Windows versions is better than the last. Somehow i dont think so. Windows XP all the way for me.

2000 was a quantum leap forward compared to W98SE, it would run on the same hardware almost as fast and was secure had a good filing system NTFS which MS are still using today and was networked. As I said earlier it runs on a Celeron 333 on 96MB of RAM and the laptop I am using here which is an antique dell laptop with an intel 82443bx pentium ii processor at 500mhz with 256 mb ram. Both these systems would never in a mililon years upgrade to XP but run fantastically on 2k by comparison to thier time on 98.
XP is a better user experience, thoug not much really. I tend not to notice the difference in use, round windows vs square windows.

Chris 17-01-2006 22:00

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MadGamer
went from Windows 98 to XP, .

On the same machine?

Damien 17-01-2006 22:42

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
On the same machine?

that is quite odd, XP takes more ram. XP is muuch more stable being the first home OS from MS using NT (expect the old awful Windows ME) . If yoou scale back the GUI it runs faster but still not as fast as 98. Much easier to use and more stable though

---------- Post added at 22:42 ---------- Previous post was at 22:39 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman
2000 was a quantum leap forward compared to W98SE, it would run on the same hardware almost as fast and was secure had a good filing system NTFS which MS are still using today and was networked. As I said earlier it runs on a Celeron 333 on 96MB of RAM and the laptop I am using here which is an antique dell laptop with an intel 82443bx pentium ii processor at 500mhz with 256 mb ram. Both these systems would never in a mililon years upgrade to XP but run fantastically on 2k by comparison to thier time on 98.
XP is a better user experience, thoug not much really. I tend not to notice the difference in use, round windows vs square windows.

I use the 98 interface with xp, improves performace :tu:

Graham M 17-01-2006 22:52

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Windows ME wasn't built from the NT Core, it was still built on DOS with most of the legacy stuff removed (half the reason it was buggy i reckon).

Damien 17-01-2006 22:54

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zeph
Windows ME wasn't built from the NT Core, it was still built on DOS with most of the legacy stuff removed (half the reason it was buggy i reckon).

That explains it

MadGamer 17-01-2006 23:12

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Quote:

Originally Posted by MadGamer
went from Windows 98 to XP, .

On the same machine?

No, we had bought a new PC back in 2001 i think.

Damien 17-01-2006 23:34

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MadGamer
No, we had bought a new PC back in 2001 i think.

well if it was on a new computer then it would have been faster....

ScaredWebWarrior 18-01-2006 08:14

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
On the same machine?

When I finally decided to move up to XP I simply 'upgraded' my Windows Me installation to XP.

Worked fine for over a year, until the hard disk expired (no connection to the upgrade, it was one of those Fujitsu drives) when I installed XP from scratch for the first time.

I had my doubts if it would work, but couldn't face reinstalling all the applications. Much to my surprise and delight, the process was simple and effective.

Chris 18-01-2006 16:13

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Bill Thompson's article has generated a lot of feedback - he's had another go today:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4620548.stm

Bifta 18-01-2006 16:21

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

I hope I achieved that goal, even if I did upset a lot of people who seem to feel that anything but fawning admiration for Apple is an act of betrayal by an apostate
It's good to see at least one Mac user who realises what most of the others are like.

Damien 18-01-2006 16:25

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T
Bill Thompson's article has generated a lot of feedback - he's had another go today:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4620548.stm

Hehe, I emailed him to told him I agreed with some of what he said. Ar well

BBKing 18-01-2006 21:05

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Quote:

(other than the CPU, which is normally far less powerful than it's x86 alernative)
I might have missed it, but did anyone point out to Bifta that the Mac is using x86 chips now? Before Dell and co. get hold of the new chips, in fact. Apple has just become worth more than Dell, too.

So, with Mac OS X being 'just another x86 OS' now, can we give the Mac v PC willy waving a rest for a bit?

I like BSD based Macs (pre OS X MacOS sucked the big one). I haven't got a Mac, I'll probably get one when I have a bit of spare cash/they bring out an x86 based Mini. I had two XP machines in 2001, I now have none. That gives you some idea of my view of the relative strengths, from the POV of someone who spends 8 hours a day on Solaris/Linux boxes.

Anyway, neither PC nor Mac runs on Sun's new T1 chip - now there's something to be seriously amazed by...8 cores per chip, 4 threads per core, one chip is about as powerful as 24 old ones and uses naff all electrickery to do it. Astounding. I'm going to play with one soon :)

* I have a Win2k box though, which is still a fine OS and does everything I want apart from play the latest XP only games, and I'm not spending £300 on an OS to play a £40 game so they can go swivel.

Damien 18-01-2006 21:10

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
I think the mac vs PC debate is always flawed since people always take the hardware angle when its the OS (and the fact they are made in snyc) that make the mac effective.

After all hardware can only go so far. It needs good software.

Macs are now using intel chips and so on. So hopefully the debate will settle and we can talk about what computers should be about and what the real user cares about and that is software. People want to surf the net, play games, use office and write emails. Not talk aboout their new core duo chip and how much GHZ they get out of it

Chris W 18-01-2006 21:25

Re: For Smug Mac Users....
 
Right, Stuart has already placed a warning in this thread about keeping on topic and it was completely ignored. Next off topic post will result in the thread being locked and poster being suspended for ignoring team warnings.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:08.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum