Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Security & Virus Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   sygate personal firewall pro ids (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=38430)

Chrysalis 17-11-2005 22:08

sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Ok I have been looking around for the right firewall for me, was using kerio 2.1.5 but for some reason it failed to log properly so I checked out the alternatives.

Been using sygate for a few weeks and all seemed very good,, but I have noticed 2 problems.

1 - It resets connections when changing rules or settings, I think this is due to the tcp randomizer (anti ip spoofing).

2 - When the intrusion prevention system is enabled (IPS) their is a marked increase in cpu usage as it inspects every single packet (sniffing), my lan actually managed to saturate my cpu quite bad and maxed at 30mbit as a result, and downloading at 10mbit of the net needs 40% cpu :Yikes: . So I disabled it and things looked normal again, but under the docs it seems the portscan detection and DoS protection rely on this setting to work but I can still keep them enabled. Is this the case or they are independent of IPS?

Anyone else using sygate and what their general thoughts are thanks.

TheBlueRaja 17-11-2005 22:22

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Invest in a good virus checker and stick with Windows Firewall.

Graham M 17-11-2005 22:44

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Worst...Advice...Ever (In a Comic Book Guy Kind of Voice)

littld 17-11-2005 22:47

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zeph
Worst...Advice...Ever (In a Comic Book Guy Kind of Voice)

OK then, what's wrong with Windows firewall?

The only thing I can think of is it does not protect outbound ports, which should only be an issue if you have a virus/trojan. That should only happen if you have no spyware detection software running.

Am willing to be re-educated on this point.

Graham M 17-11-2005 22:53

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
I just see it as the Chocolate Fireguard's Brother :)

nffc 18-11-2005 00:23

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by littld
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zeph
Worst...Advice...Ever (In a Comic Book Guy Kind of Voice)

OK then, what's wrong with Windows firewall?

The only thing I can think of is it does not protect outbound ports, which should only be an issue if you have a virus/trojan. That should only happen if you have no spyware detection software running.

Am willing to be re-educated on this point.

If your anti spyware protection isn't aware of it how can it be removed?

As for other issues. How about blocking legit things you don't want to connect, for example Media Player.

IMO, Windows Firewall is p*** poor because it only supports inbound protection.

TheBlueRaja 18-11-2005 10:11

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nffc
If your anti spyware protection isn't aware of it how can it be removed?

As for other issues. How about blocking legit things you don't want to connect, for example Media Player.

IMO, Windows Firewall is p*** poor because it only supports inbound protection.

And how would your firewall stop you getting spyware?

nffc 18-11-2005 12:54

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Quote:

Originally Posted by nffc
If your anti spyware protection isn't aware of it how can it be removed?

As for other issues. How about blocking legit things you don't want to connect, for example Media Player.

IMO, Windows Firewall is p*** poor because it only supports inbound protection.

And how would your firewall stop you getting spyware?

It doesn't, but unless it uses an ActiveX bolton or infiltrates another program, it will at some point want to connect to the internet... and ask your firewall for permission.

A firewall with OB protection only will not protect against this.

Personally I use firefox and when I do have IE, it's immunised with Spybot, SpywareBlaster and I have MS anti spyware running too.

Toto 18-11-2005 14:44

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

IMO, Windows Firewall is p*** poor because it only supports inbound protection.
No it monitors for new programs wanting access outside of your PC, well SP2 version does.

Its a simple program but certainly effective at a very basic level.

pedantic 19-11-2005 01:27

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
I have been looking at firewall's recently and stumbled across this fairly comprehensive list http://www.wilderssecurity.com/showthread.php?t=57655

Currently I'm using this one from the list http://www.filseclab.com/eng/products/firewall.htm having read through opinions on the forums there. It has a good set of built in rules, which include some for blocking a fair number of trojans. Also, it only uses very little memory, which considering it's features is very good indeed. :tu:

Regards.

Paul 19-11-2005 01:49

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Been using Winroute Pro for about 4/5 years now. I'm not even sure if this is still available.

Chrysalis 19-11-2005 05:43

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
On the subject of anti viru I have one installed but the auto protect mechanism disabled, simply because it kills performance. The best anti virus protection is knowledge and knowing stuff that you shouldnt be clicking on. I run spyware,virus scans weekly incase anything does slip through.

Yes I agree windows firewall is there because it is better then nothing, but its worse then most of the commercial firewalls out there.

littld 19-11-2005 10:11

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Ms Anti Spyw are and windows firewall are the best combination, IMO to protect without slowing your system down.

the more protection added, the slower your pc.

bumbumak47 21-11-2005 17:02

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
computer engineer with over 4 years experience use zonealram free edition best firewall ive seen yet and its free and use it along with avg anti virus ...noter best anti virus ive seen yet combination of them and adaware to remove spyware and a regestery repair program theres one those with norton system works called windoctore i think ..unfortunatly that ones not free but there are hacked versions out there for god sake dont use norton anti virus or firewall lthough that and antivirus hinder your computers performance and to be honest i realy dont think there that gud....

Graham M 21-11-2005 17:05

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bumbumak47
computer engineer with over 4 years experience use zonealram free edition best firewall ive seen yet and its free and use it along with avg anti virus ...noter best anti virus ive seen yet combination of them and adaware to remove spyware and a regestery repair program theres one those with norton system works called windoctore i think ..unfortunatly that ones not free but there are hacked versions out there for god sake dont use norton anti virus or firewall lthough that and antivirus hinder your computers performance and to be honest i realy dont think there that gud....

So...you work at PC world, right?

littld 21-11-2005 17:45

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
;)
Quote:

Originally Posted by bumbumak47
computer engineer with over 4 years experience use zonealram free edition best firewall ive seen yet and its free and use it along with avg anti virus ...noter best anti virus ive seen yet combination of them and adaware to remove spyware and a regestery repair program theres one those with norton system works called windoctore i think ..unfortunatly that ones not free but there are hacked versions out there for god sake dont use norton anti virus or firewall lthough that and antivirus hinder your computers performance and to be honest i realy dont think there that gud....

I have several years' experience of writing with coherent sentences. I particularly recommend Full Stops version 1, Commas, and the use of Capital Letters at the beginning of sentences. ;)

Graham M 21-11-2005 18:05

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by littld
;)

I have several years' experience of writing with coherent sentences. I particularly recommend Full Stops version 1, Commas, and the use of Capital Letters at the beginning of sentences. ;)

hehe I like :D Was gonna say something but thought id take the mick out of his arrogance instead :)

Chrysalis 19-12-2005 01:19

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
I am moving of this firewall now, although I like it the development has ceased and norton are killing it of to try and make their customers use their own bloatware.

Chicken 19-12-2005 01:31

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Toto
No it monitors for new programs wanting access outside of your PC, well SP2 version does.

Its a simple program but certainly effective at a very basic level.

How do you make it do that? The version I have (XP + SP2) only monitors incomming connections (and prompts you to allow/block access).

ntl customer 20-12-2005 13:07

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrysalis
2 - When the intrusion prevention system is enabled (IPS) their is a marked increase in cpu usage as it inspects every single packet (sniffing), my lan actually managed to saturate my cpu quite bad and maxed at 30mbit as a result, and downloading at 10mbit of the net needs 40% cpu :Yikes: . So I disabled it and things looked normal again, but under the docs it seems the portscan detection and DoS protection rely on this setting to work but I can still keep them enabled. Is this the case or they are independent of IPS?

Anyone else using sygate and what their general thoughts are thanks.

You think that's bad?

Last year I got a new computer and decided to network them up using a crossover cable so I could transfer files from one to the other. I plugged them in and started transferring files - and the connection was crawling along at 4Mbps, and the CPU on the old computer was maxed.

I thought it a bit strange, even for an old computer. The connection was a 100Mbit one between the two, and although I didn't expect it to go up to 100Mbps, but 4Mbps was, well, a bit slow.

So, I disabled the Sygate firewall operating on the old computer, and sure enough, the transfer speed shot up around ten times to 40Mbps. The processor usage went down, and I was rather shocked at how much the firewall slowed down the whole process. :disturbd:

Stuart 20-12-2005 13:14

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by littld
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zeph
Worst...Advice...Ever (In a Comic Book Guy Kind of Voice)

OK then, what's wrong with Windows firewall?

The only thing I can think of is it does not protect outbound ports, which should only be an issue if you have a virus/trojan. That should only happen if you have no spyware detection software running.

Am willing to be re-educated on this point.

If you use a firewall with only inbound protection, how do you know if you have spyware or a trojan that your Antivirus/Antispyware program is not detecting?

TheBlueRaja 20-12-2005 16:12

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
If you really want a good firewall, i would suggest look'n'stop firewall from,

http://www.looknstop.com/En/index2.htm

With the Phant0m ruleset.

You can read about both over here... http://www.wilderssecurity.com/forumdisplay.php?f=28

Small memory footprint and it does exactly what it should do - nothing else.

Graham M 20-12-2005 16:16

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Im not Scaremongering im just suggesting that a DECENT firewall is the best way to go :)

TheBlueRaja 20-12-2005 22:20

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zeph
Im not Scaremongering im just suggesting that a DECENT firewall is the best way to go :)

Yeah - i know - i edited what i said sharpish as it was unfair. ;)

AndrewJ 23-12-2005 18:55

Re: sygate personal firewall pro ids
 
I use Sygate Personal with AVG Free and unless your system is a celeron 333mhz 32mbram tin box... then you should not notice the resources needed.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:13.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum